6 ms·
First of all, even if the company you work for goes bankrupt, you're very likely to still receive your salary, as debts to workers are the highest priority in a
by tsimionescu 4y ago
First of all, even if the company you work for goes bankrupt, you're very likely to still receive your salary, as debts to workers are the highest priority in any bankruptcy case. So the risk to workers' livelihoods is being way overblown. Of course, if a substantial amount of your compensation was company stock, you may lose a lot on that, but that is par for the course with stock.
Second of all, the purpose of having a limit to FDIC insured deposits is to limit the government's liability in case of bank failures to small-ish depositors. A company thag has millions of dollars to deposit also has more responsibility to evaluate the bank they are depositing in. Perhaps they shouldn't keep money in the bank in the first place, but find other uses for them.
Note that the true FDIC insurance limit is much larger than the 250k that usually gets cited - since there are various facilities for business accounts which can take that up to a million $ or more (multiple signers on the same account, multiple types of accounts). Should be plenty for most startups to pay their employees' salary outright, even without going bankrupt.
- phamilton 4y ago> So the risk to workers' livelihoods is being way overblown If this were 2015 I would agree. But it's 2023 and thousands of software engineers are already struggling to find work after layoffs. Companies shutting down en masse because of SVB will soften what is already an employer's market for talent. This may hurt specific founders and VCs a lot, but total damages (in the form of a softer market for engineers) may hurt the average employee more, even if they aren't directly affected.
- mixologic 4y agoYou get your last paycheck, sure, but you still lose your job which is definitely a threat to workers lively hoods. It's even more of a threat if the whole sector you're employed in suffers simultaneously, as it becomes difficult to continue to be employed in that sector.
- JackFr 4y agoI say as a person who’s been laid off twice and worked for a company that went bankrupt — why is that my problem? Why should you get my money? (In the case of the company I worked for which went bankrupt — we were a fintech startup with a truly innovative and fantastic product. Our management made three bad decisions which led to our demise. Two were technical and would have been recoverable, the last was a strategic move which ultimately proved disastrous.)
- ordinaryradical 4y agoBecause you don’t make depositors responsible for banks’ mismanagement unless you intend to create a depression. Are you truly proposing that every time a bank fails we make everyone who kept money there take the hit? A return to the 1920s, eh?
- ryanwaggoner 4y agoWhy do you think the FDIC insurance limit is $250k instead of $250mm, or infinite?
- ordinaryradical 4y agoI will answer and you can answer this question: Why is the government involved beyond that limit in this case? Could it be they want to give the average person peace of mind while retaining the flexibility to handle a restructuring however they deem best?
- freeone3000 4y agoBecause the bank continues to have assets, and those assets will be dispersed to cover depositors.
- paulclinger 4y agoIt's because there is a cost associated with this insurance. It's not a bottomless pit of money, as FDIC pays out using the funds it collects from the participant banks and receives no funding from the government (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Deposit_Insurance_Corporation#Funds https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Deposit_Insurance_Corp...). I think it should be possible for the bank to get better coverage, but they should be paying much larger premium if they want insurance up to 250mm instead of 250k. I also think that similar to "FDIC insured" labels in bank branches, FDIC should require posting "13% of deposits are FDIC insured" to help assess risk for those clients that have uninsured funds.
- tsimionescu 4y agoIf things get dire enough, the government can intervene to protect workers in various ways (unemployment benefits, emergency housing, government employment - there are many options). No need to prop up the middlemen with free insurance.
- CharlieDigital 4y ago> with free insurance Taxpayer funded insurance. What I wonder here is how many SV CEOs and VC partners are down with Biden's proposed hike on the capital gains tax rate.
- grugagag 4y agoNone. They want it all at no cost. Should greed be fullfilled this one time around, then it’s guaranteed to happen again in a different shape or form
- ipython 4y agoNot exactly taxpayer funded: https://www.fdic.gov/resources/deposit-insurance/deposit-insurance-fund/ https://www.fdic.gov/resources/deposit-insurance/deposit-ins... > The DIF is funded mainly through quarterly assessments on insured banks. A bank's assessment is calculated by multiplying its assessment rate by its assessment base. A bank's assessment base and assessment rate are determined and paid each quarter.
