9 ms·
Dutch police collecting demonstrators' personal data on a large scale
- itsoktocry 4y agoPeople the world over have determined they're fine with this kind of surveillance as long as it's the "other side's" protesters that are being surveilled. We saw it here in Canada during the Trucker's protest. The ship has sailed.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoI am not sure. US just had a bigger protest over 'cop city' and you can find all sorts of interpretations of the event from 'they righteous' to 'they terrorists'. Trucker's protest was similarly divided in US ( I don't know how it was portrayed/received in Canada. I think what I am saying is wrong with regards to: 'People the world over have determined they're fine ' If anything, I am actually seeing regular people paying attention to sanctions, BSA, BIS and similar. Naturally, it is possible that is because it started to affect more regular people, but yeah.. I am not certain you are right.
- khyryk 4y agoMaybe a better way of putting it is that the public's amount of caring about it happens to be below the threshold for doing something.
- causi 4y agoTrucker's protest was similarly divided in US That's exactly what he's saying. It wasn't divided between people who believe in the rights of protestors and people who didn't; it was divided between pro and anti-vaxxers, which is largely to say between the political Left and Right. I don't know if there ever was a political core that cared more about their principles of governance (good or bad) than their "side" but it's gone now. The people who dismissed the threat of BLM protests/riots being COVID super-spreader events in 2020 wanted truckers lynched for clogging up a city and honking their horns. On the other side, the same people cheering on an entire city in gridlock and effectively tortured by constant horn noise wanted police to gun down entire crowds for looting a Walmart. Both of them cloaked their defenses with cries of "free speech!" and both called for repression in the name of order and safety. Those of us who apply the same principles to people we love and hate, speech we cheer and find nauseating, are an endangered species.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoThank you. That makes more sense. I think I did not parse parent's post right. I personally want to believe I apply the principles evenly, but uncharitable interpretation can do a lot to point out even slightest inconsistency derived from competing priorities ( and everyone has different ranking of those ).
- verall 4y agoDo you feel like it is applying the same principles to people you both love and hate to characterize BLM protests as riots and truckers protests as "honking their horns"?
- 4dayworkweek4u 4y agoLook up the G.F protests death count.
- vuln 4y agoPerhaps it was the coverage I saw but I didn't see any looting, property destruction, or any fights with law enforcement with the truckers protest. That's not to say it didn't happen. Could be the difference between the US and Canada media. The truckers also had bouncy houses, food tents and trucks, DJs and dancing in the street. Seems like a good time compared to CHOP and other autonomous zones where people were murdered.
- verall 4y agoIt's trivial to find examples of food tents, clashing with police, and DJs in both groups, so it's probably a difference in the media you are watching, and these aren't very good examples. I think it may make more sense to try to make a judgement as to the reason for the protests. My best understanding of the truckers protest they were protesting Canada requiring truckers who crossed the US-Canada border to be vaccinated, while the BLM protesters were protesting US police negligence, uses of force, and perceived lack of oversight. Maybe the split is more about those who judge the reasons for protesting vs the methods of protesting rather than left vs right. In any case I don't think counting bouncy houses is productive.
- sandworm101 4y ago>> I don't know how it was portrayed/received in Canada. 1/3 of the country, the anti-Trudeau bit, could see no wrong in the trucker protests. The rest of the country saw a bunch of entitled jerks being jerks. They weren't even real truckers, more like business owners who owned trucks. Rank-and-file truckers don't have the time nor resources to go on multi-week vacations across the country. The large number of immigrants who drive trucks in Canada were also not represented. The icing on the cake was the hot tub. American protesters at January 6th brought a gallows. The Ottawa "truckers" brought a hot tub. Every weekend in my area a few huge pickups get together to drive around with their "F*ck Trudeau" flags, the remnants of the trucker protest movement. Everyone else just looks at them wondering where they get enough money to waste gas driving huge trucks around in circles on a Saturday.
