3 ms·
The error in the “indirect effect” line of reasoning is that it assumes that nobody would’ve grown cotton in the American south if slavery hadn’t existed. Of co
by rayiner 4y ago
The error in the “indirect effect” line of reasoning is that it assumes that nobody would’ve grown cotton in the American south if slavery hadn’t existed. Of course they would have, it would just have been share croppers doing it instead. The north still would’ve gotten southern cotton, but maybe the supply would be somewhat lower and the products more expensive. British ships would still have been sailing around bringing that cotton to mills in Britain.
You have to look at the counter-factual scenario of what would have happened instead. And we kind of know what the counter-factual scenario looks like because European countries ended slavery and their economies didn’t collapse.
The “indirect effects” theory is so wrong that even Jacobin, who are actually socialists, wrote an article debunking it: https://jacobin.com/2019/08/how-slavery-shaped-american-capitalism https://jacobin.com/2019/08/how-slavery-shaped-american-capi...
You’re correct, Germany did have a colonial empire before WWI, but only for about 30 years. It was inconsequential to Germany’s economic development.
- selimthegrim 4y agoThe EIC was a major rival for talent to the British government. That alone should have given a fillip via competition.