4 ms·
Fascinating. Did some extra reading from Buganda wikipedia page. Like most (all?) cultures/civilizations, the circle of empathy excluded humans on the periphery
by andsoitis 4y ago
Fascinating. Did some extra reading from Buganda wikipedia page. Like most (all?) cultures/civilizations, the circle of empathy excluded humans on the periphery:
Before the arrival of Europeans in the region, Buganda was an expanding, "embryonic empire".[12] It built fleets of war canoes from the 1840s to take control of Lake Victoria and the surrounding regions and subjugated several weaker peoples. These subject peoples were then exploited for cheap labor.[12] The first Europeans to enter the Kingdom of Buganda were British explorers John Hanning Speke and Captain Sir Richard Francis Burton while searching for the headwaters of the Nile in 1862. They found a highly organized political system which was marred, however, by the ongoing practice of mass human sacrifice estimated at 800 persons annually.
- gostsamo 4y agoSo, just like any empire at the time.
- mc32 4y agoPretty much, except for the frivolous human sacrifice aspect.
- gostsamo 4y agoYes, the random genocides in the name of progress or capital gain are totally different. I'm sure that the starving irish, native americans, and asians who were caught in the opium wars died with grateful appreciation that there were no priests around to oversight their expeditious sending to the afterlife.
- irrational 4y agoI don’t know why you are being downvoted. Whether it is ritualistic human sacrifice or pushing native Americans onto reservations, it is all versions of trading human lives for our own benefit. This takes many forms from the person who uses another person’s body for their own sexual gratification to wage theft to murdering people in a ritualistic setting to curry a God’s favor. It is all about how can I use others (other’s time, bodies, possessions, lives, etc.) to get gain for myself.
- nhchris 4y ago[flagged]
- gostsamo 4y agoThink about the GP comment though: "they've had achieved statehood with a complex society, but they were killing people for religious reasons". And the religious reasoning underpinned a major part of the colonial effort.
- kortilla 4y agoAnd colonialism is appropriately panned for it. What’s your point?
- gostsamo 4y agoIt is like you did not read the first sentence of the comment that you are replying to. I'll repeat it in another form: the gp implied that human sacrifice is sufficient enough to discard any other achievement of the society in question. I argue that the value of human life at the time was rather conditional matter. The rest of the debate is quantity and quality, and people who prefer to draw semi-arbitrary lines in the sand.
- kortilla 4y ago>the gp implied that human sacrifice is sufficient enough to discard any other achievement of the society in question No they didn’t. You’re just not used to seeing criticism leveled at other things. Something can be simultaneously flawed and quite impressive.
- l3mure 4y ago> never comes up An absurd assertion, it's a staple of discussions on here. Takes all of 5 seconds to find examples. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33811795 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33811795 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32973297 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32973297 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32338743 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32338743
- orange8 4y agoLook up king Leopold of Belgium if you're looking for a less "frivolous human sacrifice" aspect during that time period. Humans have a strange thirst for blood, whether its for religion or money.
- rajin444 4y ago[flagged]
- notahacker 4y agoAh yes, just as it would be wrong to single out Hitler for capitalising on latent anti-Semitism that already existed, and the real problem with WWII is that Germany wasn't successful enough in its expansion to prevent pogroms... Leopold introduced a policy of paying his (non-native) soldiers based on the number of severed hands produced, FFS. I doubt the kingdoms that existed beforehand were wonderful places that never arbitrarily killed anyone, but you absolutely can blame him for paying bounties for evidence of sufficiently prolific indiscriminate killing/maiming, and generally being one of the most despicable humans to have ever lived.
- orange8 4y agoHe did introduce it. Rubber was not traded or even heard of in the Congo until the Belgians arrived. > Pygmies are still eaten in the congo today. LOl! There are no Pymies in Congo. Pygmies are from the CONGO BASIN, not CONGO. But I wouldn't expect someone who still believes in old proganda stories from the 1800s to know anything about the continents geography. Do you have any proof of pygmy cannibalism?
- scythe 4y agoChina banned human sacrifice in -384 (Duke Xian of Qin). Rome banned it in -97, which was inherited by the Christian and Islamic traditions. The Northern Crusades around +1000 eradicated it in the Scandinavian / Baltic region; the Spaniards banned it in the Americas in the 1500s. Buddhism (ca. -500) and Jainism (ca. -3000 or earlier) prohibited it among their followers, which gradually spread to most of India (ahimsa), though reports of cult sacrifices (Shaktiism) persist until the early colonial period. So I wouldn't say it was particularly common in the 19th century.
- gostsamo 4y agoAt the same time, making sure that those with the wrong religion and/or skin tone would die rather easily was still accepted practice of the time. I my other comment I gave a few examples how mass casualty policies were introduced with the more or less implicit understanding that people will die in the millions. This is like the difference between white-collar crimes and those of the poor - the punishment matches how graphic it is, not its overall effect because the causality chain obviously washes out the responsibility.
- lazyninja987 4y ago[dead]