3 ms·
If I were a regulator, I would try to directly link foods to health outcomes. Ie. If someone eats lots of bigmacs and then dies young, mcdonalds should have to
by londons_explore 4y ago
If I were a regulator, I would try to directly link foods to health outcomes.
Ie. If someone eats lots of bigmacs and then dies young, mcdonalds should have to pay a 'killer food' penalty.
If someone eats lots of apples and lives to 100, then the apple farmer should receive some kind of reward.
I would implement this by having some subset of the population volunteer their purchase data and health data, and have the regulator issue rewards and fines each year based on which food producers managed to make/keep their customers healthiest.
The end result should be that healthy foods are both profitable and cheap, and there is an incentive to reformulate foods to keep the eaters healthier.
That entirely bypasses the current problem of having food manufacturers trying to make their food look healthy while it actually isn't.
- notfed 4y agoIt's completely impossible to prove that eating some food X caused someone's death. Also, anything can kill you if you have otherwise poor health and eat enough of it, including apples.
- londons_explore 4y agoNo, but you can take data on 1 million customers of food X, and see how many died, vs the non-customers. Sure, there will be ways to game the system, like "Buy 6 of this soda and get free gym membership!". But is that a bad thing?
- notfed 4y agoI disagree, because... correlation does not imply causation. Does ice cream cause skin cancer?
- londons_explore 4y agoThe great thing about this is it doesn't matter if the cause is correlation or causation. Either way, companies will be incentivized to make their food and customer base healthier.
- PuppyTailWags 4y ago> No, but you can take data on 1 million customers of food X, and see how many died, vs the non-customers. This is actually extremely difficult to isolate that the food X has a causal link to lifespan. Consider the amount of research and scale of research needed to evaluate the safety of cigarettes, which I can guarantee you has a significantly greater effect on lifespan than any possible food eaten.
- ghostbrainalpha 4y agoYour first job as a regulator, should be to realize that McDonald's is the government. Your second job is to not piss off "the government".