7 ms·
Why are banks even allowed to buy assets? Every asset is a risk. Banks should have right to do exactly two things. Keep their customers saving and issue loans.
by scotty79 4y ago
Why are banks even allowed to buy assets?
Every asset is a risk. Banks should have right to do exactly two things. Keep their customers saving and issue loans. There's plenty of risks even in that activity. Every other thing bank does is just piling up risk to unreasonable levels.
- nemo44x 4y agoI think this was a weird thing where deposit demand was so much greater than loan demand. They had too much money and thought they were doing a safe thing. But failed to consider the time aspect and how rapid interest rate increases nuke them. Banks do provide a valuable service and having them reject deposits isn’t a solution.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoI have literally no idea what the treasury people at SVB could have been thinking.
- nemo44x 4y agoProbably about their bonus.
- scotty79 4y agoInvesting money is never a safe thing. They should just sit on it.
- Mimlitsch 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glass%E2%80%93Steagall_legislation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glass%E2%80%93Steagall_legisla...
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoGlass-Steagall only prevented commercial banks from owning non-investment-grade securities - from what I have read, SVB’s portfolio (of Treasuries and MBS) would’ve been entirely consistent with pre-repeal Glass-Steagall.
- scotty79 4y agoSo it was move in the right direction. Just didn't go far enough. Banks should not gamble with their money no matter how safe the bet seems. The only exception is issuing loans because that's one of core reasons for the bank to exist.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoSVB would have failed even it held only Treasuries on its book. Those are literally used to define the risk-free rate of return. The assets were not risky. It was their duration mismatch that was the problem.
- scotty79 4y agoEvery asset has some risk. If they were only allowed to own dollars and loans they created themselves there would be no problem.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoThat’s also totally wrong. What do you think the financial difference between originating a loan and buying a bond is? You pay out a principal sum, then (as long as the borrower is creditworthy) you get back the principal and interest. Unless you only make floating rate loans (which is extremely rare outside of revolving lines like credit cards) then you have exactly the same duration risk problems and you’re actually exposed to much greater credit risk with a loan than you are with a government bond.
- scotty79 4y agoTo issue a loan you need to individually check the borrower, and that's it. With bonds you put your trust in the whole system that banks apparently (as SBV debacle shows) don't understand (bacause they can't or because they have incentive not to understand). Also, floating rate loans and mortgages are super common. Maybe not in US.
- klipt 4y ago"Issuing a loan" and "buying debt" are the same thing in different words. Issuing a loan is still, in effect, buying an asset.
- scotty79 4y agoThe difference is, who created the risk. When you buy asset from someone else you are buying the risk someone else has created. So you have more risk. Banks are very unique institutions that are allowed to do things no other business is allowed to do. They also should be equally severely restricted so they can't acquire any additional risk they themselves didn't create. Banks are risk sources in the economy, the risk of "what if borrower doesn't pay in full or at all", the law should do everything to prevent banks from being risk sinks in the economy. Because in current setup banks just buy more an more risk and they eventually collapse one way or the other when risk is en masse converted to cost to the people and the economy.
- kaashif 4y agoWhat's really the difference between issuing a loan and buying the same loan issued by someone else? SVB bought a load of treasury bonds which is equivalent from a risk perspective from issuing a 10 year (or whatever) loan to the government, right?
- scotty79 4y ago> What's really the difference between issuing a loan and buying the same loan issued by someone else? Risk. When you are issuing a loan you, yourself are in control of the risk you have created. When you buy, you can easily buy massive amounts of risk someone else have created and you can easily be overwhelmed even when you try to do industry standard, responsible, "safe" thing.
- digitaltrees 4y agoIssuing a loan is buying an asset. You give the borrower money and in exchange buy their promise to pay it back with interest. And in fact that’s what SVB did, except instead of originating the loans themselves they bought them from the original lender.
- scotty79 4y agoIt's creating an asset. Creating and buying are different thing. Creating should be allowed, buying should be forbidden.
- roflyear 4y agoWhy?
- scotty79 4y agoBecause it's way easier to buy a lot of unknown risk than create it by lending.
- roflyear 4y agoNot sure that is the case. If you can't buy good loans I really doubt you can issue good loans.
- scotty79 4y agoTo buy good loan you have to check whole supply chain. To issue a good loan you need to check only the borrower and you have every incentive to do so if you can't offload the loan to someone else after it's created.
- roflyear 4y agoUh, no, lol, unless there is fraud expected ... it's not quite simple to "check the borrower" and it takes a decent amount of legwork.