9 ms·
The FBI Just Admitted It Bought US Location Data
- fIREpOK 4y agoIts OK, nobody cares... /s?
- b112 4y agoJust use facebook to send (Biden|Trump) force FBI to ..., as a tailored story to each voter. Now all will care.
- mistermann 4y agoI've been doing some experimentation in ChatGPT with this, and it is amazing. With just slightly different ChatGPT query prompts, extremely different, conflicting narratives for a given event can be produced, and each of them sounds/seems perfectly reasonable, and True. For someone to be invulnerable to this sort of thing, they would have to have fairly substantial background in several different obscure domains (none of which are taught in school, quite conveniently), as well as violate several strongly enforced social norms (ie: engaging in "pedantry", thinking in ways we've been trained to pattern match to conspiratorial thinking, falling for Russian propaganda, etc). It does not surprise me in the least how much polarization there is in society over what is actually going on, and how each side genuinely believes that they are take on it is correct. It seems (to me) almost like the system has been deliberately designed to produce this output, because it certainly isn't that hard to figure out how to vastly improve on it.
- AndyMcConachie 4y agoI care, but it's not I can do anything about it. It's not that no one cares. It's that the people who care are powerless, and those empowered don't care.
- BLKNSLVR 4y agoCorrection: those who are empowered care - about maintaining the status quo
- lmm 4y agoI don't see how the FBI buying data that's for sale in the open market is any worse than the likes of Equifax doing so, and no-one seems to care about that.
- fIREpOK 4y agoInstead of doing it, the government should create laws to make it illegal (exactly what is up for debate)
- timeon 4y agoVoters should require it as well.
- chaxor 4y agoThis is what is extremely strange to me (by principle). When the government does it, it seems to make many more headlines and people are outraged, but when a company does it, there is far more acceptance. In principle, it should be far more concerning to see private entities getting access to personal data - because they operate without any opportunity for the public to be involved (their pure tyrannies in a sense) and are completely opaque, but the government is far more transparent and the one institution which you can change by democratic involvement. Of course, this type of data gathering is concerning in any case, but the government is the last on the list of entities we should be worried about having it.
- neckardt 4y agoHistorically, there are several instances of governments accumulating more and more power until they turn into a totalitarian state and remove freedoms from their citizens. I don't know of any companies who have abused their power to that extent.
- altacc 4y agoHistorically (and currently) there are many companies that directly or indirectly working to limit freedoms, either alone or complicit with governments. Corporations are powerful and in many places have as much power over people as governments. It can be as varied as surveillance (Cisco in China) to murdering opponents (Shell in Nigeria), to industry lobbying. Look around and you'll find many more. The solution to the problem is to go down the EU route of reducing the rights of anyone to collect all this information and make it harder to access that which is collected. It's by no means perfect but it is the right direction.
- perfecthjrjth 4y agoThe third-party doctrine makes it legal to acquire data from third parties, without any consent or warrant.
- adolph 4y ago“To my knowledge, we do not currently purchase commercial database information that includes location data derived from internet advertising,” Wray said. “I understand that we previously—as in the past—purchased some such information for a specific national security pilot project. But that’s not been active for some time.” He added that the bureau now relies on a “court-authorized process” to obtain location data from companies.
- phiy 4y agoI thought this paragraph was super weasely. He is specifically saying that they don't buy directly from internet advertising sources, but there are private intel firms[1] that act as middle-men. They offer an interface and tooling that is geared for national security purposes. The wording of this comment specifically excludes a conclusion on private intel firms. Private Intel middle men would still evade application of the Carpenter decision, and it is obviously superior for the government to work with an agency like that do to human rights and what-not. [1] https://www.vice.com/en/article/qj454d/private-intelligence-location-data-xmode-hyas https://www.vice.com/en/article/qj454d/private-intelligence-...
- adolph 4y agoReminds me of a decade before: “What I wanted to see is if you could give me a yes or no answer to the question ‘Does the N.S.A. collect any type of data at all on millions or hundreds of millions of Americans?’ ” [. . .] “Not wittingly,” Clapper replied. He started scratching his forehead and looked away from Wyden. “There are cases where they could inadvertently perhaps collect, but not wittingly.” https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2013/12/16/state-of-deception https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2013/12/16/state-of-decep...
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoBecause they don't. The NSA is foreign intelligence. If a foreign target communicates with an American then that is what he means. His answer makes perfect sense to me.
- juanani 4y ago[dead]
- southernplaces7 4y agoIn other news, Sky officially confirmed as often being blue.
- miga 4y agoThe trouble here is not FBI at all. This purchase is just a proof that privacy protections given by US law are totally ineffective. As soon as the data is on the open market, no GDPR, and no US law protects the customer, since public prosecution is not interested in blatant violation of privacy here. This is also the main reason why EU continuously threatens US with withdrawing _safe harbor_ provisions. As soon as the data enters US, the open market assures it will be widely available contrary to all regulations.
