6 ms·
I broke a wine glass with my voice (2018) [video]
- pipeline_peak 4y ago[flagged]
- TekMol 4y agoDid he?
- pipeline_peak 4y agooh yeah...https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xIuon6CUKz0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xIuon6CUKz0
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vore 4y agoThis is an extremely weird thing to be bringing up in the comments here. I certainly wouldn't want anyone commemorating ("Rip"? really?) my Internet stalkers like this.
- pipeline_peak 4y ago[flagged]
- 0x7ce 4y ago[dead]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bil7 4y agocool trick. Great channel. Mike's is also very high quality entertainment. Here's hoping Diana recovers from her ME/CFS swiftly.
- docflabby 4y agoIt's not something you recover quickly from :(
- jcims 4y agoDianna (Physics Girl) is currently experiencing severe complications from ME/CFS/long COVID. Per the last update on her twitter: The last weeks were scary. ER visits were hard. Dianna still can’t walk, or even sit up in bed. But we see signs of progress. Sleeping more. Eating more. More treatments coming. Update here - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vydgkCCXbTA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vydgkCCXbTA https://twitter.com/thephysicsgirl https://twitter.com/thephysicsgirl
- therein 4y ago[flagged]
- agolio 4y ago[flagged]
- taywrobel 4y agoWell, a Ph.D.-level explanation wouldn't be nearly as approachable or interesting to the 1.2M people that watched it.
- agolio 4y agoI have nothing against the video, and I am all for making science exciting for the broader audience. I just am not sure why it is at the top of HN.
- melenaboija 4y agoSome people might be aware of her situation along with the impact of her work and maybe think that having one of her videos at the front page of HN could be a way to help. At least that why I upvoted it.
- agolio 4y agoSeems you are right and I would have saved my criticism with that knowledge. Though I do think that information should have been in the submission title then. Ah well, best wishes to her.
- gus_massa 4y agoI watched the video a few years ago. Before watching the video, I though the trick to break the cup was to sing very loud and very close to the tuned to natural resonance frequency of the glass, so the movement of the glass and the air inside are so big that breaks the resistance of the glass suddenly. Like swinging a swing until you got a 360°. In the video I learned that the important part are the micro cracks of the glass. If you sign loud and tuned up, the micro cracks begin to grow, and grow, and grow, until they are so big that one of them is big enough to break the glass. The differences are that it's also important to sing for a long time to make the micro cracks grow, and that the exact moment is difficult to predict because it's not when the singer is extremely tuned but when the invisible crack are big enough. (I also learned that it's possible to cheat and make a small crack on the border to break the glass faster and consistently and impress your friends. (I broke a glass singing, so I never had an opportunity to used that trick anyway.))
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ortusdux 4y agoI've heard that back in the day conservatories would use this as part of their entrance exam. It is a great way to test if someone can recreate a specific pitch by ear.
- causi 4y agoI wonder what percentage of the failures to recreate a pitch are due to people not being able to adjust for the difference when they're hearing it through their own skull.
- bashinator 4y agoI'm going to go with 0%, given that the fundamental pitch of a sound is unaffected by material interference. I suppose exceptionally high-pitched tones above several thousand hertz might be affected, but nothing within the range of a human voice.
- causi 4y agoThe human throat cannot produce a completely pure tone. The bones and tissues of the skull do not resonate perfectly with all harmonics, resonating more strongly with the lower harmonics. This magnification of lower harmonics distorts the perceived tone of sound coming from inside the head.
- bashinator 4y agoNothing about that is going to make the fundamental pitch of a sound you hear seem like a different frequency than it is. It will affect your perception of the complex overtones as you say, but matching the fundamental frequency you're singing with the resonant frequency of the glass does not involve complex overtones.
- galgot 4y agoDunno if true, but resonance frequency is the reason German military always avoided making goose step military marches across bridges. I suppose it would depends on the bridge anyway... But would have been fun to watch.
- bombcar 4y agoBreaking stride on bridges has been known to (some) militaries since the Roman times iirc.
- taco_emoji 4y agoMythbusters did an episode on this! I totally cannot remember what they concluded
- McSwag 4y agoThey did and if I remember correctly they concluded it was busted. I remember this episode in particular because I didn’t feel like their tests were completely sound and didn’t accurately model a civil engineered life-size bridge so at best the result should have been inconclusive.
- Doxin 4y agoThe machines they built to simulate the marching was entirely inadequate. A much better way to test it would've been a weight on a voice coil, and a contact microphone to monitor echoes. They'd still probably be unable to tear down the bridge model they built, as that thing seemed to be way overbuilt.
- jaclaz 4y agoIt was later re-tested and re-classified as plausible (for some reasons the particualr episode was aired in EU but not in the US): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MythBusters_(2004_season)#Episode_14_.E2.80.93_.22Myths_Revisited.22 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MythBusters_(2004_season)#Epis...
- burningion 4y agoI did this with Python and Pygame a ways back, and was also inspired by Mike Boyd. The code and an STL to focus a speaker are linked in a repo: https://www.makeartwithpython.com/blog/break-glass-with-resonant-frequency/ https://www.makeartwithpython.com/blog/break-glass-with-reso...
- silveira 4y agohttps://www.patreon.com/physicsgirl https://www.patreon.com/physicsgirl to help her recovery.