4 ms·
The solution is to bring in huge amounts of military police from other parts of the state or country, and arm the citizens. Street gangs and police gangs are an
by carlosjobim 4y ago
The solution is to bring in huge amounts of military police from other parts of the state or country, and arm the citizens. Street gangs and police gangs are analogous to having armed battalions of enemy soldiers in your city, that calls for a military response.
- vorpalhex 4y ago1. If you think gangs in police are bad, wait until you find out about gangs in the military 2. You probably almost certainly do not want martial law. 3. The military is not an intelligence organization.
- carlosjobim 4y agoYou can have military police without martial law. You can split investigative units from the enforcing/order keeping battalions, the military does not need to be involved in investigative work. Most lawyers could be suited for investigative police work. Gangs would have a hard time forming in battalions mixed by people from all over the country.
- vorpalhex 4y agoMost military gangs form on aircraft carriers. Lots of people + difficult day to day + natural divisions (everything is shift work, work is isolated to different areas). In any kind of deployment you will tend to see the same issues. MPs have jurisdictional limits. Their jurisdiction can only be expanded to broad civilians under martial law conditions (there are some weird exceptions here like posse comitatus but those remain exceptional). Nor do you want MPs broadly enforcing the law. Handcuffing someone to a radiator for a half day because they mouthed off is not aligned with a civilian led culture.
- dmix 4y agoLA country sheriffs are one of the largest police organizations in the country. Where would you ever find enough military police? Are they even trained for normal policing?
- carlosjobim 4y agoThey can hardly be larger than the army. Who else except the regular military could have the means to combat a militarized police force and militarized street gangs?
- isleyaardvark 4y agoIn the past this has been successfully dealt with the FBI investigating and imprisoning local cops to clean up police departments. Not the military and militias roaming the streets(?)
- voltaireodactyl 4y agoIf you are willing and have the time, I would appreciate any specific instance/cases of this you could point me towards. My current understanding is that the FBI often investigates such situations, but I am not familiar with any such cases that I would consider "successfully dealt with" -- rather, a few specific folks are hung out to dry, but it appears to me that the institutional issues always remain. Part of me wonder if issue may be (at least partially) a result of the fact that the FBI themselves are "cops", and it can be unsettling to prosecute illegal conduct in which you and your fellow officers also engage.