- CharlieDigital 4y agoNot sure if that's going to cover the haircut that depositors are going to take with respect to the difference in SBC's asset values at liquidation. There is surely going to be some gap and the question is should the taxpayers be on the hook for that gap to make the depositors whole.
- anon291 4y agoUnemployment insurance is already available. California and all the west coast states at least will also give free insurance in many cases. There is little risk to being unemployed especially for a short term while employees slowly get their money back after the asset sales. I don't really see the big problem here. Svb still has substantial assets. In the coming weeks, they will be sold and solid portions of the money returned. If companies have to temporarily furlough people, they will still get a reasonable wage that most Americans live on.
- TrispusAttucks 4y agoThat definitely sucks but why should Americans who had nothing to do with the bank or sector fork over public tax dollars to provide a soft landing?
- mulmen 4y agoBecause it minimizes harm and stabilizes the economy. There are benefits to providing safety nets to people who didn’t have a hand in their own misfortune. Specifically those people get to continue providing value. The modern economy is not zero sum. Work creates value, it is in everyone’s interest to stabilize productive workers.
- TrispusAttucks 4y agoYour statement is out of touch with most American workers. Especially blue collar. Subsidize my class on the backs of the underclass. Let's solve the wealth inequality gap with more wealth inequality.
- mulmen 4y agoThe owners of the bank aren’t being bailed out. The FDIC is only paying back depositors. That is the working class. This bank doesn’t just cater to big bad VCs. When depositors lose their savings through no fault of their own the whole system comes crashing down. That won’t help blue collar workers.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mym1990 4y agoWhere do you propose a company with millions in cash keep that money if not a bank?
- tome 4y agoMy first suggestion would be as T-Bills. I've asked a lot of questions on HN in the past few days about this, and I'm still not sure why it was not standard practice. Why people in position of authority trust bank deposits after 2008 I do not understand.
- mcculley 4y agoIt is standard practice for many businesses. Managing cash is a tedious reality that most have not had to face thanks to zero interest-rate policy.
- dehrmann 4y agoWhat if there were companies that would manage cash for you? In all seriousness, you don't want small and mid-sized companies having to think about managing their cash. They have better things to be doing.
- mcculley 4y agoWhat I want is irrelevant. Yes, there are companies (banks) and instruments that I use to help manage cash. I know that every time I have too much cash in one bank account, I am at risk. It appears some companies are learning this only now. I managed cash flow of my business through 2008. I worked through the recessions in the 90s and 2000s. When I was young, I worked for an employer who had seen banks fail in the Great Depression. He taught me not to trust a single bank. Nobody should. Yeah, it would be nice if we had a well regulated financial system.
- roflyear 4y agoIf you're spending $500k a month on payroll it doesn't make sense to do that.
- i_love_cookies 4y agoWell I'm not getting paid the entire team was essentily furloughed (~25 ppl) No idea what's going to happen with insurance since some people were expecting I'm generally treating it as being laid off with no severance and looking elsewhere
- tsimionescu 4y agoI'm sad to hear that, but by all accounts you should be able to receive your salary on Monday, when at least $250k should become available to your employer (though hopefully significantly more).
- cowsandmilk 4y agoAt plenty of companies, 250k is not enough to make payroll.
- tsimionescu 4y agoSure, but the actual amount should be significantly more (a comment around was saying that any account secured with two signatures is ensured up to 500k, for example). And, it should be enough for the mid-month payroll of a 25-person team, which is the kind of company GP was talking about.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> 250k is not enough to make payroll Plenty of firms will buy the uninsured deposit claims at a discount. Taking the haircut to make essential payments is worth avoiding disruption.
- dehrmann 4y agoFor 25 people making $200k, you get maybe one payroll run out of $250k.
