2 ms·
> Your criticism seems very "no one can explain what it's for" conservative, but the progressives don't care about what it's for. Progressives have goals. That
by acdha 4y ago
> Your criticism seems very "no one can explain what it's for" conservative, but the progressives don't care about what it's for.
Progressives have goals. That doesn’t always mean solutions, but nobody should struggle to say what they’re trying to improve. That’s somewhat conspicuously absent in Dorsey’s bounty listing, and that’s why I’ve been asking.
Ultimately, the problem is that a service like GitHub or GitLab uses a fair amount resources to run. You have non-trivial storage needs, multiple separate systems making changes which aren’t a simple write-once structure (think about what git rebase does to your storage needs), and non-trivial services like CI. Most projects started out running those themselves (possibly starting in the CVS or Subversion eras), got tired of it and switched to something like GitHub, GitLab, BitBucket, etc. and in general that’s been a popular choice. They have paid services which generate a fair amount of revenue to support their businesses but the free tiers allow many open source projects to work without thinking about infrastructure.
This means the very first question I have is the still unanswered one: what is going to motivate someone to spend time working on this or take the risk of switching to it? Nostr isn’t designed for this problem so it’ll be harder to solve there and you’re still going to have to pay for servers since relays don’t guarantee storage unless you run them, and I don’t see very many people who are unsatisfied enough with the status quo that they’re going to donate millions of dollars worth of development time.