3 ms·
The collapse of the regional banking sector across the country and possibly silicon valley as a whole is going to affect regular taxpayers a lot more than a few
by paxys 4y ago
The collapse of the regional banking sector across the country and possibly silicon valley as a whole is going to affect regular taxpayers a lot more than a few billions in temporary spending by the federal government. Doubly so because most of the funds are in risk free securities that can be easily liquidated over time. Remember that SVB is one in a long list of small to mid sized banks that made such investments in the last couple of years and now have to realize losses because of it. If left unchecked plenty more banks are going to have runs next week. The government's job is not to sit by and say "I told you so!" but do the best it can to prevent the iceberg from tipping. People forget that taxpayers made a profit on TARP bailouts and prevented the collapse of the banking system and the economy in doing so.
- muzz 4y agoNope. This is a commonly used scare tactic. Tan's proposed bailout is nothing like TARP
- jayparth 4y agoWhat is the difference between the two?
- muzz 4y agoWith TARP the government owned assets. For every dollar they invested, they could receive less, equal, or more than a dollar. Overall, they received more. Tan is proposing the backstop deposits. In this case, the govt can receive AT MOST a dollar for every one of its dollars. The absolute best case is a break-even on the investment (and the government eating the cost of administering the program)
- nmhancoc 4y agoHow are you getting to an at best break-even? Looking at the most recent 10-K (12/21), if you have more recent figures I’d be happy to use those: Total deposits: 173.109B Total assets: 211.793B Of the assets, those that the government would actually care about in a takeover: 13.8B cash 26.1B available-for-sale (presumably marked to market, so that’s supposed to represent today’s sale price) 91.3B held to maturity securities (these aren’t marked to market AFAIK, so this represents the value if they’re held to maturity not sold today) 73.6B in loans net of loss allowances Total: 204.8B There are also a few billion of non marketable securities and “other” which I left out. Granted, some of this has already been liquidated, but if the government paid out depositors one-for-one, and held the rest of the book to maturity they’d make 31B. That’s basically the same argument employed when stating the government “made” money with TARP.
- muzz 4y agoGood points > presumably marked to market This is the key-- not sure if we really know what is marked to market at what isn't > held the rest of the book to maturity That's like 8 years? and a gain in nominal terms but to real terms ie inflation-adjusted since a 2031 dollar is worth less than a 2023 dollar
- tomato_123 4y agoIf the securities can be easily liquidated then there's really no economic loss for these guys going under. The real economic cost of a bank run is the early liquidation of good firms. If all these small and medium banks just have to sell their liquid treasuries or MBS portfolios then no big deal. Whatever working capital they're providing is pretty straightforward for some other financial institution to provide. The rest is just transfers from one party to another, no need to intervene.