4 ms·
Sued by Meta, Freenom halts domain registrations
- notlukesky 4y ago[flagged]
- JeremyBanks 4y ago[dead]
- e844dbe8fb 4y ago[dead]
- peppermint_gum 4y ago>Dutch registrar was sued by Meta, which alleges the company ignores abuse complaints about phishing websites while monetizing traffic to those abusive domains. I wouldn't be surprised if they are ignoring those complaints because there's no one left to process them. They clearly struggle to keep the lights on, see: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34194555 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34194555
- Waterluvian 4y agoRandom curiosity: if they just go dark indefinitely, is there some authority that can assume authority over those TLDs? IANA or something?
- Macha 4y agoSince they're ccTLDs, the governments of those countries can designate new operators. The root nameservers (operated by a variety of operators, under ICANN's supervision) would have to update their top level record but they are generally hands off for ccTLDs (because if they were not, a country could just mandate its ISPs use a different set of root servers)
- CydeWeys 4y agoICANN has EBERO with a standardized escrow format to deal with this exact issue for gTLDs but ccTLDs are pretty much a wild west. I wouldn't use these.
- mr_toad 4y ago> I wouldn't be surprised if they are ignoring those complaints because there's no one left to process them. Maybe, but Facebook is arguing otherwise: “ According to Meta, this isn’t just a case of another domain name registrar ignoring abuse complaints because it’s bad for business. The lawsuit alleges that the owners of Freenom “are part of a web of companies created to facilitate cybersquatting, all for the benefit of Freenom.””
- pjerem 4y agoAllegations are not proofs.
- shapefrog 4y ago“We believe that the genocide against Rohingya was possible only because of Facebook,” (all for the benefit of Facebook) Happy to see other allegations aired out, especially when the consequences are a little more than squatting .tk domains (I suspect the real problem is those pesky .ml domains).
- WhyNotHugo 4y ago> The lawsuit alleges that the owners of Freenom “are part of a web of companies created to facilitate cybersquatting, all for the benefit of Freenom.”” I'm looking forward to seeing them present evidence to back this alegation.
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoAlso, abuse complaints are themselves abused so much that it's easily to want to tell the complainer to go to hell. Running 0bin.net, we have complaints from outside of our jurisdiction, false claims, idiotic claims, DMCA used for censorship, and so on. Once in a while we have a serious one, like CP or doxxing, so we read everything. But honestly, our hosting is forcing us to delete so much content based of BS complaints it's tiring. And if we refuse, we have to make our case, which unlike complaints, cannot be automatized. 9 times out of 10, the hosting tells us we should delete the content anyway, and if we wait to much, proceed to cut the power cord until we comply. I'm sure Meta does report some real website and phishing attempts, but I'm certain they also abuse their power like the GAFAM they are.
- NyckTsunoda 4y ago[dead]
- throwawaycities 4y agoDomain squatting issues aside, I must be the only person I know that’s actually used Freenom and don’t trash them. Registrars certainly can be held liable for domain squatting but it’s typically when the registrar actually registers the names and sells them, not on when a 3rd party registers them. I’m only familiar with the .ml and .gq TLDs and at least for those I’d like to see the respective countries allow more reputable registrars to manage them.
- braingenious 4y agoI used to use .tk for toy projects a lot when I was a teenager. I actually really liked this service
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 4y agoSame, no complaints
- BeFlatXIII 4y ago.cf and .ga are (were?) the other TLDs of theirs.
- sufehmi 4y agoInteresting, I thought for stuff like these - you just need to complain to ICANN. Very interesting to see that Meta feel that it needs to go to court for this. Does this mean that ICANN is broken / does not have the capability to properly take care of these things?
- elwebmaster 4y agoThese domains belong to countries, their own sovereign namespace in the Internet. The countries have designated a company to manage the space on their behalf and that’s the company which has authority over the domains. Nothing to do with ICANN “capability”.
- noirscape 4y agoICANN is an American institution (this'll matter in a bit) that basically manages the entirety of domain names. Broadly speaking, there's two kinds of domain names; gTLDs and ccTLDs[0]. gTLDs (general TLDs, so your .com domains) give you some fairly basic rights; when you buy a domain name you will always have the right to transfer it to a new registrar at no charge and IIRC the domain registrar can't suspend you with no reason given (although any reason is sufficient, including "we just don't like you"). ccTLDs (country code TLDs, so .uk for example) on the other hand have the same rights on paper, but not in practice. This mostly comes down to the fact that ICANN as an institution doesn't want to be at the center of a diplomatic incident, so they just allow countries to do whatever they want with their TLDs. Some run them like any old registrar (or subcontract it out for profit), others restrict purchases to just government entities, others go midway and use the TLD only for government websites while letting regular entities buy a subdomain from a known domain name (.co.uk for example). With a ccTLD (which are the domains freenom chiefly provides), as long as the government you're getting the rights from approves of your actions, you can basically run it however you want because of this. ICANN rarely if ever moves against ccTLDs (although freenom has already been punished in the past by ICANN over their ccTLD behavior, so it does happen sometimes.) [0]: There's also a third category which mostly just comprises .gov, which is the TLD used by the US government (why the US government gets access to that TLD instead of say, .gov.usa like all other countries, is for reasons beyond me).
