3 ms·
if your work is honest if you work for advertising then your work isn't honest. it's like saying being a janitor for a crime syndicate is honest work. either
by em-bee 4y ago
if your work is honest
if you work for advertising then your work isn't honest.
it's like saying being a janitor for a crime syndicate is honest work.
either way, your salary is coming from a dishonest source.
- ramijames 4y agoExactly. If you're a cook for an army who is pillaging and destroying, you are still contributing to destruction while making soup.
- _8j50 4y agoNo you're not. You got paid to feed people. Only those make decisions with intent are responsible for the outcome of those decisions. If the army is doing something wrong then you must actively stop them, not quietly say you won't cook for them lol. If it was that clear that which war rarely is. The strawman you and others are using is crime ot war or something but the subject here is a legitimate corporate entity. Make the activity you disagree with illegal first before comparing advertisers to a pillaging army. My point is, don't work for a company you don't like but don't you dare take this high and mighty morally superior attitude when others work at those legitimate companies so they can make a living. You cancel and judge instead of vote and convince others.
- em-bee 4y agoif as individuals we want to make this world a better place then we need to take responsibility for our lives and the influence we have that goes beyond earning a paycheck. if your moral attitude is so low that you don't care what your employer does, as long as it is legal, then you are not making a positive contribution to this world. i won't cancel you, but it's also unlikely that we would be friends.
- _8j50 4y agoI agree we can't be friends because you would sacrifice your friends and family for a cause. You do not understand your basic moral obligations as a human, that a world better off by sacrificing those who need you or even yourself is a world built by unneccesary sacrifice. You would introduce more suffering into the world when you have tools like democracy and free speech that were paid for by ages of suffering and anguish that have made that unnecesary. You will cause yourself and others to suffer all while not solving the actual problem or making the world better one iota. You would alienate anyone that you need to convince to make change happen so you can feel morally superior. You do not understand that the many rights and betternments you enjoy now was built by people working at places they did not approve of, using their position and power to make change happen. You do not undersrand your contribution into the social divide today that is making the world much worse in every way you can imagine. Not just I but many others are also not your friends and cannot even begin to have discourse with you to have our opinions changed because you have erected barriers of moral outrage and socio-economical activism that forces others to be with or against you. It could be adverising, fossil fuels, finance, insurance, military and this is just for employement we are talking about lol. A house divided is what you have contributed. Witness the not standing part.
- em-bee 4y agoyou would sacrifice your friends and family for a cause there is a difference between avoiding people i don't like and abandoning friends or family. you are making a claim that has no basis in reality. i stay away from people who are primarily materialist, so those would never become friends to begin with. the special case that a friend suddenly turns materialist is unlikely to happen. my basic moral obligation as a human is to make a positive contribution to the world. i can't see how i can make a positive contribution to someone who is materially oriented, but there is no need, because i get to choose how and who i contribute to. there is no obligation to work with anyone specific except my parents and my children (and siblings) but you can rest assured that my conviction here is how i grew up so everyone in my immediate family is similarly oriented. there is no risk of abandoning any of them. You would alienate anyone that you need to convince to make change happen so you can feel morally superior i am not alienating anyone. i am staying away from people who try to push their worldview on me like you are doing now. i am holding my ground on my beliefs, but you try to keep telling me that i am wrong. i am not trying to feel morally superior. i am just trying to explain that i reject your moral basis.
- nske 4y agoIn general I dislike advertising industry, just like I dislike the banking industry, or the gambling industry, but I think the comparison to a crime syndicate is not a good one. The difference is that the existence of both is within the boundaries that are specified by law, which is the most objective mechanism that we have to define something as honest. I don't think the law is always right, but it's got to count for a bit more than each individual's subjective morals. Because in principle it tries to break down things and isolate exactly what is problematic, which is something we're not doing when we pass general judgement in the form of an opinion. Wouldn't you agree for example that collecting and analysing user data for purposes of displaying relevant advertisements doesn't have to be dishonest, if the users consented to it? Maybe then the problem becomes that some methods of obtaining user consent are not honest -which would mean that there could be methods that are honest, and companies that can follow them. And if the subject is so nuanced then maybe it's not fair to say that an employee that simply wants to work in their domain of expertise doesn't do honest work, just for failing to set more strict standards than the law with regards to their employer's activities.
- em-bee 4y agoi didn't mean to equate advertising with a crime syndicate, just that dishonest is dishonest, and obviously there are different degrees of how bad something is. there may be some honest and fair advertising, but a lot is deception, and maybe an ad platform isn't dishonest by itself but they are enabling deceptive advertisers. Wouldn't you agree for example that collecting and analysing user data for purposes of displaying relevant advertisements doesn't have to be dishonest, if the users consented to it? no, because the majority of people do not understand what they are consenting to and when they consent they have no way to verify that the data is actually used in a fair and honest way. to elaborate: people need to be protected from sharing personal data against their own will. say for example you share your address. and then somewhere on a public forum you indicate that i am your neighbor. suddenly you shared my address too, against my will. therefore i have an interest to stop you from sharing your address. people do not and can not understand the consequences of consenting to share their data, because the ways to abuse that data are way to complex and subtle.
- _8j50 4y ago> it's like saying being a janitor for a crime syndicate is honest work. If the crime syndicate is legal? Yeah, that's exactly what I am saying. Your hypocrisy amuses me, are you telling me you would starve and let your familu starve rather working for a legitimate company because instead of voting to make thay illegal you chose starvation? Or is your claim that because other people are not actually starving, the suffering and hardship they and theirs endure is tolerable? People work to live. If you're going to play the indirect moral culpability game then by simply being a voting age adult you are morally culpable for everything the US government does and everything it refuses to do (including regulate ad business lol). And how much of your tax money went to weapons that kill someone else's innocent child continents away? So why do you pay tax? Shouldn't you be refusing to pay tax or is prison the line in the sand you won't cross? Unlike democracies, corporations do not derive their authority from their subjects, their authority comes from their owners. Only those with the authority to make decisions are culpable for those decisions. Hitler's janitor is not responsible for the holocaust.
- em-bee 4y agoare you telling me you would starve and let your familu starve rather working for a legitimate company that's not fair because most of the times you have the choice to work for another company. i do refuse to work for google or microsoft or other companies if i have a choice, but if i had no choice i would accept their offer. it's a matter of degree and opportunity. by simply being a voting age adult you are morally culpable for everything the US government does and everything it refuses to do yes, you are. i don't blame my american friends for being american, but i do listen carefully which activities of their country they support, and which they reject. unsurprisingly most of my american friends agree with me on many issues. i do keep an open mind though if they disagree. obviously as an individual we have little power to make a visible change on things we disagree with, therefore i consider it sufficient to focus on one particular aspect where one can make a small contribution. but if your attitude is that you don't care what your government (or employer) is doing, as long as you get your paycheck, then we will likely not become friends. in fact we are more likely to become friends if we disagree on issues but are able to have honest and open debates about that. So why do you pay tax? first of all, refusing to pay tax won't change anything. if i want to change my country i do need to be a lawful citizen and try to influence my peers until we have a majority that will be able to influence the country to stop spending taxes on such things. Unlike democracies, corporations do not derive their authority from their subjects, their authority comes from their owners which is why i prefer cooperatives. Only those with the authority to make decisions are culpable for those decisions disagree. following the orders of your superiors does make you culpable if those orders turn out to be illegal or cause harm, and you knew that they would cause harm. Hitler's janitor is not responsible for the holocaust hitler's janitor was most likely carefully selected as a trustworthy person, and probably would not have been a person that i would have liked to be friends with.