4 ms·
Maybe $70B in credit but there is no way anyone is going to redeem that much in real currency. How is the $70B number even helpful. Is it supposed to trigger
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago
Maybe $70B in credit but there is no way anyone is going to redeem that much in real currency.
How is the $70B number even helpful. Is it supposed to trigger notions of "too big to fail".
Who cares how much the Ponzi scheme has taken in. Victims want to know how much it can pay out.
The answer of course is not enough.
Singh has now flipped on SBF.
The outcome of the Ripple case is anyone's guess.
Fraud is not difficult to understand.
- mrweasel 4y agoThis may just be me being cynical, but any attempt to convert any significant about of Bitcoins to anything real will collapse the price further.
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoNo, you are not cynical, you are spot on. Crypto gains are worth nothing until you change it into currency. The same is true for stock gains. Crypto gains only were people imagining money into existence. This is the problem of going off the gold standard.
- senttoschool 4y ago>No, you are not cynical, you are spot on. Crypto gains are worth nothing until you change it into currency. The same is true for stock gains. Actually, stocks are slightly different. Because stocks are based on an underlying real company producing real services and goods, it's worth something even if you don't sell it. This is because stocks can pay dividends or do buy backs. Crypto does not pay dividends or do buy backs. If they do, they should be classified as a security.
- FollowingTheDao 4y ago> Because stocks are based on an underlying real company producing real services and goods No, they are not. Stocks prices are solely based on their supply and demand in the market. Products and services may play a role in the demand fro the stock, but they are not the sole determinate of price. Take AMC for example...
- wyatt_dolores 4y agoStocks do have a natural lower bound which is the actual value of the company.
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoAre you saying Bitcoin can go negative?
- chollida1 4y agoit's possible if the carrying cost of BTC is positive.
- medvezhenok 4y agoThe total stock of a company, yes. Your particular share - not necessarily. You could get diluted to pretty much nothing if the company chooses to issue more shares. Shareholders can usually push back via voting, but depending on the way the company is setup they could still successfully dilute smaller shareholders.
- senttoschool 4y agoStock prices are based on supply and demand. But a stock is the ownership of a company, which produces goods and services.
- HPsquared 4y agoThe same is true for any asset, including gold or real estate.
- mrweasel 4y agoGold does have real world applications, you can build stuff with it, but yes, if only using in electronics the price would crash. Real estate, depending one the type can generate money by being utilized, it doesn't need to be traded as such.
- ashwagary 4y ago>but yes, if only using in electronics >it doesn't need to be traded as such. Only a small percentage of sellers can convert an asset into the current dollar price in every market, regardless of where the underlying is used. This is true for every asset. Once supply outpaces demand, price moves down.
- tomputer 4y agoThis is exactly what makes Bitcoin a fantastic store of value. Bitcoin supersedes gold because compared to gold, it has no other use. If Bitcoin would be used as a store of value instead of gold, gold can be used for other material purposes for a lower price. The same goes for real estate. A house does not have to be an investment asset or store of value. If (institutional) investors would use Bitcoin instead of housing, it could make housing affordable again. Or at least result in more fair/realistic housing market instead of the propped up market from the last few years. Compared to gold and real estate, Bitcoin is a scarce asset that can easily be divided into small pieces. It has a liquid market and can be exchanged 24/7 anywhere in the world.
- proto-n 4y agoI think you have the wrong mental model about market caps. Market cap going down by $70B does not mean that $70B has been withdrawn.
- smcl 4y agoNot necessarily. It sounded to me like they were dismissing the idea that there was anything to that original value. That there's nothing "lost" because there just doesn't exist $70bn of demand for BTC, it could never be realised
- Veen 4y agoI think they are arguing that the market cap is a fantasy number anyway. It went down by a theoretical $70 billion, but that number (and the market cap) is meaningless because it's not possible to convert large amounts of BTC to fiat without collapsing the market, assuming the exchanges will let you and that they have the fiat reserves to do so, which is highly doubtful.
- culturestate 4y ago> assuming the exchanges will let you and that they have the fiat reserves to do so, which is highly doubtful If you’re trying to sell off several tens of millions of dollars of BTC, you don’t go to an exchange - you go to an investment bank. Goldman will happily run that for you.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Veen 4y agoThen Goldman has more faith in the future value of BTC than seems warranted.
- gizmo 4y agoThe crypto market cap is about 1 trillion USD. Now suppose all current crypto holders want to exchange their crypto for dollars. How many dollars do they get, collectively? The market cap is 1 trillion, but for them to get dollars somebody else has to put up those dollars in exchange for the crypto. And that's a problem, because everybody who thinks crypto is a good idea is already in crypto, which means there is no sizable group of people to sell into. If all current Apple shareholders decide to get rid of Apple an inflow of 2.5 trillion is needed. The new group of shareholders will like Apple less than the current group of shareholders, so the stock would get sold at a slight discount (10% maybe). The universe of investors who are willing to buy Apple shares at a discount is enormous, so it's fine. With crypto, not so much. The first 100bn you might be able to sell to people at a reasonable discount, but then you're out of buyers for sure. So who are the holders of the remaining 900bn worth of crypto going to sell to? How big of a discount do they need to offer to get the dollars they want? 30%? 60%? 99%? With crypto the market cap is an illusion because when people sell crypto en masse the price will trend towards the intrinsic value (which is zero). That's what the parent means with "The money is not there. Some folks will lose. Everyone knows it."
- jfengel 4y ago"Market cap" is always a dubious number, even for something like stocks that do represent an actual underlying asset. It's extrapolating the last trade (or last few trades) to the entire set, and that's not realistic. A market capacity can drop millions of billions with just $1 changing hands. The number isn't completely worthless. Most of the time, you're not thinking about liquidating the entire thing all at once. The actual total number isn't all that important, but the way it changes is informative -- it accurately captures what happens at the margins. Crypto is weird in that the entire thing genuinely can collapse at a moment's notice. Unlike a stock, there's no real-world asset anywhere, just the consensual agreement. Even a fiat currency at least has the force of a government collecting taxes and paying wages. The market cap is a useful number so long as nobody expects to actually realize it. When you actually could realize it, like a currency collapsing, you have to unpack the full meaning of it and realize that it's very different.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoFunny that replies discuss the term "market cap"(italization). It is mentioned nowhere in the article. Is this even an appropriate term to apply to "cryptocurrency". Traditionally it has been used to refer to companies. Putting aside the untrustworthiess of the sources of crypto "market cap" data, what, or should we say "who", exactly is being capitalised. SBF was one of many. https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-programmer-at-the-center-of-a-100-billion-crypto-storm-1516708800 https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-programmer-at-the-center-of...