- geraldhh 4y ago> EU continuously threatens US with withdrawing _safe harbor_ provisions safe harbor was invalidated in 2015, replaced by "Privacy Shield" which was overturned in 2020. Now "Trans-Atlantic Data Privacy Framework" is being worked on but i suspect it won't hold up either because muricans can't even protect their own citizens from governmental spying let alone foreigners. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trans-Atlantic_Data_Privacy_Framework https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trans-Atlantic_Data_Privacy_Fr...
- throw_a_grenade 4y agoNARRATOR: It's year 2068. ECJ just declared "EU-US Whatever Shield, This Time For Real" invalid in the case known as Schrems LXIV.
- petesergeant 4y agoI'd agree that the FBI using legal means to get their hands on data isn't proof the FBI has done something wrong, but I would worry that if the FBI came to rely on it, they might be motivated to further impede better privacy protections.
- tremon 4y ago> the FBI using legal means to get their hands on data isn't proof the FBI has done something wrong Perhaps not, but the FBI using one method to get their hands on data without a warrant, while a different method to acquire that same data would require a warrant, is definitely a sign that something is going wrong.
- causality0 4y agoThis is only news if your opinion of institutions is much higher than it should be. Any large organization has bad actors in it. Undesired behavior is reduced/filtered first by culture, then by policy, then by law, then by technical ability. Anyone at the FBI who cares to has the technical ability to invade your privacy on a whim. Barrier removed. Whether or not it's technically illegal, any law that isn't enforced effectively doesn't exist. Barrier removed. It's openly admitted to having a policy that changes with its needs. Barrier removed. It sure as shit doesn't have an organizational culture geared toward respecting people and their privacy.
- petesergeant 4y ago> Anyone at the FBI who cares to has the technical ability to invade your privacy on a whim Is that true, though? I certainly don't believe any Google employee has the ability to read my email without consequence.
- xwolfi 4y agoWell think of it that way, the policy might be here, the punishment planned for and the monitoring in place. Then ofc there s a way to bypass it to debug prod incidents without a lawyer present, and so anyone can read anything. I hope you re right, but I ve worked at a company that had very sensitive data on individuals and I could see it all. We were even GDPR compliant: Im a french citizen working in China and I can ssh to a finland database no problem: the data never left Europe ... that was our interpretation of it anyway and an audit would have had trouble to fault us, for various reasons. I had a girlfriend working at a giant telco... showing ME proudly the graph of all calls for the day she had to browse for something... and she was remoting on the private vpn all good and compliant... but nobody controls who else is behind the screen. Best is not to commit crimes on public spaces, and not assume public spaces are private: even letters can be intercepted by the mailman, so... I think you can reasonably expect that it would be hard for one of your enemies to access your data for nefarious reason, but I always assume random access by an employee is possible.
- deleted 4y ago
- DlSGUSTlNG 4y ago[dead]
- LatteLazy 4y agoTo me, the weirdest thing about this is that the US already has total government surveillance and all the massive issues that come with that. Then instead of just using that, the FBI play this weird game of paying for the same data privately. It's like watching the Army rent tanks when they have 1000s sat in storage waiting to be used or something.
- reustle 4y agoThey would probably need warrants to get access to the other data within the gov.
- LatteLazy 4y agoThat is what confuses me. The data is freely available for things like undermining democracy, the rule of law, having an internal US coup etc. But using it to solve murders would be overreach.
- Synaesthesia 4y agoIn an interview with Seymour Hersh recently he also mentioned how in the George W Bush era, the FBI was illegally using NSA wiretap on Americans to prosecute cases. In many instances he said, the oversight actually does work. Sometimes though, it doesn't.
- Broken_Hippo 4y agoIt isn't overreach if you have a warrant. Seriously, police (and agencies like the FBI) already abuse any power they have and should have more oversight. These government agencies already undermine democracy - usually in other countries, though - and I'm not sure of any example of this sort of thing being purchased to undermine democracy (except at government levels). Sure, it could be used like that, but folks have monitored locations of assassination targets long, long before we ever had such technology. All that said, I don't think this sort of information should be for sale to anyone. If the police agencies actually need such a thing, they should have limited scope and a warrant. The larger the scope, the more folks should have to sign off on the warrant. Police - because of their power - shouldn't have free access to such things even if the criminals have them. Following "rule of law" doesn't mean folks are doing immoral or wrong things as the laws aren't always just - and often, the methods of change include illegal things, hopefully nonviolent.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoI actually want the FBI and law enforcement to to buy and use commercial data to solve crimes. Otherwise, we will end up with private investigators for the rich who have access to commercial data and hobbled law enforcement for everyone else who are prevented from accessing commercial data. If the data can be bought on the open market, law enforcement should have access to it.
