4 ms·
Juries do not have the “right” to ignore the law. Juries are required to follow the law as set forth in the judge’s jury instructions. Their job is just to dete
by rayiner 4y ago
Juries do not have the “right” to ignore the law. Juries are required to follow the law as set forth in the judge’s jury instructions. Their job is just to determine the facts and apply the law to the facts. As a legal matter, nobody gives a shit what twelve random people think about the law enacted by the democratically elected legislature.
“Jury nullification” therefore isn’t a “right” it’s a loophole. It arises from the fact that there is nothing a court can do to enforce a jury’s obligation to follow the law in a criminal trial. That doesn’t mean the obligation to follow the law doesn’t exist.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- linuxftw 4y agoWhen you consider the fact that police are lying sacks of garbage, you don't need to nullify anything. You just find the state's witnesses non-credible. I think most will admit, they have a bias to believe agents of the state. This preconceived bias should be treated no different than a preconceived bias to the contrary.
- jurynulifcation 4y agoJury Nullification, aka The Citizen's Veto, is a necessary consequence of the rights enjoyed by the citizens. It might not be a right, but it is a valid form of lawfare. It is a tool we should use to undermine bad laws. That bad laws exist is, in my opinion, undeniable. I mostly have in mind, currently, the drug laws that have imprisoned tons of recreational users for the high crime of smoking a doob. The mere choice to partake is not unethical and should not be illegal. We should not expect juries to uphold these laws. We should make the jobs of prosecutors absolute hell if they want to ruin someone's life for doing something that is not unethical. Jury Nullification, aka The Citizen's Veto, is how we do that.