5 ms·
Academics don't resell the data to others. In fact, their existing agreements with Twitter requires their published datasets (for reproducibility) to be anonymi
by anigbrowl 4y ago
Academics don't resell the data to others. In fact, their existing agreements with Twitter requires their published datasets (for reproducibility) to be anonymized precisely to ensure they don't become a commercial goldmine.
Given that most of the article is about the pricing tiers for academic use, based on marketing communications to universities, your comment seems strangely indifferent to the context of this news. These proposed costs are unaffordable precisely because academics are not running a business around the data. If the article were about enterprise data sales, your point would make sense.
- mrtksn 4y agoAcademic work has all kinds of costs, why should data be free of charge?
- andrejguran 4y agodoesn't have to be free but with every increase there will be less research that can afford to pay for the data and with the proposed pricing of $500.000 for 0.3% of tweets it seems that no-one will be willing to pay the price
- viscanti 4y agoHow many researchers can and will pay $42k per month for access? What's the market size here? Is this anything more than a drop in the bucket for Twitter?
- mrtksn 4y agoI don't know but it's theirs to sell and find the right price. > Is this anything more than a drop in the bucket for Twitter? I don't know, Twitter were selling office furniture and cutting on the food on campus. So maybe it's not just a drop in the bucket after all?
- optionalsquid 4y agoAs you say, Academics are pretty used to paying for access to data, services, material, etc., but $42k-per-month for limited access to Twitter sounds more like a "fuck off" price than anything else.
- goosedragons 4y agoThere's pretty huge gap between $0 a month and $42,000. Even a year of data would require pretty huge grant.
- anigbrowl 4y agoSorry, no time for goalpost-chasing today.
- isubasinghe 4y agoWell I guarantee you the research project I worked on is now gonna get shut down because of this. Academic work has costs but nothing like 42k per month, if anything that was the entire budget allocation for one RA's salary for 80% of the year. The current project I am on now, has only been allocated 250k for multiple people (3 RAs) working on it for the year.
- 2h 4y agoWhy cant universities fund it with their billion dollar endowments?
- kenjackson 4y agoNot many universities have billion dollar endowments.
- SteveGerencser 4y agoIndiana University a Midwest US state school has a 3+ Billion Dollar endowment behind it and ranks 16th right now. University of Texas is #1 at $42B and Berkeley is 20th at $2.6B. These are just state schools. Stanford is at $38B and Yale is at $42B. There is plenty of money out there in the university endowments. They just need to spend it on things like research and professors rather than Golf Courses and sports stadiums.
- kenjackson 4y agoThere are ~6500 universities/colleges in the US. Probably around 1,000 academic schools. How many have $1B plus endowments? 150? So maybe around 15%. https://www.univstats.com/corestats/ https://www.univstats.com/corestats/
- asutekku 4y agoThere is literally only couple of US universities having that, for smaller universities 42k a month for a research or two doesn't make any financial sense at all. This price is just basically a huge gatekeeper to prevent most people using it.
- favaq 4y agoI don't see anything positive coming out of academia having access to the Twitter firehose.
- makestuff 4y agoWhen I was in college we used it to try and try a sentiment analysis model since they are notoriously bad at detecting sarcasm and Twitter was full of sarcasm. We also used the API to try and determine the most impacted areas after a natural disaster. Basically it would use the model we trained to try and read tweets of people that needed help or people tweeting about severe damage and group them by their coordinates. The first one I agree isn’t really positive since it is just using other people’s data to train a model, but the second one could’ve been a useful tool to help EMS during a natural disaster.
- isubasinghe 4y agosigh this is just straight up wrong, I was an RA that worked on a real time social media analytics software. We were able to pick up on things like likely covid infections sites etc.
- mike_hearn 4y agoTry searching Google Scholar for "social bot", or to save time, just read this paper: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3814191 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3814191 Academia has flooded the literature with >10,000 research papers based on the Twitter API feed. Virtually none of it is reproducible, it's frequently based on circular logic, the methodologies are unscientific and the conclusions are usually deeply partisan, but it nonetheless gets amplified by the media as "proof" of various false claims. Count me in the camp of people who is happy Musk is doing this. I've been writing for years about the plague of "social bot" research coming out of academia that's based on the Twitter API: https://blog.plan99.net/fake-science-part-ii-bots-that-are-not-c66129e5e3f5 https://blog.plan99.net/fake-science-part-ii-bots-that-are-n... https://blog.plan99.net/did-russian-bots-impact-brexit-ad66f08c014a https://blog.plan99.net/did-russian-bots-impact-brexit-ad66f... Maybe your specific work on COVID was good, but it was certainly drowned out by the work that was sharply net negative for both society and science. Academic institutions were clearly never going to get the problem under control, so booting them out whilst allowing search engines and the like to continue accessing the feed seems like a good solution.
- briandear 4y agoExcept if I want to buy some piece of academic research, they sell articles for as high at $60. Why aren’t academics complaining about the absurd costs for the public accessing their information?
- notafraudster 4y agoThey do? Every single academic in the country supports open-access, lobbies their institutions to pay for the costs of open access. Every researcher will send you a copy of their article if you are paywalled and want to read it. And you, like all academics, know about Sci-Hub, so you should do what most academics do and use Sci-Hub to pirate the article to begin with.
- gammalost 4y agoMost academics (at least in Sweden). Get a lot of their articles from their University Library. Scihub is also an option if needed. If those options aren't possible then either request the library to buy it or to do it themselves. Besides it is way less than $43k. Even then a lot of people are against the high cost
- isubasinghe 4y agoJust email the academic and ask for the paper, it's the journals that are ripping everyone off.
- anigbrowl 4y agoAcademics don't make money from academic publishing. In fact, they often have to pay exorbitant review fees to journals. There have been many, many HN threads about this part of the the publishing industry.
- mftrhu 4y ago... they are.
- jwestbury 4y ago> Why aren’t academics complaining about the absurd costs for the public accessing their information? They are. Loudly and consistently. Academics largely abhor the academic publishing industry, but feel trapped by it.