7 ms·
Brown Fat, Triggered by Cold or Exercise, May Yield a Key to Weight Control
- aymeric 15y agoIs it related to what Tim Ferriss recommends in the Four Hour Body when he suggests to take cold showers?
- umno 15y agoNo
- ebiester 15y agoIANAbiologist, but not from what I can tell. the brown fat burns calories over hours, whereas the purpose of the cold shower is to produce more testosterone. (Supposedly.)
- cooldeal 15y agoYes, the cold showers are supposed to be taken on the lower neck area which triggers the brown fat.
- newandimproved 15y agoPerhaps, but Daniel Duchaine recommended it first, back in 1996 in his book Body Opus. Actually, his recommendation was swimming in cold water, which would probably be much more effective.
- billswift 15y agoWay back when I was in Boy Scouts, I tested for my lifesaving merit badge in a mountain lake in October. In my opinion, anyone who has the self-discipline to do this regularly isn't going to have any problem lowering his weight whatever method he chooses.
- chillyconker 15y agoI'm not clear whether cold and excercise are capable of increasing the number or proportion of brown fat cells, or whether they just trigger activity in existing brown fat.
- jacobolus 15y agoThe impression I got from the article was that cold triggered distinct brown fat deposits in particular places (neck, back, etc.) to burn fat (and sugar?) as a way to increase temperature. By contrast, the article implied that exercise turned “white” fat into “brown” fat, spread throughout the body rather than in particular isolated spots. It wasn’t clear what the purpose of this exercise-related brown fat was.
- BerislavLopac 15y agoI'm just guessing as wildly as Doc Brown's hair, but it seems logical that the "white" fat is the storage form of fat, while the brown one is the kind that body uses to do actual useful stuff. Like in a gasoline engine -- the gas is stored in concentrated form, but it's diffused and mixed with air moments before the actual combustion, as that's more efficient. So body creates the exercise-fat to have a ready source of energy required for physical activity (remember, while humans were evolving there were no exercise, only physical activity needed to survive).
- tallanvor 15y agoCold apparently activates the brown fat - causing it to burn fat and sugar. Exercise seems to release a hormone that causes white fat to convert to brown fat, but they don't seem to know why exercise causes this yet.
- scythe 15y agosee also: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Melatonin#Obesity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Melatonin#Obesity
- niels_olson 15y agoAt this stage, any link between obesity, brown fat, and melatonin is somewhere between one of many highly speculative hypotheses, and randomly selected string of grammatically coherent words. Not to be dismissed, but not worth reading any more unless your actually the one writing or funding the grant.
- jacques_chester 15y agoWhile this is interesting, it's still early days. In the meantime, using a control system based on a caloric deficit and regular measurement of weight and caliper fat, combined with some weight training to prevent muscle loss, is still the best way to lose weight. People spend too much time looking for a silver bullet. We already have lead bullets and they're plenty effective for 99.999% of cases.
- tallanvor 15y agoUnfortunately that's not exactly the case. While it's true that maintaining a caloric deficit will result in weight loss, determining the necessary deficit - and taking into consideration that you have to increase that deficit the more weight you lose - and then maintaining this is very difficult, especially for people who have lost a lot of weight. A couple of years ago I lost about 100 pounds. Just to maintain that weight loss I have to limit myself to around 2000 calories a day and run 80k a week. I'm trying to lose another 20 pounds, but that means eating even less and exercising even more.
- jacques_chester 15y agoI mentioned weight training, not by accident. Steady state cardio using the lipolytic energy system[1] is a very slow way to create a caloric deficit; and it causes atrophy. It's not unusual for Olympic marathon runners to have higher body fat percentages than their sprinter compatriots. I admire your grit, but have you tried some weights or perhaps some high-intensity interval work? [1] http://www.hussmanfitness.org/html/TLEnergySystems.html http://www.hussmanfitness.org/html/TLEnergySystems.html discusses the four energy systems at a high level.
- tallanvor 15y agoI've done weight training in the past and I've tried interval training. I haven't found either of them to be more helpful. I plan to switch back to weight training around March and give that a try for a couple of months to see if I can find a way to make that work better. Part of the problem is that the more research that's done into exercise, the more we see that what works for one person may not be effective for someone else. A lot depends on your metabolism and the way your body responds to the various hormones that control energy use and storage.
- neworbit 15y agoThis isn't a particularly new claim - back when the fad weight loss supplement was ephedrine (or a "ephedrine/caffeine/aspirin stack") the purported mechanism was brown fat thermogenesis. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ephedrine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ephedrine First I recall hearing about it was the mid-80s book Life Extension Weight Loss Program from megavitamin proponents Durk Pearson and Sandy Shaw. So this has been known of for a while. It was also thought to be debunked because "adult humans don't have brown fat" - which, as this article makes clear, is more "don't have much". But better imaging techniques have brought brown-fat thermogenesis back around. If you're trying to do this with vitamin/herbal supplements, I think the current trend is to use "bitter orange" instead of ephedrine. I find it's not very effective for me, but I wasn't a fan of ephedrine either.
- bretthopper 15y agoThe E/C/A stack isn't a "fad weight loss supplement". It's actually one of the few weight-loss methods that's been proven by many studies. Meta-study: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12672771 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12672771 Scientific reasoning behind the stack: http://thinksteroids.com/articles/ephedrine-targeting-beta-adrenergic-receptors/ http://thinksteroids.com/articles/ephedrine-targeting-beta-a...
- checoivan 15y agoRay Cronise also gave a talk at ted med about how the cold can increase fat loss. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UrQ_ldCwKUQ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UrQ_ldCwKUQ
- programminggeek 15y agoI realize it's just one data point, but I tracked my weight for a whole year basically and while my diet fluctuated somewhat, there did seem to be a strong correlation to weight loss and using cold therapy to activate brown fat. When I did the cold therapy, I lost weight much faster. Ice pack on the back of the neck for 30-60 min each night while reading a book works wonders.