2 ms·
"and spending it on poverty relief programs could eliminate poverty to a large degree in the U.S." No, it won't, assuming you're talking about existing program
by giantg2 4y ago
"and spending it on poverty relief programs could eliminate poverty to a large degree in the U.S."
No, it won't, assuming you're talking about existing programs. The current programs aren't designed to fix the problems the recipients face. They're merely designed to keep people alive (food, medical care, etc). They have absolutely nothing to do with getting those people jobs with pay high enough to exit the support system. Many of the people on those relief programs work, but simply don't make enough. So in that regard your last sentence allpies to your own statement: "It's that we're spending it on the wrong things".
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThe Child Tax Credit of 2021 has been massively successful. That's probably why there's massive pressure to let it expire.
- giantg2 4y agoWasn't the child tax credit change just that it was sent monthly instead of with the tax refund?
- bryanlarsen 4y agoIt also increased from $2000 to $3600. But yes the change from monthly to annual is also a significantly positive change for poor families.
- giantg2 4y agoThe amount I can see being a big help. I have trouble understanding how the monthly part is really any better. In theory, if you get it back at the beginning of the year, or nearly so, then you can budget that for needs throughout the year. The only real benefit would be to the people who aren't responsible enough to budget that and splurge on something because they suddenly have more money. If that's the case, there are bigger issues here that this program will only hide.
- insane_dreamer 4y agoI didn't mean existing programs. As others have pointed out, the Child Tax Credit was a huge boon to low income families, but sadly discontinued since "cash handouts is socialism and in America, we believe in capitalism, darn it!" That's the type of program that could make a difference.
- giantg2 4y agoDid it really make a difference? The amount increased and it went to monthly payments instead of yearly. But all the claims I saw about it were linked to necessities like how many children were adequately fed (which the free lunch program could possibly be a confoundingnl factor) and not to any longterm benefit like actually moving up to middle class (which we are discussing here). In fact, middle class and wealthy families benefited the most while poor families recieved the least. I could be wrong, but one of the biggest deceptions of the program seemed to be how many people were "lifted out of poverty" simply because monthly payments were included as monthly income whereas the lump payment before would not be, thus lifting peoples monthly income above the poverty level even though it was largely the same amount overall. The program may have been beneficial, but expanding it would mean lining the pockets of the middle class and rich more than the poor without drastic changes. And we have no data to show it truly reducing poverty.