3 ms·
Three thoughts: First, elites feel like losers because they define themselves as elite. "Elite" is a comparative description - better than almost everyone els
by AnimalMuppet 4y ago
Three thoughts:
First, elites feel like losers because they define themselves as elite. "Elite" is a comparative description - better than almost everyone else. But that's a game where you can't win; you can only lose. If you're in the top 10%, you know someone who's in the top 1%. If you're in the top 1%, you know someone who's in the top 0.1%. If you're in the top 0.1%, you know someone who's in the top 1000 worldwide. And even if you're in the top 1000, you still lose as you compare yourself to others: "He's better at law. She's better at mathematics. He's got better connections." If you define your worth by comparison to others, all you can do is lose, because there's always someone to whom you lose.
Second, it's both a rigged game and a stupid one. The elites have created a game of competing to see who's elite. And they wrote the rules, and they wrote the rules so that they win. That means that you get to lose. But it's a stupid game anyway. Take social status, for instance. If you crack into the 400 who rule New York society, then you get to attend a bunch of social events so you can feel like an insider. That's great, I guess, but... if you don't accept the premise of the game, then it becomes very difficult to explain why you should care about playing. It's like Santa Claus. Once you don't believe, people have a really hard time convincing you that you should believe.
And third, part of this may be because many people think they're elite when they're not. They've been given participation trophies, and told that they're special, but in terms of elite competition, they're not. Then they get out of college and run into real elites with 30 years of experience.
- vakadrayio 4y agoYour third point is quite solid. People support capitalism for only one reason—they actually really do believe they are temporarily embarrassed capitalists, just one job away from some Prince Charming mentor figure discovering their talent being “wasted” at the bottom and lifting them into the C-suite. In truth, of course, the system sees them as being right where they belong. This “overproduction” crisis is a war between the outer capitalist party and the inner one, the former being a powerless but once comfortable buffer class the real elite has decided it wants to try living without. Technological changes and globalization have led the actual economic elite to decide they no longer need a large middle class (outer party). This is not about overproduction. Supply isn’t changing. It’s demand going to zero that is creating the problem.
- lisper 4y ago> People support capitalism for only one reason—they actually really do believe they are temporarily embarrassed capitalists That's not true. I support capitalism because it objectively produces more wealth than competing systems. (But I also think that capitalism needs to be regulated. Capitalism is a tool, and like any tool, it can be used both constructively and destructively.)
- dauertewigkeit 4y agoPeople care about social status because it brings about opportunities in the same way that wealth or natural talent do. You can also choose to live like a hermit, but then if you ever need do anything that requires the involvement of others, you'll find it harder to pull that off. And beyond that, people derive their happiness and satisfaction from social fulfillment to some extent, and again here social status plays a role.
- analog31 4y agoOddly enough I've never met an elite who defined themselves as elite. In fact the only time I've heard that term is when it's used as a term of derision, typically by populists who are themselves, elites.
- TigeriusKirk 4y agoYou've never met an elite who has called themselves an elite in your presence. I promise you many of them define themselves as elite.
- analog31 4y agoThat's true, but we don't even call ourselves elites when gathering with one another. Literally the only time I've seen the word used, is as a dog whistle.
- antisthenes 4y agoJust 1 thought: Elites feel like losers, because they set high standards for themselves. High standards come with respective advantages, but also drawbacks. The end. The rest of details can be filled in by individual experience and standing. Some people keep raising their standards, and are never content. This means that even as their skill rises, they still feel like losers, because they keep moving the goalposts. I think everyone should aspire to high standards, but also find a reasonable stopping point.
- precompute 4y agoThat's a very plebian take on elite social dynamics. The truth is, if you ever feel like some social signalling is pointless, you've reached the limit of what you know about the social situation. True, most people at the top of the social hierarchy have very ego-motivated my-way-or-the-highway mindsets but most of these people are still pressed down by someone else that owns them for some thing or other. There's always someone on a higher rung ready to scoff at your progress. People that do reach the "top" often do it do the detriment of their own original goals and end up getting eaten by the process of reaching the top and either become spiders weaving social webs endlessly to some arcane end or get toppled off. Only the plebs have the luxury of relaxing without a care in the world. Also, doesn't help that tech is so advanced that assaulting our senses is now a question of "how often" and not "how". Of course, there's about ten different definitions of "elite" ITT and the article's muddy writing doesn't help either.