5 ms·
Many people who deal with raw hardware don't realize that what the business wants is guarantees that shit is going to work, cost mostly be damned. And so that'
by bombcar 4y ago
Many people who deal with raw hardware don't realize that what the business wants is guarantees that shit is going to work, cost mostly be damned.
And so that's how you get scenarios where you pay through the nose, but you've explicitly called out what you need and you get it, even if the company ends up doing weird things like shipping the top-end hardware (with speed disabled) so that they can make sure they meet the requirements.
- sanp 4y agoBut when you purchase hardware, are you not paying a lower cost than what you would to the hyperscalers?
- dilyevsky 4y agoWhen you buy oem drives yes, when you purchase from high touch vendor such as PS and proprietary tech then no
- bombcar 4y agoit can go either way and it entirely depends on your use case and what you need 4PB of cloud storage is probably a bit more than $800,000k and then you still have data "in the cloud" and not local to whatever you're doing with it.
- dilyevsky 4y agoAgreed. If you’re egressing a lot to other sites or have elevated iops reqs then cloud may still lose
- SteveNuts 4y agoThat’s debatable when you consider the performance you get from Pure. Our X20 which is on the small end, with only 10 drives can easily do hundreds of thousands of IOPs, supporting over 1000 VMs and a high performance ERP solution. The whole thing costs us about 50k a year. On an AWS/GCP that would cost a lot, lot more.
- riku_iki 4y ago> hundreds of thousands of IOPs that's like number for consumer grade ssd which costs $100?
- SteveNuts 4y agoSure, try running a thousand VMs on it though (which is an extremely random workload). A single sequential test at an optimal byte size benchmark for a consumer SSD is not representative of a real workload these arrays would see. Doing so is a lot more complex and intensive than what a single consumer grade SSD can handle. My point was just that if you wanted to get dedicated IOPs on AWS to match what you get with modern SANs, it’ll cost you far more.
- riku_iki 4y agoit is random 4k iops: https://eu.community.samsung.com/t5/image/serverpage/image-id/711085i0072733DF2FDB712/image-size/large?v=v2&px=999 https://eu.community.samsung.com/t5/image/serverpage/image-i... I tend to think your number for PS is likely off.
- SteveNuts 4y agoIn what way? It can do more or less?
- riku_iki 4y agolikely much more: scale with ssd speed and number of disks. Also, I am not sure how it will stack up against some cloud instance with bunch of ssd under software raid.
- SteveNuts 4y agoI agree that if you ran a synthetic benchmark against a brand new pure x20 with 10 NVME drives you'd see astronomical numbers for iops. That is absolutely not representative of a real workload of mixed reads and writes, different block sizes, potentially different queue depths, all coming in on hundreds or maybe thousands of different volumes. A single consumer Samsung SSD would hilariously crumble under a real workload, it will NOT deliver hundreds of thousands of IOPs in that environment. Your benchmark screenshot is the equivalent of showing your pickup truck can do burnouts in the parking lot, and extrapolating that to think it could keep up with a Ferrari on the Nurburgring.
- SteveNuts 4y agoIn this case, Pure will monitor your arrays for you and determine if the latency issues are coming from the controllers or the nvme subsystem, and they’ll either add more drives or swap out the controllers for faster hardware to make sure the SLA is met. It’s a pretty good system especially for CFOs who prefer opex model