3 ms·
Reducing the U.S. military budget by 20% and spending it on poverty relief programs could eliminate poverty to a large degree in the U.S. (not entirely, but tha
by insane_dreamer 4y ago
Reducing the U.S. military budget by 20% and spending it on poverty relief programs could eliminate poverty to a large degree in the U.S. (not entirely, but that's unrealistic).
It's not that the government doesn't have the money or that we're not paying enough in taxes. It's that we're spending it on the wrong things (if we want to have a generally prosperous and stable society).
- prottog 4y agoAs the article rightly points out, the US has spent more money over time on the poor, not less, with middling effect. Whether or not the military budget is bloated, there's no evidence to suggest that yet more money for the poor would result in better outcomes. Articles like this never address some fundamental questions that would be much more enlightening: * Why does poverty persist in any country? Is there any country where there are no poor? * It states that the percentage of the poor in the US stayed relatively constant over time. But is it the same people (and their descendants) who are staying poor, or are the poor of one generation (or their descendants) able to lift themselves out of poverty into a stable middle-class life? Instead it chooses to frame most economic choices made by the poor as being "exploitative", and at the same breath blames payday loan companies for being predatory and yet posits that the poor need greater access to credit.
- dfxm12 4y agoPutting cash into poor people's pockets is the best single way to spend the money, yes, but I think that article makes a great case that as long as banks, employers, landlords, etc. can take advantage of the poor, poverty will continue. So there has to be more of a policy component here. Biden recently talked about limiting "junk fees" for example - we need more focus on stuff like that, and incidentally, these policies probably help all Americans.
- blindriver 4y agoGiving people living in generational poverty a handout is the BEST way to keep them enslaved on government largesse. You need to take that money and invest in their neighborhoods and lift the entire neighborhood out of poverty by educating them. My God, how many eons is the saying "Give a man a fish..." been around? Yet the best idea we still have is to hand money out to absolve ourselves of collective guilt? Look at San Francisco. Their homelessness budget is over $600 million a year, and yet, homelessness is the WORST its ever been. That's because homelessness "activists" keep the homeless as farm animals, living in homelessness without actually trying to help them elevate themselves. Look at the open drug markets and free access to drugs and needles they have. This is all to keep them enslaved in drugs and homeless without trying to help them. Because if they solve the problem of homelessness, they won't have jobs anymore. They are like the pharmaceutical industry except at the grassroots level.
- MSFT_Edging 4y agoPoverty is cyclical. It continues because it's expensive to be poor, and one road block multiplies to many roadblocks. You're upset about the SF homelessness budget and homelessness activists, but what is your solution? break up homeless camps and throw all their earthly possessions into a dumpster, then tell them to "elevate themselves" at the shelter where they're more likely to be assaulted and stolen from? Or maybe send as many to prison as you can to "teach them a lesson"? Can you point to a study where safe injection sites make drug problems worse? Can you point to anything where its physically possible to "pull oneself up by their bootstraps"? Look, I get it, you don't like looking at them, they make you feel bad, you don't want to see them as human. But you can't just solve poverty by telling the diseffected masses to become an entrepreneur.
- prottog 4y agoYou're attributing a lot of intent to the GP ("you don't want to see them as human") that wasn't written. I don't think there's anything wrong in asking what kind of results the nearly $700m that San Francisco has budgeted for the homeless has gotten the city, and why the idea persists that more money would alleviate the problem. It's ipso facto sensible that giving people addicted to drugs an upside to continue their addiction (i.e. a safe place to consume said drugs) and no downside (i.e. no threat of jail time) will make them in fact continue to be addicted and unable to become productive members of society. If you're asking for studies, it's incumbent upon you to prove why it would be otherwise.
- insane_dreamer 4y ago> Giving people living in generational poverty a handout is the BEST way to keep them enslaved on government largesse. in some cases that may be true; but UBI trials have also shown that they make a huge difference in people lives. It's not just the jobless/homeless, it's the working poor.
- giantg2 4y ago"and spending it on poverty relief programs could eliminate poverty to a large degree in the U.S." No, it won't, assuming you're talking about existing programs. The current programs aren't designed to fix the problems the recipients face. They're merely designed to keep people alive (food, medical care, etc). They have absolutely nothing to do with getting those people jobs with pay high enough to exit the support system. Many of the people on those relief programs work, but simply don't make enough. So in that regard your last sentence allpies to your own statement: "It's that we're spending it on the wrong things".
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThe Child Tax Credit of 2021 has been massively successful. That's probably why there's massive pressure to let it expire.
- giantg2 4y agoWasn't the child tax credit change just that it was sent monthly instead of with the tax refund?
- bryanlarsen 4y agoIt also increased from $2000 to $3600. But yes the change from monthly to annual is also a significantly positive change for poor families.
- giantg2 4y agoThe amount I can see being a big help. I have trouble understanding how the monthly part is really any better. In theory, if you get it back at the beginning of the year, or nearly so, then you can budget that for needs throughout the year. The only real benefit would be to the people who aren't responsible enough to budget that and splurge on something because they suddenly have more money. If that's the case, there are bigger issues here that this program will only hide.
- 4y ago