4 ms·
Wow. Is Bloomberg actually a credible business publication? Barring a serious housing surplus, or similar major economic problems, there are ~no upsides for p
by bell-cot 4y ago
Wow. Is Bloomberg actually a credible business publication?
Barring a serious housing surplus, or similar major economic problems, there are ~no upsides for political leaders who actually work to attract more residents to an area. (Attracting more & higher bidders, for the limited housing stock, is a different story.)
Vs. "attracting new business"? That attracts plenty of favorable press, bragging rights, etc. And for local governments - which live on property taxes and have to fund the schools & local services - every dollar worth of business properties is a money farm, and every dollar worth of residential housing is a money pit.
- comte7092 4y agoEven in the era of remote work, businesses are attracted to places with strong (as in a well developed & highly skilled workforce) labor markets. Workers who have high career capital are mobile and can generally choose where they want to live. Nothing about this is unserious just because it doesn’t fit your worldview.
- bluGill 4y agoThat depends. Factory work is often attracted to a dieing town in the middle of nowhere they can scoup up cheap labor that is just skilled enough. You can only get your factory so large doing this though, but there are towns of 5-10k people that fit the bill just fine for manufacturing cheap in the US.
- comte7092 4y agoYes indeed, however that isn’t really an economic development model most would want to hold up as an ideal.
- bluGill 4y agoThose small towns won't get anything better and know it do they consider it their best possible model.
- comte7092 4y agoYes, I’m just saying that I don’t see how that is a generalizable mode outside of that narrow circumstance. There may be a large number of small towns, but most people and most economic activity happens in larger urban areas, and that’s what is germane to the article’s argument.
- pessimizer 4y ago> there are ~no upsides for political leaders who actually work to attract more residents to an area. The article is about attracting more wealthy residents to an area. It doesn't say it that directly, but it does directly reference the new work-from-home upper-middle-class, and how they can live anywhere now. I don't think the indirectness is being sneaky, it's more trying to be polite.
- DoneWithAllThat 4y agoTo answer your opening question: no, Bloomberg has not been a credible business publication for some time. They’re one of the legacy publications that used their name recognition and reputation as a springboard to essentially a paid op-Ed publication - authors pay them to have their opinion pieces published. See also: Newsweek.
- mattkrause 4y agoFWIW, I've always found Matt Levine's "Money Stuff" column to be funny and informative.
- throwaway6734 4y agoOdd lots is an amazing podcast as well
- legitster 4y agoBloomberg is actually a good publication - especially their print edition. But most people's exposure only comes from the op-eds - people who only read the op-eds are not reading the boring but competent reporting on the pages in between.
- legitster 4y agoDid you actually read the article? > If Amazon stiffs Northern Virginia, future politicians elsewhere may be less eager to promise tax breaks and infrastructure investments, not to mention spend their reputational capital. Politically speaking, it will be harder for urban and suburban leaders to rise to the top by attracting a new major corporate tenants. “Pro-business” local governments may be less common in the years to come. If anything, the politicians who blocked Amazon from coming to Queens actually got more bragging rights.
- RetpolineDrama 4y ago> and every dollar worth of residential housing is a money pit. This can't possibly be true in any of the municipalities I've ever lived in. Property taxes are insane, like fancy private school tuition insane and it's definitely not going into the roads. Actually lets break it down: Power, water, and sewer are paid for by their consumption. My local utilities actually have the problem that they _make_ too much money. Roads are paid for by fuel/registration taxes/insane vehicle sales tax. Schools are paid by property tax, but every public school in every jurisdiction I've ever lived in has been inferior to private while costing me almost as much via property tax. Then there's Fire and Police, but those costs should be minimal and distributed over the huge number of residents. Then there's the mail, oh wait that's again funded by usage. Zoning and code compliance? Again, absolutely minimal costs there. Permits cost $... so again funded by usage! Central planning for development? _What_ planning? lol. I know where this is coming from, poorly researched and often-dishonest narrative from "not just bikes" and their ilk. In reality residential communities are huge tax farms. Every watt of power, gallon of water, etc is *paid for* (including a healthy markup). The damn roads don't cost $15k/year.
- loganmhb 4y agoThe roads might actually cost more than that: https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2019/4/30/my-city-has-massive-infrastructure-liabilities-so-do-99-of-the-cities-in-america https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2019/4/30/my-city-has-ma...
- btilly 4y agoI have no idea whether it is true where you are, but it certainly IS true where I am. First, commercial property taxes in California are generally higher than residential. Which is an incentive to attract business, not residents. https://www.hechtgroup.com/the-different-taxes-imposed-on-commercial-and-residential-property-in-california/ https://www.hechtgroup.com/the-different-taxes-imposed-on-co... Second, you're seriously underestimating the cost of roads. As https://www.amazon.com/High-Cost-Free-Parking-Updated/dp/193236496X https://www.amazon.com/High-Cost-Free-Parking-Updated/dp/193... pointed out, the bit of road your car is parked on usually costs more than the car. Now walk around your neighborhood and look at how much road there is. ALL of it costs that much. Most of us don't think about it, but it has to be paid for somehow. And it really isn't cheap.
- beebmam 4y ago"Corporations are people" - Mitt Romney Competing for residents IS competing for businesses, with maybe a few exceptions for resource extraction.
- 464628346 4y agoThis seems like a false dichotomy. Politicians try to attract new businesses because those businesses, if nothing else, attract these things called employees. The advantage of the approach is that you can try to attract more of the kinds of residents you want instead of just "anybody". Most places have plenty of "anybody" already. What else does better as a medium of attraction for worthwhile people? Walkability? Save that for the Europeans who pretend like boasting Paris and (formerly) London qualifies them to talk about managing large cities. Civil services? I'm salaried and I've got a car, the only reason I'd use most common civil services is either because my ride is in the shop or I was literally stabbed and needed the ER. Otherwise you couldn't /pay/ me to deal with the kinds of people who take the bus. Meanwhile parks and libraries are for the homeless and parents in denial about the times. So what's left to brag about to attract people?