4 ms·
What’s wrong with giving teens work experience doing low value jobs?
by SoftTalker 4y ago
What’s wrong with giving teens work experience doing low value jobs?
- slater 4y agoWhat's wrong with paying adults a livable wage?
- ghaff 4y agoNothing wrong with it--whatever that term has come to mean exactly. But, as many SV companies have found out over the years as VC subsidies have dried up, there are a ton of services people want but only so much money most people will pay for them. Pick up and drop off laundry? Sign me up! For $50? Umm. Maybe I'll pass. Of course you see this effect where middle class people in developing countries have far more full-time help than all but the wealthiest do in the US and Western Europe. I suspect that in the coming years, we'll see far more self-service, automation, and some services that are pretty commonplace today becoming much more of a luxury.
- walkhour 4y agoIf the value of their production exceeds the living wage, nothing. If it doesn't, there's nothing the company can do but pay less than the living wage or fire the employee.
- matsemann 4y agoWhy are the jobs "low value", and why don't those who do them deserve to make ends meet?
- SoftTalker 4y agoNot all work is worth a living wage, and not all workers are in need of that. If you try to force that, the work will either just not get done or it will be automated, and more people will be unemployed. Experience showing up to work, following instructions, getting along with bosses and coworkers is valuable even if the work itself requires little skill.
- falcolas 4y ago> Not all work is worth a living wage. And there we have it. "I don't view your work as being valuable enough to justify you being able to obtain basic needs for yourself (like food and shelter), let alone a family. Now give me my frappe." Funny how we will still call such employees "essential" when it's time to force them to work in shitty and potentially dangerous conditions.
- SoftTalker 4y agoSweeping the floor at a factory is just not a high value job. Anyone can do it, and if you demand that they pay $40/hr with full benefits they will just buy industrial Roombas and deprive someone of a job he may have been happy to have as a first job or for supplemental income.
- ssnistfajen 4y ago>if you demand that they pay $40/hr with full benefits >a job he may have been happy to have as a first job or for supplemental income You are contradicting yourself here. Those two conditions don't occur at the same time.
- SoftTalker 4y agodid you overlook the "or" in my sentence?
- ssnistfajen 4y agoNo. Someone who's happy to have a first job OR as supplemental income is not going to demand $40/hr with full benefits in those sectors. You are using a completely hypothetical scenario to justify exploiting children.
- SoftTalker 4y agoOk I misread your conment. I was responding to those who seem to think that any job should be able to support a family, or should not be permitted to exist. Not supporting exploitation of children, dont know where that came from.
- giantg2 4y ago'Why are the jobs "low value"' Could be several different reasons that all boil down to supply/demand and leverage. In the article, it's claimed that many businesses can't afford to pay more, which is fairly believable for small businesses and for industries with global price pressures. The workers can't find better jobs, so they take whatever they can get. "why don't those who do them deserve to make ends meet?" They do, but society can't get it together to balance interests in a way that works for everyone (if that's even possible). Also, $15/hr should be fairly doable in a rural area.
- carlosjobim 4y ago> businesses can't afford to pay more That's what we should call a "Low value" business, which is actually what many businesses and entire industries are in the real world. Restaurants say they can't find workers, when the truth is pay and work conditions cannot attract workers. They say they can't afford to pay higher salaries, the response is "then raise prices". They say "then we'll lose our customers". Good! The business is not valuable enough and that means customers have to do without. There is absolutely no need to continue with low value economic activity.
- giantg2 4y agoYou seem to be missing the supply/demand and leverage part. Workers take the low value positions because they don't have an alternative. Not to mention the consumer culture of racing to the bottom. You'd have to fix those for the low value businesses to go under. Of course stuff like farm work and grocery stores are low paying, so it's not like they're just going to disappear.
- carlosjobim 4y ago> Workers take the low value positions because they don't have an alternative. I'd like to correct that with "they believe they don't have an alternative." Almost all of them can get a better job, and that's why they are leaving bad employers and bad industries. Information is traveling faster than ever right now, and people are waking up. Gone are the generations of older people recommending a young person to take a shit job. Instead they are getting advice from the middle generations who have already been burned to stay far away from these jobs. Even people at the bottom have mobility and will go where better opportunities are found. > Of course stuff like farm work and grocery stores are low paying, so it's not like they're just going to disappear. Farm work has been massively automated with tractors and harvesters, those jobs have mostly disappeared. Today but a tiny percentage of the work force are employed in farming, when before it was the majority of the population. Grocery stores have changed as well. When before there were clerks handing goods over the counter, now people grab their products from shelves.
- Ekaros 4y agoWhy not give them experience working in high value jobs? Like software. I'm sure with some training we could flood the market with very cheap front end developers for example.
- ssnistfajen 4y agoYou just described these jobs as "low value", so what valuable work experience can be gained for teens? What are the work hours like for teens? Is the work environment safe enough for teens? Teens aged 14 and above are already able to work relatively long hours under current child labour laws, so why are you speaking as if teens in the US are forbidden from any type of work? https://www.oshaeducationcenter.com/articles/child-labor-laws/#:~:text=Legal%20Hours%20and%20Jobs%20for,per%20week%20while%20in%20school https://www.oshaeducationcenter.com/articles/child-labor-law....
- thebradbain 4y agoThe industries that are excited to use child labor (which is what this is) are only doing so because they have a shortage of capable adult workers that want to work in the conditions and for the pay provided. Aside from the fact that most kids can’t tell when they’re being exploited, why should kids be the stopgap for corporations that not even adults want According to the rules of the “free market”, these jobs should either provide better conditions or working conditions or both in order to attract talent, because the issue is not an oversupply of capable workers, it’s less.
- ssnistfajen 4y agoOr in the case where passing the cost of better pay & benefits onto the customers will reduce demand of their products/services making continued operation unviable, then their business don't deserve to continue to exist. But instead of letting the free market sort itself out, they seek to exploit children in order to prop up their unethical and unviable business.
- thebradbain 4y agoThe industries that are excited to use child labor (which is what this is) are only doing so because they have a shortage of capable adult workers that want to work in the conditions and for the pay provided. Aside from the fact that most kids can’t tell when they’re being exploited, why should kids be the stopgap for corporations that not even adults want According to the rules of the “free market”, these jobs should either provide better conditions or working conditions or both in order to attract talent, because there’s plenty of workers— they just don’t want to work for the lack of return.
- thebradbain 4y agoI don’t know how what was supposed to be an edit seemingly posted a new comment, sorry for the dup
- ilyt 4y agoCoz you don't get useful experience from low value jobs. Also what's wrong with companies having to pay living wage instead of child labour ?