- idopmstuff 4y agoI'll probably get my next paycheck or two, but I'll lose my job. You're pretty clearly saying here that I should lose my job, along with many other people, because of the bank at which my company's cash is stored. > Perhaps they shouldn't keep money in the bank in the first place, but find other uses for them. I work at a small startup that's raised five million dollars. Not a huge amount of money, but obviously losing all but 250k would be extremely damaging. You're talking about concepts of fiscal responsibility here, but then you're suggesting that businesses should deploy virtually all of their cash and keeping close to nothing in reserve. Our founders are extremely fiscally prudent and purposely keep a very low burn rate, which is exactly why that money is in the bank instead of being used elsewhere.
- FartyMcFarter 4y agoI'm not sure your founders are as "extremely" prudent as you claim them to be. For example, couldn't they have spread their funds throughout more banks instead of putting their eggs in one basket?
- grugagag 4y agoApparently they did that on purpose to be better able get a view on the activity of the money they poured in. Someone on a different thread is pointing to the levers VCs had in SVB for this exact purpose.
- rmilk 4y agoExactly. If you’re forced to use SVB because of your founders, you don’t have a recourse on the bank. But there is also a risk question that companies are responsible for that I see is glossed over. No, you shouldn’t have to spread your business accounts to limit them to 250k. But you must know it’s not insured above this, just like a money market account is not a guaranteed rate of return or even guaranteed against capital loss. I’m just spitballing, but for example what was the rate on a “money market” checking at SVB versus other larger national banks? If it was much higher, it immediately indicates higher risk in a business checking account at SVB to get those rates. You can see this way back with the old junk bond / Lincoln Savings fiasco of the 1980s, or with 2008 MBS, or CD accounts in early 2000s.
- mustache_kimono 4y ago> even if the company you work for goes bankrupt, you're very likely to still receive your salary Spoken like someone who has no experience with bankruptcy. The rule of thumb used to explain this to an unsecured creditors, before this happens, is -- dude, you might get 10 cents on the dollar. Employees are rarely made completely whole. > as debts to workers are the highest priority in any bankruptcy case Secured creditors have to get paid first. Then after quite a few other priority claims (attorneys, trustees must be paid, domestic support, etc.) employees are paid.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Analemma_ 4y ago> Perhaps they shouldn't keep money in the bank in the first place, but find other uses for them. If this is the position you want to take, that's fine, but you need to own the consequences of that position. The point of the FDIC is that you don't have to worry about the credit-worthiness of your bank before deciding to do business with them. If that's not true anymore, then I'm pulling every dollar out of my local bank and giving it all to Goldman Sachs. Everyone else will do the same, and now you've destroyed small regional banks and make the biggest ones even bigger and more powerful. Was that worth it to "own the techbros"?
- dehrmann 4y agoThere's something the airline industry does where they don't compete on safety. They're all safe. You don't want banks to start competing on safety; they should all be safe.
- ekidd 4y agoNo normal bank is safe without government backing. Banks are inherently vulnerable to bank runs, because they work with money across different time intervals. For example, a hypothetical small town bank might turn checking and savings accounts into mortgages. If everyone decides to withdraw their savings all at once, the bank can't call all the mortgages due. So if everyone panics all at once, banks will fail. So we try to regulate the risks taken by banks, and we provide government-backed insurance. To be honest, the last-ditch "insurance" behind most banks is sovereign power. It has been a long time since companies have lost money in bank failures. Everyone has gotten complacent. The failure of SVB means that a great many people are suddenly seeing new risks. Come Monday, I expect to see lots of companies moving funds. And lots of banks hold government bonds that have fallen substantially in value because of the rapid changes in interest rates. I will be very happy if we get out of this with few bank failures.
- dehrmann 4y ago> So the risk to workers' livelihoods is being way overblown. If the company you work for suddenly goes bankrupt, you're much more concerned about finding yourself unemployed in a not-great tech job market than collecting your last paycheck. Don't forget how systemic this is. If your company goes bankrupt, it's likely a lot of similar tech companies also went bankrupt.