- Broken_Hippo 4y agoThere is limited use for private investigators - and the end result is rarely the systematic oppression of people, rarely involved someone in prison, rarely involves things like violence, and rarely are using tax money to do it. I'd also argue that more often, a PI isn't for someone rich and famous, but rich enough to afford it and has reason to hire. (divorce, for example). If the police need to purchase such information, they should have to get a warrant like they do for other things. Someone (or two) not involved in the investigation should have to agree that it is necessary. Law enforcement should be somewhat hobbled because the opportunity for abuse is much greater, especially to general society because of its reach.
- seanw444 4y agoIn short: PIs are limited in what they can actually do. They can't imprison you or kill you. However, the government has the monopoly on violence and imprisonment. Seems pretty clear to me which one should be able to purchase this information and which one shouldn't.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoGood. The data shouldn't be for sale in the first place. These are attempts to deflect the data privacy issue away from tech giants and toward our favorite punching bag, law enforcement.
- AbrahamParangi 4y agoIt’s not just a deflection. If I could choose for my data to be public to everyone except for the government or private to everyone except for the government I would choose the former.
- prepend 4y agoThis is bad, but the data is for sale. I think the solution it not allowing data sales. It seems odd that we’re upset that the FBI did what anyone else in the world can do, but data on US citizens. When I read that, I though “duh, of course, everyone buys data.”
- uncletammy 4y ago" Anyone else in the world " cant build a criminal case against you using parallel construction tactics while bypassing American's constitutional right to due process.
- voiper1 4y agoI'm pretty sure "due process" means being tried in a court of law. Buying data doesn't skip being tried in court. I assume you're implicitly referencing that the FBI is skipping getting a warrant, but why do they need a warrant? Your information is already publicly for sale. As other's have mentioned, it's not really an FBI issue, it's a general privacy issue - that companies are collecting, compiling, and selling this information and it's all legal. Which is darned hard to get people to care about - because it's convenient to give your information away. I know about these things and still use google for almost everything (I finally moved my business email to fastmail... but didn't yet bother to move my personal email.)
- justinclift 4y ago> Buying data doesn't skip being tried in court. That's an interesting point. Wonder how foolproof/incorruptible the chain of custody is supposed to be for the provided data? We've probably all worked on IT systems at one point or another that the outside world regards as really good, but the admins / ops staff know is really held together with sticky tape + bubblegum. Sometimes with data not quite being stored as it was entered (heh MySQL springs to mind).
- jasonlotito 4y ago
- throwawaaarrgh 4y agoEveryone buys that data. It's not a secret, it's not illegal, and they'd be crazy not to.
- loonginthetooth 4y agoYeah this is kind of a "Breaking: Water is wet" headline.
- EGreg 4y agoI wrote about this years ago: https://magarshak.com/blog/?p=169 https://magarshak.com/blog/?p=169
- alasdair_ 4y ago"simple" solution (that breaks a whole lot of the world as we know it): Make a law that states people have ownership (including copyright) over their own PII. If that goes too far, do something like the UK's Data Protection Act of 1998 that insists almost all PII is subject to review by the individual and they can demand erroneous data be fixed. They can also demand deletion in various scenarios. But personally, I like the copyright idea. If a copy of a song can be protected from being made legally, even if I personally make the copy, I see no reason why my most personal of details cannot be similarly protected.
- m463 4y ago> I like the copyright idea I used to add a copyright notice to the bottom of my resume, to prevent distribution. Don't know how well this works practically speaking, especially in this electronic day and age.
- ronsor 4y agoThe public policy reason is that facts can't be copyrighted, whether that's a street address or GPS coordinates at 5:32 PM.
- alasdair_ 4y agoIt's a "fact" that a book has specific words in a specific order, yet we're not allowed to share that fact with other people without legal repercussions. I fully understand laws are not written by computer scientists and that nuance is involved, I'm just saying that the idea that PII could be copyrightable doesn't seem THAT crazy to me.
- geodel 4y agoHuh, one can obviously share snippets of paragraphs or pages for review and all for books. Same with address, it is snippet of information about a person and not the whole detail of everything in a house.
- 4y ago
- bastard_op 4y agoWell why wouldn't they? They have no perceivable budget, clandestine in nature, and need all info on everything, so why wouldn't they be even the highest bidder to any and all info related to their affairs? If I were to impose my will as a dictator of a nation or crime organization with an unlimited budget, it's what I would do too.
- emodendroket 4y agoThey'd be fools not to. Why would anybody anticipate they wouldn't?