Did he give any sense of the best arguments that might be deployed on each side? The non-copyright people will point to recipes. The weights are ideas, not exp

Did he give any sense of the best arguments that might be deployed on each side? The non-copyright people will point to recipes. The weights are ideas, not expressions. A “simple set of directions” is uncopyrightable. The copyright people will point to the ability to extract significant chunks of copyrighted material from the weights. I find the non-copyright argument stronger.