3 ms·
Surprised the article does not discuss the much more impactful fact that Ivy’s coordinate to not provide merit scholarships. Columbia does a bit of defection o
by whimsicalism 4y ago
Surprised the article does not discuss the much more impactful fact that Ivy’s coordinate to not provide merit scholarships.
Columbia does a bit of defection on the side that is tolerated, but otherwise there are no merit scholarships for Ivy league students.
- ryukoposting 4y agoThis one has always been truly baffling to me. By all means, make sure that need-based scholarships are plentiful, but isn't great academics the entire point of the Ivy league? I was never going to make it into an Ivy anyway, but I remember learning about that system as a middle-class high school kid and thinking "huh, sucks for me I guess." Too rich for need-based scholarships, too poor to pay full price.
- camel_Snake 4y ago> but isn't great academics the entire point of the Ivy league? No, that is just branding. If these institutions were truly based on merit the legacy system wouldn't exist.
- whimsicalism 4y agoArguably. The legacy system exists to provide funding that can be directed to students of merit. It is also unclear the extent to which legacy programs influence admissions. Legacy applicants have higher acceptance rates, but we would likely also expect this in a situation where there was no preference for legacy admission.
- horns4lyfe 4y agoExcluding middle class kids is the point. The needs based scholarships are an obfuscation.
- sandkoan 4y agoThe Ivies and adjacent elite colleges are more than capable of giving out academic scholarships—they simply refuse to because that would lead to a race to the bottom in terms of how much money they'd be able to extract from top talent (who could easily negotiate colleges against each other for lower and lower tuition). And, from experience, Colubmia's defection hardly counts for much (which is why, I suspect, it's permitted): even their "prestigious" Rabi Scholarship yields no reduction in a mind-boggling $90,000 tuition—just a minute research stipend. They want to make you feel special while ensuring you still pay full price.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoThis is totally ridiculous; virtually all of the Ivies offer need-blind funding; if you're admitted, then you're going to get whatever amount of scholarship you need to go. You can look at Yale's details here: https://finaid.yale.edu/costs-affordability/affordability https://finaid.yale.edu/costs-affordability/affordability ... e.g. virtually all families earning less than $75K per year will get a full-ride plus a $2,000 grant in the first year. Are you seriously criticizing the Ivies decision to prioritize scholarships on the basis of financial need?
- whimsicalism 4y agoI think the parent commentator would reject that you need to pick between need-based and merit scholarships. I have no idea how it would impact spend and whether it would be sustainable or not to provide full-need & merit scholarship.
- riku_iki 4y ago> e.g. virtually all families earning less than $75K per year will get a full-ride plus a $2,000 grant in the first year. and some middle class parents with two kids need to sell house to cover tuition?..
- whimsicalism 4y agoWho has to do this? Like give me the finances you are imagining
- pyuser583 4y agoThis makes sense though - using conventional criteria, all students would qualify for it. Better to just offer according to needs.