2 ms·
TFA is light on quotes, but it seems to come down to "China could feed misinformation to users". That's the most concrete claim I've seen. I'd buy that it coul
by jfengel 4y ago
TFA is light on quotes, but it seems to come down to "China could feed misinformation to users". That's the most concrete claim I've seen.
I'd buy that it could happen, but I'm still not sure it's worth "screaming" about. We get plenty of misinformation, and disinformation, via US-owned channels.
One could imagine a sinister plot where they develop a detailed model of you and use it to concoct the perfect disinformation campaign targeted at you, engaging enough so you don't shut it off, subtle enough that it isn't obvious and annoying. It's not impossible; even mediocre targeting tools have led to some pretty impressive targeted propaganda campaigns. What could they do with the information that is currently useful enough to make it a near-addiction?
And yet, it seems unlikely to me. The alternative is "they're making a ton of money", which seems a perfectly ordinary thing for them to do. That sinister plot seems to hinge on a lot of things going in their favor, like TikTok users not just moving on to the next shiny thing that catches their attention.
Maybe the FBI has more reason to believe that this really is China's plan than they can let on. But it really looks to me just like they beat us at our own game, selling entertainment, and doing it on the cheap.
- cwkoss 4y agoI think it's plausible that the deep state feels threatened by Tiktok because it is out of reach of US misinformation campaigns: Tiktok has the power to counterprogram against falsehoods spread by US officials. We've seen how cozy Twitter is with the state. I wonder if any US propaganda falsehoods have been corrected by Tiktok already or if this a just a threat to national orwellian potential.