3 ms·
>So if you argue that we can use ChatGPT to make a fact checker then I agree. It is unclear how accurate it would be, but at least then we have something that t
by coldtea 4y ago
>So if you argue that we can use ChatGPT to make a fact checker then I agree. It is unclear how accurate it would be, but at least then we have something that tries to evaluate truthiness. But ChatGPT itself doesn't use such a layer, so it doesn't have a truth model.
Why would it need such a layer? That's begging the question.
The parent just asked ChatGPT to do fact checking, and it did, with success. It could get it wrong sometimes too, but then so can humans.
But you're "no true Scotchman" it hard, as well as "moving the goalposts", and "begging the question"...
If it can use the corpus + the output selection mechanism it has to perform fact checking when you ask it to, and the output it gives matches with the expected results we'd expect from someone doing fact-checking (or is even better than how some humans would go about it), then it does fact-checking.
That's regardless of whether it has some dedicated "fact-checking" faculty or its result is "just" the result of a huge markov-chain like process.
Heck, humans can be said to also not have any dedicated "fact-checking faculty" as nobody has ever built one. We just have neurons and weighted connections between them. The "fact checking" we do is just a result of a general purpose machinery: those neurons firing and being connected in particular patterns as trained by real world sensory input during our lifetime.
If it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck, it's a duck, even if it doesn't have a mystical "duck" layer.