4 ms·
Wildly incorrect. The slave trade peaked around 11% of the UK economy: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-global-history/article/on-the-economic
by rayiner 4y ago
Wildly incorrect. The slave trade peaked around 11% of the UK economy: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-global-history/article/on-the-economic-importance-of-the-slave-plantation-complex-to-the-british-economy-during-the-eighteenth-century-a-valueadded-approach/DBB1225FF928C09689B3EEFCA8F66C55 https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-global-hi.... In the US slavery never accounted for much more than 5% of GDP.
Europe as a continent had already diverged from the rest of the world before the slave trade. The divergence of the UK from Asia began before 1500: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Maddison_GDP_per_capita_1500-1950.svg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Maddison_GDP_per_capita....
While the desire to pin European wealth to the slave trade is understandable, it’s self-evidently incorrect. For one thing Britain wouldn’t have ended the slave trade when it did if its economy was built on it. For another, European powers that never engaged in the slave trade or colonialism, namely Germany, ended up becoming wealthier than countries like Spain who did. Same is true for free states versus slave states in America. As to a third thing, the end of slavery wasn’t accompanied by major economic hardship in either the US or Britain. You can look at a graph of US GDP per capita and struggle to identify when the civil war happened if you don’t have axis labels.
- novaomnidev 4y agoThat gdp graph doesn’t show what you seem to think it does. For one, you can’t separate the UK from Europe, since the UK being situated in Europe traded the refined goods from produced by the raw materials found in their colonies and produced by their slaves with the rest of Europe. So we should expect it’s trading partners GDP also rise along with it. Even if they didn’t directly participate in the slave trade at the time (Germany). OPs comment is not “self evidently incorrect” in the least bit.
- l3mure 4y ago> The slave trade peaked around 11% of the UK economy As your own source states, focusing on this single number is overly reductive: > Any indirect linkage effects are not included in the quantitative estimates presented here. > The growth of economic activities directly associated with the Triangular Trade or the American plantation complex would in turn have contributed to the development of other parts of the economy, through backward and forward linkages to a host of other value-chains. For example, a growth in demand for maritime shipping associated with the Triangular Trade most certainly had effects upon the development of the financial, insurance, and shipbuilding industries. It has also been argued that these factors helped drive the development of docks in the ports of Europe. > In addition, it has been suggested that this would include fundamental shifts in institutions and economic structures. The growth of the Atlantic trade may thus have had other important consequences, for example, through contributing to institutional change in Britain, as Daron Acemoglu, Simon Johnson, and James Robinson have famously argued. > Activities of this magnitude can hardly be dismissed as marginal to the British economy at the time. -------- > European powers that never engaged in the slave trade or colonialism, namely Germany What? Germany was absolutely involved in colonialism. Slavery perhaps not in an official state capacity given the lateness of its formation relative to the Trans-Atlantic trade, but people from the region certainly were. > Same is true for free states versus slave states in America. Again this is overly dismissive of the economic interplay between North and South. The Northern textile industry was reliant on cotton grown in the South, and the South provided an important outlet for Northern goods. [1] > As for the lack of a home market, southern consumers generated a significant demand for northern-made shoes, clothing, locomotives, steamboats, farm implements--to name just a few products--that encouraged such promoters as Gregg and De Bow to believe that a market for southern manufactures existed if it could only be exploited. [1] Battle Cry of Freedom, pp. 97
- rayiner 4y agoThe error in the “indirect effect” line of reasoning is that it assumes that nobody would’ve grown cotton in the American south if slavery hadn’t existed. Of course they would have, it would just have been share croppers doing it instead. The north still would’ve gotten southern cotton, but maybe the supply would be somewhat lower and the products more expensive. British ships would still have been sailing around bringing that cotton to mills in Britain. You have to look at the counter-factual scenario of what would have happened instead. And we kind of know what the counter-factual scenario looks like because European countries ended slavery and their economies didn’t collapse. The “indirect effects” theory is so wrong that even Jacobin, who are actually socialists, wrote an article debunking it: https://jacobin.com/2019/08/how-slavery-shaped-american-capitalism https://jacobin.com/2019/08/how-slavery-shaped-american-capi... You’re correct, Germany did have a colonial empire before WWI, but only for about 30 years. It was inconsequential to Germany’s economic development.
- selimthegrim 4y agoThe EIC was a major rival for talent to the British government. That alone should have given a fillip via competition.
- orange8 4y ago> Wildly incorrect. The slave trade peaked around 11% of the UK economy: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-global- https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-global-... Thanks for the link, very interesting. Some quotes from it.. "By the end of the eighteenth century, the British part of the Triangular Trade alone incorporated economic activities equivalent to around 5% of the British gross domestic product. If we add the activities in the American plantation complex, as well as the industries in Britain directly dependent upon this (either for inputs of raw materials or for markets for output), the estimated figures show that economic activities equivalent to around 11% of British GDP were directly involved in or associated with the Triangular Trade and the American plantation complex. Activities of this magnitude can hardly be dismissed as marginal to the British economy at the time." Note that this 11% is only at the end of the 18th century. Just a snapshot of a trade that started in the 15th century. "The transatlantic slave trade did have intimate connections to several European economies, but the consequences have also been fiercely debated." They say "fiercely debated", you say "wildly incorrect". Do you actually read the sources you link to? "One important reason for this focus on Britain was no doubt the publication of Eric Williams’ much-cited book Capitalism and slavery, first published in 1944." Someone actually wrote a whole book about it! That's how deep the subject is. I remember watching a 1 hour lecture on you tube, where this professor argued that the trans-Atlantic slave trade is actually what made Europe and economic powerhouse. Something about a combination of good timing and location. If you have any alternative theory of what powered Europe's economic growth in the 18th century, let me know. My take, it was not much different from what powered the roman empire and many other economic powerhouses going thousands of years back. "The assumptions underlying such counterfactual models can be quite controversial. For instance, the American plantation complex might seem unimportant as a supplier of cotton and other plantation crops, if one assumes a very high elasticity of supply of these crops in other parts of the world, and declining costs of maritime transport. In his recent book Empire of cotton, Sven Beckert has essentially argued against making such an assumption. In his view, the coercion involved in the expansion of the American plantation complex was the key ‘that opened fresh lands and mobilized new labor, becoming the essential ingredient of the emerging empire of cotton – and thus an essential ingredient in forging industrial capitalism’." Another book! This one is more about America though, and the influence of the cotton industry, powered by slaves. Not sure how those GDP calculations from the 1800s you quoted were arrived at, but I'm certain an "essential ingredient in forging industrial capitalism" is not 5%.