2 ms·
This seems like a very limited notion of "understand". It seems to be talking about natural language sentences as if they were merely convoluted versions of pro
by jfengel 4y ago
This seems like a very limited notion of "understand". It seems to be talking about natural language sentences as if they were merely convoluted versions of propositional logic.
I see it the other way around: propositional logic is a very limited sub-domain of natural language. It may be the case that you can model human brains with propositional logic, but the kinds of sentences you create are very, very different. They're more along the lines of "Neuron 1 has a .25 weight connected to Neuron 2" than "A BLT is a sandwich made out of bacon, lettuce, tomato, and bread".
Focusing on sentences is designed to highlight this mapping of language to propositional logic, while missing everything else about discourse. A sentence like "I would like a cheeseburger" is not understood by "the conditions under which I'm hungry". That sentence is a request from one person to some other, who is not visible in the sentence at all but is part of the conditions in which that sentence is uttered.
As it comes to LLMs, I think that is the opposite of helpful. LLMs are not expert systems, which do come closer to trying to establish truth conditions. Those were abandoned because they were poor models of human cognition.
Whether LLMs do human cognition either remains an open question, but I don't think this direction is a very helpful one for understanding it.