3 ms·
> I think it's perfectly reasonable for a firewall to be tied to a specific operating system. Oh, I have no qualms about Little Snitch specifically being tied
by LoganDark 4y ago
> I think it's perfectly reasonable for a firewall to be tied to a specific operating system.
Oh, I have no qualms about Little Snitch specifically being tied to macOS. I just find it annoying that this general concept of "a firewall that asks you before blocking a connection" has apparently never been implemented outside of macOS.
I don't want the network request to fail and the application to panic just because I had to be given a prompt with an "allow" button. Suspend the connection instead please.
Windows and Linux firewalls are not yet capable of this, as far as I can tell. If there is one that can, I'd love to replace Windows Firewall with it.
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y agoOh, that is fair. I assume https://github.com/evilsocket/opensnitch https://github.com/evilsocket/opensnitch doesn't work for you?
- LoganDark 4y agoI think if I used Linux either that or Lulu would be what I'd go with, but AFAICT OpenSnitch uses wording that suggests it is actually suspending connections for the prompts instead of outright blocking them. I can't find any info on this in the README so I could be wrong but that could probably work yeah.
- phneutral26 4y agoSimpleWall? https://github.com/henrypp/simplewall https://github.com/henrypp/simplewall
- dhaavi 4y agoPortmaster is an application firewall similar to Little Snitch that works on Windows and Linux. When prompting, it suspends connections for a short amount of time, which, as far as I remember when implementing it, is configurable. I can check to tell you the details, if interested. See https://safing.io/ https://safing.io/
- LoganDark 4y agoI am so scared of Portmaster's website. Looking at their pricing page, it's talking about some VPN thing, and they absolutely insist that Portmaster itself is free and open source, but they keep emphasizing "free" to such an extent that I can't tell if they're lying. Free free free, free download, free and open source, etc etc. Could you confirm if Portmaster is actually completely free forever and doesn't lock any crucial features behind a paywall or different "plans" or pricing tiers? Is it actually just a local firewall? Because if so I might switch to it from WFC, it does look like it might actually do the trick. It has great documentation and seems to have a userbase too. Edit 30 minutes later: I've been reading more about Portmaster and found this article: https://safing.io/blog/2022/08/17/portmaster-vs-glasswire/ https://safing.io/blog/2022/08/17/portmaster-vs-glasswire/ "Many of the features mentioned by GlassWire, such as remote connection monitoring, Wi-Fi network monitor, Virus total scanning, and longer connection history, will cost you $39, $69, or $99 depending on your needs. Portmaster, on the other hand, is both free in terms of freedom and free in terms of price. Safing makes money by charging a monthly fee for additional privacy features." They will list every paid feature of Glasswire but only say "additional privacy features" for Portmaster? I am so sketched out right now. Are they trying to hide something or not? Also, the docs don't mention connection prompts—how did you get them?
- dhaavi 4y agoCTO of Safing here. I am sorry this has caused confusion. In principle it is very simple: The Portmaster software itself is completely free and there is no catch. The only thing we charge for is access to our VPN-alternative, the SPN. This is our business model in two sentences. So, all local features are free. We are thinking about testing new features with the supporter subscribers in the future, but eventually these features will also become free. However, we will never put previously free features behind a paywall. (The software is open-source, so people will just grab the forks!) > Is Portmaster actually completely free forever? Except for the SPN, yes. (additional privacy features == SPN) > Is it actually just a local firewall? Not counting SPN, yes. > Also, the docs don't mention connection prompts—how did you get them? Set the Default Network Action to "Prompt": https://docs.safing.io/portmaster/settings#filter/defaultAction https://docs.safing.io/portmaster/settings#filter/defaultAct...