4 ms·
Groupthink on this kind of decision is usually a feature, not a bug. When you're a startup founder, you have to focus your efforts on the unique problem you ar
by simonw 4y ago
Groupthink on this kind of decision is usually a feature, not a bug.
When you're a startup founder, you have to focus your efforts on the unique problem you are trying to solve.
For generic problems like "which bank should I use" taking a shortcut like "the one my peers are using already" is generally a great idea - saves you from having to waste your time investigating options that usually don't make a material difference to your business.
- hyperpape 4y agoI think this is debatable. Let P = group makes better decisions than individual Q = there’s no downside to everyone making the same decision P && Q => yay groupthink ~P && Q => could go either way P && ~Q => could go either way ~P && ~Q => groupthink is bad I think we have pretty good evidence of ~Q though, and P isn’t obvious. Was SVB better than throwing a dart at a picture of major banks? I can believe it, but I haven’t heard a substantive reason. P.S I mean for “not obvious” to be load bearing. Upthread, someone says SVB is much easier to work with for founders. If so, maybe it was a reasonable decision. But if so, that’s on the merits (aka P && ~Q).
- simonw 4y agoI'm not saying SVB was better than a major bank (it looks like it wasn't). I'm saying that, had this situation not happened, defaulting to "what bank do other companies like us use?" would have been a perfectly reasonable strategy.
- hyperpape 4y agoIf you stipulate the risk of concentration away, I agree that groupthink is fine here, but I think you shouldn’t stipulate that away. Also, I’d really say that founders probably weren’t the ideal people to be thinking about this risk, VCs were. If you advise a portfolio of companies, you’re better positioned to think about broad risks.
- JohnFen 4y ago> When you're a startup founder, you have to focus your efforts on the unique problem you are trying to solve. When you're a founder, the unique problem that needs to be foremost in your mind is the business. You don't make business decisions based on "this is what everyone around me is doing". If you don't have the time, talent, or energy to get into the minutia of running the business, you do at least hire good people who are into that sort of thing. Good people who do things like analyze situations, determine best approaches, etc. > taking a shortcut like "the one my peers are using already" is generally a great idea No. That's a really dumb idea. Is that really a common approach in SV startup culture?
- simonw 4y ago> Is that really a common approach in SV startup culture? Yes, absolutely. As a founder, especially at the start of your company, you're responsible for _everything_. You need to figure out how to do product roadmap planning, and sales, and marketing, and hiring, and HR, and run payroll, and work with investors, and manage an office... anything that can help shortcut a decision that isn't fundamental to the unique opportunity your business is going after is very welcome. Where an established company might have a whole role (or even a whole team) who are responsible for selecting a bank account, you need to get one setup RIGHT NOW because you just landed your first investment check and you need somewhere to put it! Have you seen the TV show Silicon Valley? There's a scene in the first series where they've just landed their first cheque, but they don't have a bank account yet so they have nowhere to pay it in! This happened to us when we founded a YC company back in January 2011. We went to the Mountain View branch of Silicon Valley Bank because someone told us that they would know what to do with us. They sorted us out. We did not pause for one second to check who their Chief Risk Officer was.
- JohnFen 4y ago> As a founder, especially at the start of your company, you're responsible for _everything_. I know, I've been a founder more than once. You are responsible for everything. When it comes to the things you don't have expertise in, or don't have the time for, you need to bring in people who do. I wouldn't even begin to entertain the thought of starting a business without having an accountant and attorney at least on retainer. > you need to get one setup RIGHT NOW because you just landed your first investment check and you need somewhere to put it! Those checks don't come without you knowing they're coming, though. Surely you'd have already have made a plan for what you're going to do with them. > We went to the Mountain View branch of Silicon Valley Bank because someone told us that they would know what to do with us. You had no actual experts to consult about this?