3 ms·
Because that worked out so well for Russia and China. Command economies have never efficiently allocated resources, and they never will. Economies are just too
by simonh 15y ago
Because that worked out so well for Russia and China. Command economies have never efficiently allocated resources, and they never will. Economies are just too complicated for a single central authority to control successfully. They can never have enough accurate information, and can't be flexible enough to rapidly changing circumstances.
Just look at the hopeless response to the financial crisis from European leaders. You really want to put politicians in charge of all business activity as well?
- jdlegg 15y agoActually, it's working great for China (in the short-term at least). Though they probably wouldn't call their system "communist" anymore, in preference for the new description: "state capitalism."
- reader5000 15y agoHuman-commanded centralized economies, perhaps. But what about e.g. a Google-commanded centralized economy?
- rsheridan6 15y agoIf the alternative does turn out to be unemployment on a massive scale due to automation, the Soviet Union doesn't look so bad in comparison. It's probably not optimal, but at least we know that it works (badly, no doubt, but life went on under the Soviets). I seriously doubt Friedman's idea of sending everyone to college would work at all.
- jpadkins 15y agoThe Soviet Union killed 100m of its own citizens. Now what doesn't look so bad?
- rsheridan6 15y agoThat's a grossly exaggerated figure, and if you skip the Lenin/Stalin era and go straight to Khruschev it's not nearly as bad. And if, by hypothesis, the "average" person become redundant and unemployable, they would simply starve to death in lieu of government intervention, which would lead to a death toll that would make the Dekulakization look like a traffic ticket.