Yeah, this sounds like they are using Nature as an advertising platform to hype up their work. I didn't realise it was possible to publish a paper with the pre

Yeah, this sounds like they are using Nature as an advertising platform to hype up their work. I didn't realise it was possible to publish a paper with the premise that details required to reproduce it are omitted in some sort of weird guessing game... It makes sense that the allegations focus on analysing data manipulation. Maybe it's real, maybe it's fake, but the extreme scepticism seems deserved if they aren't going to be completely open and have a history of doing the same thing over and over.