- LawTalkingGuy 4y ago> The large number of immigrants who drive trucks in Canada were also not represented. There are famous videos of Sikh truck drivers on other drivers shoulders, as the crowd dances to Indian music - near the bouncy castle. But would it be illegitimate if it appealed to one demographic more than another? > Rank-and-file truckers don't have the time nor resources to go on multi-week vacations across the country. They were out of a job so they had time. > The icing on the cake was the hot tub. American protesters at January 6th brought a gallows. The Ottawa "truckers" brought a hot tub. How is this good or bad? Lots of people enjoy hot-tubbing in cold weather. > 1/3 of the country, the anti-Trudeau bit, could see no wrong in the trucker protests. No chance any of their supporters are there because they agree with the issues? You feel that everyone who supported them was doing so because they disliked the PM? Do you also feel that everyone who spoke out against them was a supporter of the PM? What opinions are legitimate opinions and which ones do people only have to support their party?
- sandworm101 4y agoThe canada trucker protests are not a great pro-privacy example. Given the weapons that were found at the border protest, and the subsequent prosecutions for those possessing them (conspiracy to murder cops), any data requests seem to have served a legitimate purpose. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/coutts-protest-charges-laid-court-appearance-bail-1.6352482 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/coutts-protest-charge...
- olalonde 4y agoI think parent was referring to the large trucker protest in Ottawa where several privacy violations occurred (e.g. freezing bank accounts) despite the protests being mostly peaceful.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- eldaisfish 4y ago[flagged]
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoWould you describe the BLM protests as mostly peaceful?
- tomkarho 4y agoFiery but mostly peaceful. /s
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- barbazoo 4y ago> despite the protests being mostly peaceful https://pressprogress.ca/it-was-violent-peoples-commission-report-shines-light-on-violence-harassment-and-hate-crimes-during-freedom-convoy/ https://pressprogress.ca/it-was-violent-peoples-commission-r...
- hommelix 4y agoI remember this text [1] when I read your comment. Thank you [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_they_came_ https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_they_came_...
- AussieWog93 4y agoHonestly, I think a lot of people are pretty sick of protests in general, regardless of their political affiliation (probably not on HN, since we're extremely online and libertarian, but ask your grandma and see what she says). Whether it's the left doing it or the right, it seems that many protests have nothing to do with the "movement" at all and are just thinly veiled excuses to act like an ape and smear shit on the wall.
- wolverine876 4y agoDo you have any objective information to support that? Certainly some reactionary groups want to stop protests, which are a threat to authoritarian power. The reason is protests are often very effective; they are a threat to their power. Look at Israel now, for example. Look at the US Constitution, which went out of its way to protect protests.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- swayvil 4y agoVoting (on social media, like here) is like protesting. They're both public expressions of emotion. Online anonymity is also like being-part-of-a-crowd anonymity. Frame either in whatever rational interpretation you like. But they both amount to howls of embrace/reject.
- skylanh 4y agoCanada's "The Trucker's Protest" is more commonly referred to as a hostile occupation and blockade. There is a strong white-washing attempt by certain unsavory elements to recast it as a benign protest movement.
- 4dayworkweek4u 4y agoDo you believe in "my body my choice"?
- arunharidas 4y agoSame for most of the protests out there. You should not support surveillance even if you're against cause of protest. The government will come for you sooner or later.
- DeathArrow 4y agoWhat about GDPR?
- mhitza 4y agoAny EU state institution which can package their motives behind a shallow "national security" excuse can exempt itself from GDPR. And whose motives are really shallow (like it could be in this case, haven't read the article), the only way forward is to bring them to court and test their "national security" excuse.
- coretx 4y agoNo it's not... When you ask them for your file they may return a letter ending with "we have no info about you but if you publish the content of this letter you go to prison" It happend to me. ( In the Netherlands)
- andai 4y agoDamn, that's terrible. Do I understand correctly, you asked the police to give you what they have on you, under GDPR? Does GDPR make exceptions for police? (If I was a criminal and being investigated, I imagine it would defeat the purpose if they had to tell me everything they knew about me.)
- coretx 4y agoNot just GDPR, also WPG etc. The latter is what you are supposed to use. And no, no criminal investigation involved.
- formerly_proven 4y agoGDPR article 2 section 2 clauses b and d
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoGDPR protects you from private enterprises spying on you, it doesn't protect you from your own government spying on you.
- hahamaster 4y agoThey never collect profiles of anyone who's a law abiding, non-protesting citizen who always does what they're told. Docile, compliant, obedient Dutch people are almost never profiled. Be docile, compliant and obedient and you will not have a problem with the police - it's super simple.
- heywherelogingo 4y agoBehave like you are an owned pet, rather than a human with rights equal to those controlling you.
