3 ms·
If the super long string on a Google doc is “security through obscurity”, so are passwords, 2FA codes, and ssh keys.
by ceejayoz 4y ago
If the super long string on a Google doc is “security through obscurity”, so are passwords, 2FA codes, and ssh keys.
- Nextgrid 4y agoOne persists in your browser history and is easy to copy/paste into the wrong place, the other is not (good luck copying a password field without technical workarounds such as changing the field type in the developer tools).
- NoZebra120vClip 4y agoA Google Doc ID (or Drive/Sheets/Slides) is a single identifier which denotes a resource in the cloud. It is a name; it is not intended as a secret. "Anyone with the Link" really means anyone. In fact, I would say that "Anyone with the Link" access modes are a hack and a workaround for people who do not have Google accounts. If you rely on privacy, use Google accounts. So if you created a secret, clandestine, world-readable, anyone-comments, blog post with the slug "http://example.com/correct-horse-battery-staple/ http://example.com/correct-horse-battery-staple/" would you really complain when someone brute-force or outright guessed your blog post? YouTube has "unlisted" videos which are unsearchable and unreachable unless you've been shared a link, but do people freak out when someone stumbles across this shared by others? Just because a Google Workspaces ID is a long, jumbled-up, base-64 string doesn't mean it is a password or a cryptographically secure secret. It's quite different. It's meant to be well-known by anyone who is intended to have access. The "Anyone with the Link" access simply relies on a circle of friends/colleagues keeping the URL to themselves.