5 ms·
Fixing typos in "search" illustrates the difference between "search" as a means to find out whether something exists in a database versus a means for an adverti
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago
Fixing typos in "search" illustrates the difference between "search" as a means to find out whether something exists in a database versus a means for an advertising company to direct the searcher to the most optimum page for supporting advertising services.1
What is the difference between showing someone the winning advertisement versus showing them the winning "search result".1 The advertising company makes a decision according to secret criteria which ad/search result to show. A long, successful tradition of using alphabetical or chronological sorting for information, objective criteria, is jettisoned in favour of manipulation for commercial benefit of a middleman. The advertising company gets to decide what comes first and last, according to subjective criteria. Then make it infeasible to see what is last.
Google has admitted that in the majority of cases, an appropriate ad does not exist to pair with a given search query. That is what I call the noncommercial web. It has little direct value to "tech" companies and advertisers. Yet "tech" company intermediaries want to surveil and control our access to it nonetheless. As the parent states, "most of the internet is walled off."
In sum, the advertising company, and "AI", allow people to search for web content that exists, cf. allowing people to search for whether certain web content exists. The advertising company will make "suggestions". However not all content that exists is made searchable by the advertising company. If the content has no commercial value, e.g., it is "unpopular", it is considered garbage.3
1. When we search Wikipedia, typos do not result in "guessing" by an advertising company. If something does not exist, Wikipedia does not try to guess "what we want".
2. The term "winning" applies because the advertising company makes the process an actual auction or an effective contest.
3. If the web is mostly garbage, then its users should be entitled to know that through discovery. It seems as if the discoverable web, the one optimised for the advertising company, is mostly commercial garbage anyway. It is difficult to be serious about "AI" when it is trained on mostly garbage.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- klooney 4y agoI'm really on the fence about Kagi. Results are good, but I'm just so accustomed to search being free.
- jackson1442 4y agoIt's hard to articulate, but especially in the past year I've noticed that Google (the search engine) has become a place that serves the advertisers more than the users. Adding more and more ads to the top of the feed, doing effectively nothing to combat SEO spam (that generally has AdSense on the site), etc. Kagi comparatively feels like a search engine that serves me as the user. It's a hard difference to spot, but the results _feel_ higher quality because I've curated them to suit what I actually want to see when I search the web. If there's a site that's unreadable due to adblock-block nonsense or is generally very low quality, I can block it and move on. If there's something that generally has good content, I can raise it to prioritize it in results, or if it's something that I know I'll want to see a lot of (like AWS documentation when relevant), I can pin it to the top of the feed.
- zikduruqe 4y ago> It's hard to articulate, but especially in the past year I've noticed that Google (the search engine) has become a place that serves the advertisers more than the users. Not hard at all to articulate... Google is not a search engine, but an ad platform. https://freakonomics.com/podcast/is-google-getting-worse/ https://freakonomics.com/podcast/is-google-getting-worse/ "It used to feel like magic. Now it can feel like a set of cheap tricks. Is the problem with Google — or with us?"
- user3939382 4y agoI like paying because I know my interests as the user are Kagi’s priority. With these “free” solutions of course the priority is the advertisers which is often at conflict with users.
- eitland 4y agoFor most techies in the west at least the price of Kagi should be next to nothing. I personally will happily pay $10 a month for a search engine that works and takes search quality seriously and has its incentives aligned with my best interest. And no, Google, Bing and DDG are utterly broken for many of the searches I do every week and I have written about it a number of times here and elsewhere since 10 years ago.
- potatoman22 4y agoFixing typos and ordering results by relevance instead of recency enhance user experience. They also help serve better ads, but do you really want the top result to be the page that was first indexed 3 minutes ago?
- svat 4y ago> If something does not exist, Wikipedia does not try to guess "what we want". Try it out: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Search&search=typograpihcal+error https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Search&se... > Showing results for typographical error. No results found for typograpihcal error.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoPerhaps this illustrates the importance of defaults. Consider which defaults favour advertising. Search Wikipedia for "exmaple.com", a common error when typing the string "example.com". By default, the results are the pages that contain this exact string. https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?limit=500&profile=all&search=exmaple.com&ns0=1&useskin=vector https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?limit=500&profile=all&s... Now try the same query with Google. To get pages with this exact string, one needs to enclose the string in quotes. By default the results will not be pages that contain the string. "Tech" companies want people to believe "search" and "suggestions" (non-objective ranking, insertion of "popular" items, insertion of the search provider's own web properties, etc.) are the same thing. I have no issue with suggestions. Sometimes, but not all times, suggestions are helpful. However I do have an issue with people believing search and suggestions are the same thing. IIRC, there was a point in the past where Google was ignoring quotes and there were some HN threads about the subject.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoIn truth the Wikipedia search results do not contain the exact string "exmaple.com". It appears Wikipedia drops the .com and queries for the string "exmaple", in both singular and plural forms.