5 ms·
While this is interesting, it's still early days. In the meantime, using a control system based on a caloric deficit and regular measurement of weight and calip
by jacques_chester 15y ago
While this is interesting, it's still early days. In the meantime, using a control system based on a caloric deficit and regular measurement of weight and caliper fat, combined with some weight training to prevent muscle loss, is still the best way to lose weight.
People spend too much time looking for a silver bullet. We already have lead bullets and they're plenty effective for 99.999% of cases.
- tallanvor 15y agoUnfortunately that's not exactly the case. While it's true that maintaining a caloric deficit will result in weight loss, determining the necessary deficit - and taking into consideration that you have to increase that deficit the more weight you lose - and then maintaining this is very difficult, especially for people who have lost a lot of weight. A couple of years ago I lost about 100 pounds. Just to maintain that weight loss I have to limit myself to around 2000 calories a day and run 80k a week. I'm trying to lose another 20 pounds, but that means eating even less and exercising even more.
- jacques_chester 15y agoI mentioned weight training, not by accident. Steady state cardio using the lipolytic energy system[1] is a very slow way to create a caloric deficit; and it causes atrophy. It's not unusual for Olympic marathon runners to have higher body fat percentages than their sprinter compatriots. I admire your grit, but have you tried some weights or perhaps some high-intensity interval work? [1] http://www.hussmanfitness.org/html/TLEnergySystems.html http://www.hussmanfitness.org/html/TLEnergySystems.html discusses the four energy systems at a high level.
- tallanvor 15y agoI've done weight training in the past and I've tried interval training. I haven't found either of them to be more helpful. I plan to switch back to weight training around March and give that a try for a couple of months to see if I can find a way to make that work better. Part of the problem is that the more research that's done into exercise, the more we see that what works for one person may not be effective for someone else. A lot depends on your metabolism and the way your body responds to the various hormones that control energy use and storage.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoI plan to switch back to weight training around March and give that a try for a couple of months to see if I can find a way to make that work better. Try Starting Strength ( http://www.amazon.com/Starting-Strength-3rd-Mark-Rippetoe/dp/0982522738/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1327534336&sr=8-1 http://www.amazon.com/Starting-Strength-3rd-Mark-Rippetoe/dp... ). Most people (read: me) dick around in the gym with bicep curls and nautilus machines, which is a mistake. I got basically no results while doing that, and my improvements have been dramatic since I started SS.
- jacques_chester 15y agoThat's well and good, but (1) most folks are not outliers and (2) thermodynamics is not subject to hormones. As I said above: the "black box" is enormously complex but it is not observable, so it's not useful for an ordinary person. Caloric deficit works for everyone and it can be controlled easily.
- xiaoma 15y ago>It's not unusual for Olympic marathon runners to have higher body fat percentages than their sprinter compatriots. It's not only unusual, it's unheard of! Elite marathoners have far lower levels of body fat than other athletes, with men clocking in at around 3%! Even unusually lean sprinters have about double that. See the chart in this journal for a variety of athletes including marathoners compared (should be free for a few page views), p.764 http://books.google.co.kr/books?id=XOyjZX0Wxw4C&pg=PA764 http://books.google.co.kr/books?id=XOyjZX0Wxw4C&pg=PA764
- jacques_chester 15y agoYou're right (I should have double-checked). I've been repeating bro-science. If you'll excuse me, I'll be jogging around the block for penance.
- xiaoma 15y agoHaha, that made me smile! :) I think the main reason for the misconception is that lots of people compete in marathon races and some of them are fat. So people see someone who can still run a marathon but is still fat and think, "ha they can run for hours but they're still chubby!" But nobody really competes in a 100-400m race after school age unless they're elite or semi-elite... and obviously those guys are lean sprinting machines. That's the only kind of person we ever see sprinting. Compared to that zany uncle who decided to start marathoning upon reaching midlife, elite sprinters on TV are manimals! If we reversed it though, and compared everyone fit enough to complete a 400m race, at any level with elite marathoners, the results would be the opposite. We'd be saying wow... those skinny marathoners can run 400m faster than most racers, and then do it again 104 more times without rest! Woah!!!
- bad_user 15y agoYou really should read "Good Calories, Bad Calories" by Gary Taubes: http://amzn.to/yLvq0A http://amzn.to/yLvq0A TL;DR - diets based on caloric deficit don't work so well / are inherently unhealthy and there's staggering evidence that gets ignored.
- jacques_chester 15y agoI've heard of Gary Taubes and I've been shown the same stuff. I mentioned a control system and I meant it. Weight loss is an enormously complex system internally. Almost all of the mechanisms are unobservable. What is observable is: food in vs weight / calliper measurements. Paleo works for lots of people. That's awesome. But it doesn't change the fact that a large component of the weight loss is removing calories in by cutting out sugar-dense foods.
- bad_user 15y agoAnother fact is that the human body is trained to survive starvation. When you consume less calories, the body will simply burn less calories. And yet another fact: there are people that could eat enormous amounts of table sugar and French fries and pork grills and whatever else is considered a calories-bomb and do so daily and not gain any extra weight and if they do, they return to a normal weight immediately after stopping this unhealthy practice. Clearly something is missing from this picture and losing weight by starving yourself is not sustainable, even if it works for some people. Your body will just adjust and after a certain threshold it will stop losing weight. And as soon as you break the rules, your body will put back the lost weight faster than ever before. The (biggest) problem lies with carbohydrate-rich foods - things like white bread, potatoes, pasta. E.g. if you eat meat and only meat (disregarding the healthiness of this approach), the daily intake of calories doesn't really matter as you will lose weight. You can also be a vegetarian - as long as you stay away from starch and sugar, you will lose weight. Also - only thin people are suggesting that for losing weight you should eat less (in general). There are fat people out there that barely eat anything and are still fat. Spreading such lies can do real damage.
- 15y ago
- radu_floricica 15y agoProblem isn't losing weight, it's how to keep losing it, how to maintain a low weight, and how to do this without turning your brain in a "I want food" machine.
- jacques_chester 15y agoAbsolutely. Find the diet that works for you; there's hundreds. I've found intermittent fasting works well for me, but there's no magic. I'm basically just skipping a meal per day and that causes the deficit.
- ryandvm 15y agoI engage in a similar practice. I do mild exercise and whenever I find that I need to lose a few pounds I just start skipping a meal. Works wonders. I find it odd that the thought of running a caloric deficit in order to lose weight is "off the table" for so many people.
- randallsquared 15y agoThe main issue with "eating sensibly" for people who don't naturally do so is that it requires thinking about food all day, which means being desirous of food all day, even if you're not technically "hungry". Low-carb, intermittent fasting, and other such schemes are ways to diet without having to constantly think about how much you're eating (and therefore how much you'd like to eat).
- radu_floricica 15y agoLow carb makes you think about food plenty. I never thought I could crave so much a piece of bread. Admittedly, I was going for ketosis so it was a bit extreme low-carb.
- eavc 15y agoThe problem is that weight is an issue of behavior change much like drug addiction or depression, so you need to measure success of a treatment by doing outcome studies over the long-term. For losing weight, these outcomes are shockingly poor for almost every approach. That's why people are looking for a silver bullet; the lead bullets are proving to be anything but effective for actually addressing the problem of overweight people.