4 ms·
It does not make sense to let bank shareholders profit from having an implicit guarantee of federal taxpayer funded bailouts. The bank’s owners have to pay $x
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
It does not make sense to let bank shareholders profit from having an implicit guarantee of federal taxpayer funded bailouts.
The bank’s owners have to pay $x for buying FDIC insurance of up to $250k per account per person. If it actually costs $y > $x to insure for more than $250k, then that is quite a windfall for the bank owners at the expense of federal taxpayers.
- a13n 4y agoI’m with you that we shouldn’t make a habit of spending taxpayer dollars to make depositors whole. We should have better regulation so this couldn’t have happened in the first place. Banks should be required to manage their risk better. But in this particular instance taxpayers should want to invest in trust in US banks and dollars until regulation is corrected.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThis particular instance happens all the time.
- a13n 4y agotop 20 banks do not fail all the time
- lotsofpulp 4y agoWhat is the significance of top 20? And SVB was far closer to the 50th bank than a top 10 bank.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> We should have better regulation so this couldn’t have happened in the first place We do. SVB lobbied successfully to exempt itself from the Fed’s stress tests and Basel III, both of which test assets for interest rate risk and would have caught this problem.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- amalter 4y agoThere's no moral hazard if we pay out depositors and let the bank fail. The big "problem" in 2008 was that the bailed out banks were made whole with equity injections and then continued to grow. (Although the government did quite well on those investments). SVB is dead. Shareholders are getting zero. The losses are not being socialized. But because we don't want a bank run on every regional bank, let's make depositors whole.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoWhy even bother with the fiction and payroll of the FDIC and a $250k limit and FDIC insurance premiums if there is always an implicit taxpayer bailout? Obviously that insurance costs something, and the moral hazard is that both bank owners and depositors of banks with lax standards get to financially benefit from lower costs due to all federal taxpayers subsidizing their risk. Anytime taxpayers give money, they are tilting the incentives such that the risk of the loss being bailed out is now going to be underpriced, because it will be assumed a bailout is coming. If the goal is to have no depositor in the US ever lose any money, then the government should just give everyone an account they can transfer money into and out of. It will earn no interest, and no bank owners will profit from the taxpayers’ subsidy.
- junofan 4y agoThe FDIC does this as a matter of course with LSAs though.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoWhat is an LSA? Legal service agreement? I am not sure how it applies.
- zerocrates 4y agoLoss-sharing (or "shared loss") agreement.
- tome 4y ago