3 ms·
> Do you think depositors should hire an accountant and economist to review their bank's balance sheet every quarter? Basically, yes, but without the hyperbole
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
> Do you think depositors should hire an accountant and economist to review their bank's balance sheet every quarter?
Basically, yes, but without the hyperbole - an accountant yes, an economist no. This is not that hard. Treasury management is a specific function of any company.
I definitely don't blame these startups for not being financial experts, but VCs absolutely should have been coaching their client companies how to manage their cash safely.
- mgraczyk 4y agoImagine what the world would look like if you got what you're asking for. Tens of thousands of extra dollars of overhead to open a bank account? To save literally nothing directly for taxpayers, and a few dollars per account for banks? I would strongly prefer to he socialized insurance and safety net in this case, and I'm a die hard capitalist.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoYou seem to think that the world doesn't already work like this. There are tons [1] of [2] products [3] that are offered specifically to make it easy to spread cash around at multiple institutions. And that in and of it self is beneficial, because it is essentially diversifying the risk of those deposits. Now, with what the fed has done, why would anyone bother spreading their risk around? 1. https://www.intrafinetworkdeposits.com/ https://www.intrafinetworkdeposits.com/ 2. https://www.wintrust.com/maxsafe.html https://www.wintrust.com/maxsafe.html 3. https://www.moneycrashers.com/cash-management-account/ https://www.moneycrashers.com/cash-management-account/
- creato 4y agoSeems like the FDIC is achieving the exact same outcome with a lot less hassle and overhead for everyone.
- naasking 4y agoI think this is exactly it. More and more this arrangement is starting to sound like the baseless justification used for US healthcare: a bunch of middle men milking value for little actual benefit. Addressing risk can be more efficient and we can make the system far more efficient by cutting out all of this overhead and red tape. As long as the banks are properly disincentivized in other ways from being over-leveraged and taking too much risk, this arrangement would just be much better overall.
- hellojesus 4y agoIt very quickly devolves to socialism, however. Without the incentive to make money, you lose market competition. Eventually it collapses to a handful of big players, but they are all extremely constrained by the government insofar as they are really one government run operation with different names. Suddenly all market efficiencies are lost and you end up in a worse position than the market originally presented.
- naasking 4y agoI'm not sure why you think the incentive to make money evaporates if deposits are assured.
- hellojesus 4y agoA bank makes money from deposits by making available a % of them for loan originations. If all deposits are assured, then either the bank cannot take on any risk, or they can take on risk with the knowledge that the gov will foot the bill for any loss scenarios. If the gov removes the potential for risk, banks will be free to make wildly speculative loans/investments, which will of course fail in time, causing the gov to tighten regulations even more until all profit is driven out of the game. Thus the gov would be the sole regulator of loans centralizing banking. Sure,maybe you get some banks that pop up and offer assured deposits by only floating operating costs from risk-free assets like treasuries, but then you're looking at pay-to-bank for economic times with unusually low treasury rates. Maybe I'm being hyperbolic, but it seems like a potential evolution when moral hazard isn't controlled.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]