- RobotToaster 4y agoHow does an American court have the power to halt registrations for Central African Republic, Malian, etc, domains that are managed by a Dutch company?
- JeremyBanks 4y ago[dead]
- elwebmaster 4y agoThey don’t. But the Dutch company is broke.
- zinekeller 4y agoYeah, I'm not even sure if it's even correct to attribute it to Meta to be honest, it's been years that their registration system is known to be broken from time to time. At best the Meta lawsuit is the partial reason (not full reason) why they halted registrations, at worst it's just coincidence since that their systems were already broken for years.
- joecool1029 4y agoI have a domain paid on there so I don't need to keep a site live on it (there is legacy email stuff pointed there). This past year they let it expire after I paid, took almost 2 months for them to correct it. Previously this domain was unpaid and suspended for violating free TOS (need a website on the A record). I had to call this Dutch woman, we will call her Freenom lady, like 20 times for months to get her to finally unsuspend it and take my money for a paid registration. I'd say it was the worst but I have dealt with 1&1 and smaller enom resellers that disappeared. So if my registration gets screwed with now, who do I go after? The country with ccTLD is with?
- windthrown 4y agoI am not familiar with the legal specifics but per the article: "Although Freenom is based in The Netherlands, some of its other sister companies named as defendants in the lawsuit are incorporated in the United States."
- awoimbee 4y agoNote that freenom is known for blocking free domains until users pay up once there's a bit of traffic. I thought it was bullshit until it happened to me.
- noirscape 4y agoDoesn't even have to be a lot of traffic. They just quietly flag your account after a while. I used their TLDs specifically to host high school projects like a decade ago. Suddenly, overnight, the DNS got updated and the account got "suspended" (thankfully only after the high school projects were done and over with). I knew it was suspended because while I seemingly wasn't allowed to iterate over the domains list, I was able to see the total amount of domains I had a registration for. Making an alternate account to try and see if they unregistered the domain (and to see if I could rerequest it) showed them selling the domain for ~$6. They get away with this due to some clause in their TOS that says that they're the owners of the domain and are just leasing it to you. I'm not sure if that's in-line with broader ICANN rules surrounding domain owner rights (iirc they've actually been suspended a couple times because of this sorta stint), but the company are complete scumbags.
- zinekeller 4y ago> I'm not sure if that's in-line with broader ICANN rules surrounding domain owner rights. Doesn't matter, they're ccTLDs, and if the countries-in-question didn't require that Freenom assign the names to actual users. ICANN is irrelevant here, period.
- noirscape 4y agoICANN iirc still has a group that can tell ccTLD registrars to get their shit together and if the company also handles gTLDs (which iirc freenom does), they can still make that a bureaucratic nightmare for them. It's not one of those things where they can outright say "you can't do that", but it is one of those things where it's "if you don't cooperate we'll make your life hell in other ways".
- 4y ago
- tobinfekkes 4y agoThe incredible irony of Meta complaining that the entire Internet is worse off because of a free Internet service getting abused, and they're tired of the costs of fighting it, and the degraded experience for their (free) users. Does anyone have a mirror handy?
- BizarroLand 4y agoI used my pihole to block all facebook data in or out of my home network and the internet is palpably faster with the block in place.
- tobinfekkes 4y agoPihole user myself :) Setting that up was arguably the best technical decision I've ever made, after setting it up for my parents!
- Baljhin 4y agoAnd for those who want to track... > The 10 Most Abused Top Level Domains (updated daily?) https://www.spamhaus.org/statistics/tlds/ https://www.spamhaus.org/statistics/tlds/
- antifa 4y agoLol only the 10th one "gq" is a freenom tld.
- WelcomeShorty 4y agoEven better: today (March 9th) gq nor any other freenoms domains are on the list.
- rldjbpin 4y agoplease use this opportunity to replace freenom with someone else. their system has been impossible to use for legit use cases, while scammers have managed to keep getting domains.
- thinking001001 4y agoOh so people are getting like facebook-login.tk and catching passwords or something, I guess. I'm sure there are tonnes of (free) @gmail.com or @yahoo.com accounts used for phishing though? Or AWS hosted serves? Maybe Meta should be paying engineers instead of lawyers, to protect users, it is kind of an arms race thing. Easy to blame the little guy (Freenom). But I agree with other commenter - the amount of data Meta is scraping, and time wasted to addiction, is potentially more damaging than a few domain names.
- rurban 4y agoSo no more free domains for free open source projects? I won't pay for my free services to the community for sure.
- account42 4y agoYou already pay with your time, is a tenner a year really where you draw the line? Even then, maybe just ask your users to donate.
- WhyNotHugo 4y ago> The lawsuit alleges that the owners of Freenom “are part of a web of companies created to facilitate cybersquatting, all for the benefit of Freenom.” Don't the grand majority of registrar work this way? They usually don't care about unethical activities as long as it brings in profits. Cybersquatting is not illegal in most countries, and registrar themselves often do it themselves.