5 ms·

What financial advice was that? That SVB was a good bank for Startups to use? It was the recommended bank by our Merchant Provider Stripe. Sure it’s easy to id

What financial advice was that? That SVB was a good bank for Startups to use? It was the recommended bank by our Merchant Provider Stripe. Sure it’s easy to identify poor choices after the fact.

DubiousPusher 4y ago
It seems like a bad idea to have a large amount of static cash sitting in an account unbacked by any asset, regardless of who is your primary bank. It seems to me, your financial advisor should've had a plan for rolling this cash through CDs or short term bonds and distributing it across multiple institution to decrease your exposure or at the very least increase your FDIC insurability.
- hizanberg 4y ago
  All our efforts are spent on improving our products, we've never sought any financial advisors and spent exactly zero time worrying about the liquidity of the bank we're with. Any funds left over from business operations are simply left in the bank they were collected in. But sure after knowing this event is possible and that effectively all small US Banks are at risk of a Bank run we'll be moving to a top 3 bank that's too big to fail, then go back to focusing all our efforts on improving our products as usual.
  - dboreham 4y ago
    > we've never sought any financial advisors No accounting firm??
    - hizanberg 4y ago
      Our accountant helps facilitate our tax obligations, they don't provide financial advice on our banking choices.
  - DubiousPusher 4y ago
    For your own sake, pay someone to help you with this. It doesn't need to be someone full time. You can use a consultant. You are not protected even with a big bank. Given the way the political climate has developed, if there's another "big one" even a fraction of this size of 2008, it may be politically impossible to wrangle another bailout. Your only protection is diversification.
    - hizanberg 4y ago
      No, I don't need to pay for an external consultant's help to tell us to spread our funds over multiple accounts to fit within 250k FDIC insured limit. If any of the top 3 "too big to fail" US Banks collapses we'll all have bigger problems resulting from the collapse of the US Banking system.
      - DubiousPusher 4y ago
        Cool. Suit yourself. You got lucky this time and are getting bailed out.
- ctvo 4y ago
  > It seems to me, your financial advisor should've had a plan for rolling this cash through CDs or short term bonds and distributing it across multiple institution to decrease your exposure or at the very least increase your FDIC insurability. Who do we hire to plan and manage this process to ensure we have adequate cash flow? Why would any small or medium size business take on this overhead? When some other part of the financial system endangers whatever mechanism we were using here, will you be back asking why we didn't just keep money in a bank somewhere? I'll be blunt: You're not that smart. You're not that experienced. You're not an expert on managing "FDIC risk" even if you read about it this weekend.
  - DubiousPusher 4y ago
    > When some other part of the financial system endangers whatever mechanism we were using here, will you be back asking why we didn't just keep money in a bank somewhere? No. The point is that a bank is better than a safe but that diverse assets are better than a bank. > You're not an expert on managing "FDIC risk" even if you read about it this weekend. Exactly. And this is why, if you have a critical business dependency you should hire an expert and not ask my advice which the parent poster did.
    - hizanberg 4y ago
      > you should hire an expert and not ask my advice which the parent poster did Sorry, who has asked for your financial advice exactly?
      - DubiousPusher 4y ago
        The commenter asked me what financial advice I thought was poor. > What financial advice was that? That SVB was a good bank for Startups to use? It was the recommended bank by our Merchant Provider Stripe. > Sure it’s easy to identify poor choices after the fact. My reply was purely in the context of that question. You yourself asked further advise here. > Who do we hire to plan and manage this process to ensure we have adequate cash flow?

What financial advice was that? That SVB was a good bank for Startups to use? It was the recommended bank by our Merchant Provider Stripe. Sure it’s easy to identify poor choices after the fact.

DubiousPusher 4y ago

It seems like a bad idea to have a large amount of static cash sitting in an account unbacked by any asset, regardless of who is your primary bank. It seems to me, your financial advisor should've had a plan for rolling this cash through CDs or short term bonds and distributing it across multiple institution to decrease your exposure or at the very least increase your FDIC insurability.

hizanberg 4y ago
All our efforts are spent on improving our products, we've never sought any financial advisors and spent exactly zero time worrying about the liquidity of the bank we're with. Any funds left over from business operations are simply left in the bank they were collected in. But sure after knowing this event is possible and that effectively all small US Banks are at risk of a Bank run we'll be moving to a top 3 bank that's too big to fail, then go back to focusing all our efforts on improving our products as usual.
- dboreham 4y ago
  > we've never sought any financial advisors No accounting firm??
  - hizanberg 4y ago
    Our accountant helps facilitate our tax obligations, they don't provide financial advice on our banking choices.
- DubiousPusher 4y ago
  For your own sake, pay someone to help you with this. It doesn't need to be someone full time. You can use a consultant. You are not protected even with a big bank. Given the way the political climate has developed, if there's another "big one" even a fraction of this size of 2008, it may be politically impossible to wrangle another bailout. Your only protection is diversification.
  - hizanberg 4y ago
    No, I don't need to pay for an external consultant's help to tell us to spread our funds over multiple accounts to fit within 250k FDIC insured limit. If any of the top 3 "too big to fail" US Banks collapses we'll all have bigger problems resulting from the collapse of the US Banking system.
    - DubiousPusher 4y ago
      Cool. Suit yourself. You got lucky this time and are getting bailed out.
ctvo 4y ago
> It seems to me, your financial advisor should've had a plan for rolling this cash through CDs or short term bonds and distributing it across multiple institution to decrease your exposure or at the very least increase your FDIC insurability. Who do we hire to plan and manage this process to ensure we have adequate cash flow? Why would any small or medium size business take on this overhead? When some other part of the financial system endangers whatever mechanism we were using here, will you be back asking why we didn't just keep money in a bank somewhere? I'll be blunt: You're not that smart. You're not that experienced. You're not an expert on managing "FDIC risk" even if you read about it this weekend.
- DubiousPusher 4y ago
  > When some other part of the financial system endangers whatever mechanism we were using here, will you be back asking why we didn't just keep money in a bank somewhere? No. The point is that a bank is better than a safe but that diverse assets are better than a bank. > You're not an expert on managing "FDIC risk" even if you read about it this weekend. Exactly. And this is why, if you have a critical business dependency you should hire an expert and not ask my advice which the parent poster did.
  - hizanberg 4y ago
    > you should hire an expert and not ask my advice which the parent poster did Sorry, who has asked for your financial advice exactly?
    - DubiousPusher 4y ago
      The commenter asked me what financial advice I thought was poor. > What financial advice was that? That SVB was a good bank for Startups to use? It was the recommended bank by our Merchant Provider Stripe. > Sure it’s easy to identify poor choices after the fact. My reply was purely in the context of that question. You yourself asked further advise here. > Who do we hire to plan and manage this process to ensure we have adequate cash flow?