2 ms·
> Let me know if the government decides to absolve you of all taxes if you don't think at the end of your year that you've been given money. I... wouldn't? It
by crazygringo 4y ago
> Let me know if the government decides to absolve you of all taxes if you don't think at the end of your year that you've been given money.
I... wouldn't? It just wouldn't have been taken from me.
Why would I think it would have been given to me? I'm perfectly aware it's money I earned in the first place.
In contrast with stimulus checks, for example, which were given, because even if you earned no money at all you still got them.
- gruez 4y ago>In contrast with stimulus checks, for example, which were given, because even if you earned no money at all you still got them. At the end of the day, there's no difference from a fiscal perspective between handing a company a $1M check and giving them a $1M tax deduction. While I agree that this is technically a distinction (ie. tax deductions require a tax liability to actually be used, as opposed to cash which can be spent as-is), I don't think it's relevant here because the companies were already known to be making money. Even if they had a bad year and the tax credits could only be used on profits, they'd likely turn a profit sooner or later.
- junofan 4y agoI think you mean tax credit instead of tax deduction, and even then there is a substantial difference from a fiscal perspective.
- gruez 4y ago>I think you mean tax credit instead of tax deduction Tax deductions are equivalent to tax credits once you factor in the marginal tax rate. >and even then there is a substantial difference from a fiscal perspective. Specifically... how? Giving a company a $1M check has the same effect on the government's balance sheets as giving them a $1M tax credit, given the assumptions listed in my previous comment.
- crazygringo 4y agoOf course at the end of the day you either have a certain amount of money or not. But the point is that there is meaning to the words give and take. It's about language not finances. If you take less that doesn't mean you're giving. Similarly if you give less that doesn't mean you're taking. Words matter.