3 ms·
Banks use deposits to extend loans to other customers. A narrow bank wouldn't do that.
by loeg 4y ago
Banks use deposits to extend loans to other customers. A narrow bank wouldn't do that.
- avidphantasm 4y agoCouldn’t the Fed just offer retail loans at the Federal Reserver rate, with maybe some kind of premium if inflation is high, or discount if inflation is low? What am I missing? Why do we need all these banks, some of which catastrophically explode every decade or so?
- loeg 4y agoI mean, you would be substantially increasing the size of government. The federal government currently employs about 3 million workers. The banking sector employs 1.4 million. To perform similar functions, the US government would need (at least) a similar number of employees. That is probably politically disagreeable.
- avidphantasm 4y agoThey would be employees of the Fed, not the Federal Government, no? Also, I am not afraid of a big government so there’s that. Also, they would be paid well, but not get insane bonuses, etc. so that’s a distributive plus in my book (i.e., less wealth concentrated in a tumescent financial sector).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- scrlk 4y ago> Banks use deposits to extend loans to other customers "Money creation in the modern economy" from the Bank of England is worth a read - it explains why this isn't the case. https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/quarterly-bulletin/2014/q1/money-creation-in-the-modern-economy https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/quarterly-bulletin/2014/q1/m...
- pgwhalen 4y agoThis is nitpicking. While that paper is a good read and important to understand how banking works, the parent commenter's point about how money creation works, and how a narrow bank would not participate in it, is valid. Deposits _are_ a source of funding that a bank considers when making loans, even if a bank does not "turn deposits into loans."
- lbsnake7 4y agoI have been reading about this topic recently and still don't really understand how 'new money' is being created. In a loan, the bank creates an IOU that didn't exist before and doesn't point to a stack of $$ on the shelf. But it does point to the bank, and the bank itself has tons of customer deposits. And if I take that IOU and give it to a car dealership who puts it in their bank, for the transfer my bank will take actual money from the general pool of customer deposits. AND I have to pay back the loan which goes into the general pool. So while specific money isn't earmarked, the IOU represents money that the bank has right? I guess a way to ask the question would be: if i were to liquidate all assets of a bank and call in every loan, would that be >= all customer deposits?
- rashkov 4y agoAlso been thinking about this. If you look at this article, read section titled “money creation process” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional-reserve_banking https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional-reserve_banking If I deposit $5 in my bank account, and then the bank keeps $1 in reserve and lends out $4, then they just added $4 to the money supply. I can withdraw my $5, and the loan-taker can withdraw their $4. This is possible because there’s a reserve pool of money which is not loaned out, and because people tend to just leave the money in their account. At least that’s my understanding. Happy to be corrected
- scrlk 4y agoFor a solvent bank, assets >= liabilities. Customer deposits are liabilities on a balance sheet.