- uoaei 4y agoThat is extremely incorrect, and obviously so if you have any prior experience with privacy.
- taneq 4y ago"Be meek and they shall not come for you yet" seems like solid life advice.
- read_if_gay_ 4y ago[flagged]
- FooBarWidget 4y agoThis is a strange characterization. "Docile" can also just mean "follow rule of law". The latter suddenly doesn't sound so odd. If the police is violating the law then there's no discussion and they need to be corrected. Otherwise, aren't we supposed to follow the law? If we disagree with the law and want it changed, now that is a different process. But there's no need to be disobedient for disobedience's sake, or just for the sake of not appearing "docile". We Dutch are also good complainers so I don't think we can be described as "docile", even if "just be normal and you're already crazy enough" is a local saying.
- kornhole 4y agoEverybody should learn a little self defense before attending protests. PI provides some good guides. https://privacyinternational.org/long-read/5012/guide-surveillance-and-connecting-world-online https://privacyinternational.org/long-read/5012/guide-survei...
- expertentipp 4y agoThe Dutch are famously cash averse, aren't they? ...or at least their retail banks are. So we are maybe half dozen steps away from "expiring" the money of the blacklisted or shadow banned.
- sluijs 4y ago> Ten of the 67 demonstrators have never been arrested. This feels like a very select group of people to be honest. Extrapolating these numbers to “demonstrators” in general seems like a bit of a stretch, regardless of whether this is right or wrong.
- rex_gallorum2 4y agoThis reminds me a bit of the recent discussion here about networked security cameras using cloud storage. Many people seem to have a very simplistic idea about how the law, law enforcement, and courts work. Laws are always selectively enforced. Police, prosecutors, and courts are not going to simply round up petty criminals such as serial package thieves just because victims suddenly have HD video footage of the (countless) perpetrators. They have other priorities. Political crime is back with a vengeance, even in the 'liberal' west, and pursuing threats to the existing socio-political and economic order will always take priority. The main issue with pervasive surveillance systems isn't that they are used to detect and prosecute ordinary street crime or nuisance infractions (though the latter can become burdensome). The problem is that these systems will be used to pursue 'special' categories of crime such as political activism. (Expect those categories to creep and expand just as flimsy justifications such as 'conspiracy' and 'incitement' proliferate.) Expect the full force of the surveillance and control systems being constructed now to be used extensively to maintain public order and pursue threats to public order. Remember, the primary role of the police is to maintain order. Everything else they might do is secondary to that. I hate to bring up Julian Assange as he is such a polarizing and widely reviled character - but it is clear now that several governments saw him as a sufficiently dire threat to that they felt justified pouring gargantuan resources into neutralizing him. This never happens with ordinary criminals except in sensational cases where the public is out for blood. I do not know if Assange himself was ever considered such a big threat, but I suspect the systemic risk threatening the whole system was great enough to justify making an example of him to deter others (at least from the perspective of the US and UK governments). In a slightly unrelated aside, I might also remind some of you of this case: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Kennedy_(police_officer) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Kennedy_(police_officer) And back to the networked cameras. Your own surveillance system is ultimately spying on you and creating records of your activities that probably should not exist - and should you store your data locally, and some of it happens to conveniently go missing, it could incriminate you, whereas this would not be an issue if it never existed in the first place. It brings up the old 'if you have nothing to hide' argument. Yet here we see evidence that largely benign political activities are deemed sufficiently threatening to justify closer scrutiny. Pardon the sloppiness of this comment. I posted it piecemeal with many edits.
- vestrigi 4y agoSo how did the police find out about the identities of the 10 people who have never been arrested? Because they posted to social media about them attending a demonstration? How was it connected to them being demonstrators? Where their identities collected during protests but they weren't arrested? Article leaves that open.
- orangepurple 4y agoPure speculation: Your national ID is linked to your cell phone via the payments and the banking system. IMEIs are globally unique and its possible to triangulate cell phones by constantly monitoring signal strength to nearby towers. Intelligence agencies know where almost every person is at all times since most people have their cell phone turned on and on their person as they move around. The solution is obtaining SIM cards and cell phones without ID, which is probably why that is outlawed in many places.
- realworldperson 4y ago[dead]
- tommica 4y agoI'll add my voice to the list too, and state that this is not a good thing, and I'm against it.