3 ms·
Doing the stress tests isn't where the cost would be coming from; the issue is more about the distraction of making sure that compliance is in place. I'd draw
by roenxi 4y ago
Doing the stress tests isn't where the cost would be coming from; the issue is more about the distraction of making sure that compliance is in place.
I'd draw an analogy to having breakfast. If we legally required people to have breakfast every day, that would actually be quite expensive. It'd go from a reflex to something that has to be considered, we have to spend a little bit of time creating evidence that we had breakfast to satisfy the regulator, there'd have to be enforcement where parents check on their kids to make sure they have breakfast, situations where it doesn't make sense to have breakfast (eg, really excessive sleep-ins) now need big reworks to make sure that despite that someone rolls out of bed to have breakfast. The police would roll in and muck up people's life because they skipped breakfast one day due to illness.
It'd be a debacle. It is funny to even imagine what mandatory breakfast would look like if we tried to legally enforce it. It would be expensive, both in dollar figures and hours of lives wasted; no question of it. Just because the act itself is cheap and necessary doesn't make legal compliance cheap and easy. There is a huge gap between the everyday "should do" and the legal "must do".
- cjalmeida 4y agoThat’s an incredibly bad analogy. A more apt one would be lobbying FAA to give up pilot mandatory rest time for regional jets (eg. ERJs) as “they’d be too expensive compared flying with wide bodies 777”
- mym1990 4y agoThe issue is that you think making sure compliance being in place is a "distraction". This is like devs saying writing test classes is a "distraction", or having an infosec team is a "distraction", or having seatbelts in cars is a "distraction".
- roenxi 4y agoI feel that is an unfair interpretation because there was one phrase spent on the word "distraction" and then a long paragraph included comparing stress tests to breakfast. If you feel breakfast is unimportant then more power to you I suppose, but I disagree.
- mym1990 4y agoYou're comparing breakfast to regulatory compliance for the financial system. Just think about that for a second...
- roenxi 4y agoBreakfast represents something like 10-30% of of a person's caloric intake, it is much more important than regulatory compliance in the financial system. We could adjust to poor compliance relatively easily (we did without formal compliance regimes for centuries). You seem to be underestimating breakfast. This is part of why I like the analogy; something being important is different from whether it is a legal necessity. Making it a legal necessity is what brings in the complaints about costs, not the cost of doing the thing itself. The cost is in proving compliance under all possible conditions. The complying act, as the thread ancestor I first replied to noted, is often cheap and generally already done as good practice.
- Clent 4y agoAny analogy comparing requirements for a corporation with a human being is always going to sound ridiculous because you are comparing a legal entity with a person. A government is formed by people, not corporations. Corporations exist inside of a space governments specifically carve out for them. The mantra that corporations are people is political ideology.