2 ms·
The only CDs you can trust are those of classical music. The CD format is really allowed to shine with classical music and vinyl cannot come close. Having said
by globular-toast 4y ago
The only CDs you can trust are those of classical music. The CD format is really allowed to shine with classical music and vinyl cannot come close. Having said that, a good vinyl record will still sound remarkably good.
But for popular music all bets are off. There were some great CDs released prior to the 90s and a few here and there since but most have had numerous "remasters" issued since. Unless you know what you're looking for you'll probably end up with something crap.
It's unfortunately the strengths of CD (and digital in general) that become its downfall. CD will happily and faithfully reproduce clipping and other unnatural waveforms. Vinyl simply can't be abused to such an extent which is one reason it often sounds more pleasing to the ear.
- mrob 4y agoThis online database is useful for estimating how compressed something will sound: https://dr.loudness-war.info/ https://dr.loudness-war.info/ The DR score isn't a perfect measure of perceived dynamic range (e.g. the surface noise and phase distortion of vinyl can increase DR score without adding any musically significant dynamic range), but it's a good starting point. >CD will happily and faithfully reproduce clipping and other unnatural waveforms. Vinyl simply can't be abused to such an extent Ability to reproduce clipping depends on the high frequency response of the medium. High frequency response of good vinyl typically exceeds that of human hearing, so if you ignore the inherent flaws of the medium (e.g. low signal-to-noise ratio), it can reproduce clipping that sounds the same as CDs. However, this requires mastering at a lower volume, which defeats the point of the loudness war, so the only reason to do this is saving money by reusing the digital master. Many vinyl releases do this anyway. See: https://wiki.hydrogenaud.io/index.php?title=Myths_(Vinyl) https://wiki.hydrogenaud.io/index.php?title=Myths_(Vinyl)