4 ms·

I must be the only one here who downloaded it to try it out, because none of the commands work. See issue#56, I just get "abnormal end". It also hasn't been upd

I must be the only one here who downloaded it to try it out, because none of the commands work. See issue#56, I just get "abnormal end". It also hasn't been updated since 2021. The chords for guitar also are weird. It doesn't seem to be using traditional shapes, but is looking for available notes within a fret range. Which leads to difficult, basically unusable fingerings. The other functions would be very useful to have, if it worked. Maybe one day I'll write a similar CLI tool.

cyberbanjo 4y ago
$ bundler $ ./bin/coltrane ? Welcome to Coltrane 4.1.1 (You chose: notes) ? Which notes? > C E D F G A ? How to display? (You chose: Guitar) -> coltrane notes notes:C-E-D-F-G-A representation:Guitar [[ omitted ]] ? What to do now? (Choose with ↑ ↓ ⏎, filter with 'f') > 1. Different notes 2. Different representation 3. Go back
- mastazi 4y ago
  I don't really remember much about Ruby and I'm having a hard time $ bundler [... many packages listed ...] Using coltrane 4.1.1 [... some more packages ...] $ ./bin/coltrane zsh: no such file or directory: ./bin/coltrane $ gem which coltrane /opt/homebrew/lib/ruby/gems/3.2.0/gems/coltrane-4.1.1/lib/coltrane.rb $ /opt/homebrew/lib/ruby/gems/3.2.0/gems/coltrane-4.1.1/bin/coltrane Could not find [... many packages ...] Run `bundle install` to install missing gems. but I have just ran `bundler` above... help?
trane_project 4y ago
Yeah. I really wanted to try it but I couldn't get the commands to work. All the issues seem related to another gem written by the same author, which has not been updated since around the same time. Not knowing ruby, I can't really invest too much time trying it to work. :<
pedrozath 4y ago
> because none of the commands work The Readme had some outdated information. Explained better on the issue https://github.com/pedrozath/coltrane/issues/56 https://github.com/pedrozath/coltrane/issues/56 > The chords for guitar also are weird. It doesn't seem to be using traditional shapes, but is looking for available notes within a fret range. Which leads to difficult, basically unusable fingerings. That's a design choice on this library. I tried to rely the least as possible on lookup tables, dictionaries, etc, leaving things to be discovered algorithmically instead. It is a difficult challenge, but for example if someone decides to use an entirely different tuning, the software will provide. The software might also find chords that you have never thought about. What has to be improved here is the sorting mechanism for guitar chords. > The other functions would be very useful to have, if it worked Just try running `coltrane` and test it interactively.
- huimang 4y ago
  That's fair, thanks for updating the readme and making this tool. It works for me when I run it interactively, and I plan on using it a lot!

cyberbanjo 4y ago

$ bundler $ ./bin/coltrane ? Welcome to Coltrane 4.1.1 (You chose: notes) ? Which notes? > C E D F G A ? How to display? (You chose: Guitar) -> coltrane notes notes:C-E-D-F-G-A representation:Guitar [[ omitted ]] ? What to do now? (Choose with ↑ ↓ ⏎, filter with 'f') > 1. Different notes 2. Different representation 3. Go back

mastazi 4y ago
I don't really remember much about Ruby and I'm having a hard time $ bundler [... many packages listed ...] Using coltrane 4.1.1 [... some more packages ...] $ ./bin/coltrane zsh: no such file or directory: ./bin/coltrane $ gem which coltrane /opt/homebrew/lib/ruby/gems/3.2.0/gems/coltrane-4.1.1/lib/coltrane.rb $ /opt/homebrew/lib/ruby/gems/3.2.0/gems/coltrane-4.1.1/bin/coltrane Could not find [... many packages ...] Run `bundle install` to install missing gems. but I have just ran `bundler` above... help?

trane_project 4y ago

Yeah. I really wanted to try it but I couldn't get the commands to work. All the issues seem related to another gem written by the same author, which has not been updated since around the same time. Not knowing ruby, I can't really invest too much time trying it to work. :<

pedrozath 4y ago

> because none of the commands work The Readme had some outdated information. Explained better on the issue https://github.com/pedrozath/coltrane/issues/56 https://github.com/pedrozath/coltrane/issues/56 > The chords for guitar also are weird. It doesn't seem to be using traditional shapes, but is looking for available notes within a fret range. Which leads to difficult, basically unusable fingerings. That's a design choice on this library. I tried to rely the least as possible on lookup tables, dictionaries, etc, leaving things to be discovered algorithmically instead. It is a difficult challenge, but for example if someone decides to use an entirely different tuning, the software will provide. The software might also find chords that you have never thought about. What has to be improved here is the sorting mechanism for guitar chords. > The other functions would be very useful to have, if it worked Just try running `coltrane` and test it interactively.

huimang 4y ago
That's fair, thanks for updating the readme and making this tool. It works for me when I run it interactively, and I plan on using it a lot!