6 ms·
Wild macaques challenge the origin of intentional tool production
- jjtheblunt 4y agoinstead of decades of "who uses tools" maybe it would be more modern to consider what cognitive requirements exist for dreaming up using tools, in some more rigorous manner, perhaps mathematical.
- AlotOfReading 4y agoAnthropologists have been trying to do that for decades, beginning with chaînes opératoires approaches in the 70s, to Haidle's cognigram approach ([0]), to the explicitly comp-sci inspired approaches like Perrault's [1]. They tend to suffer from the same set of issues, namely that they tend to be difficult to consistently apply within reasonable epistemological frameworks and unspecific in their arguments/predictions. Even when you have those, you still need to ground-truth things with the material record of "who was using tools when", so the kind of work discussed in the linked article remains valuable. [0] https://doi.org/10.1017/S095977431200025X https://doi.org/10.1017/S095977431200025X [1] https://doi.org/10.1086/673264 https://doi.org/10.1086/673264
- mkl 4y agoEven if you had rigorous knowledge of the cognitive requirements, how would you verify its accuracy without going out and seeing who uses tools? How would you identify species meeting the cognitive requirements without seeing who uses tools (even if only in an artificial puzzle-solving context)?
- jjtheblunt 4y agogood questions, i agree!
- pbj1968 4y agoMacaques are the true under-appreciated menace. You’re quick to let your guard down because they’re not a chimp or gorilla, but you will regret it.
- rqtwteye 4y agoI remember in Cambodia they stole water from female tourists. And if somebody confronted them you had to be very careful to not get bitten. In a sense they reminded me of humans. I bet we would also be very crafty and annoying if we were held as pets or another more intelligent species took over the world.
- kibwen 4y agoThe headline makes it sound like the theory was refuted, but the abstract instead makes it sound like the evidence that we have has been called into question. So it's not that anything has been disproven, it's just that we no longer trust the evidence we have.
- mkl 4y agoHas the headline changed? It's currently "Wild macaques challenge the origin of intentional tool production", which doesn't imply anything is disproven, just that evidence is called into question.
- _qua 4y agoI noticed there seemed to be unnecessary use of jargon in the abstract. I asked ChatGPT to rewrite it in plain English and I think it did a pretty good job: The sharp-edged stone flakes and flaked pieces that our ancestors intentionally made are important evidence of the development of technology in our lineage. This evidence helps us understand how early humans behaved, thought, and survived. In this study, we talk about a large collection of sharp-edged stones found near areas where long-tailed macaques were foraging for food. These stones are almost identical to the ones early humans made, which suggests that the macaques unintentionally produced them while searching for food. When we compare these stones to ones made by early humans millions of years ago, we find that they are very similar. If we didn't know that the macaques made these stones accidentally, we might think that they were made by early humans.
- unclesaamm 4y agothat's great, thanks for sharing! (though I'm not enough of a domain expert to know if it's accurate) another solution to this would be if Science Advances were to require submissions to provide a "Significance Statement", like PNAS does, which would be essentially at the level of readability you provided.
- t-3 4y agoI feel like the detail of "conchoidal edges" is important for the abstract, as it gives a good idea of how the edges look and why/how they are being unintentionally made. A search/replace of "lithic assemblage" to "stone tools" would accomplish much the same as your summary without losing any of the details.
- Retric 4y agoIt’s interesting just how bad of a summery that is compared to the human created abstract included in the text. “It is now clear that the production of unintentional conchoidal sharp-edged flakes can result from tool-assisted foraging in nonhominin primates. Comparisons with Plio-Pleistocene lithic assemblages, dating from 3.3 to 1.56 million years ago, show that flakes produced by macaques fall within the technological range of artifacts made by early hominins. In the absence of behavioral observations, the assemblage produced by monkeys would likely be identified as anthropogenic in origin and interpreted as evidence of intentional tool production.”