3 ms·
Apple's not really a monopoly here, is it? In the operating system market, it's small. In the laptop market, it's small. In the Mac OS market, it's small. EDIT
by renewiltord 4y ago
Apple's not really a monopoly here, is it? In the operating system market, it's small. In the laptop market, it's small. In the Mac OS market, it's small.
EDIT: Guys, you can literally just install using Steam or Epic. It's really not a problem.
- jojobas 4y agoIt might be small-ish in terms of units shipped, but nowhere near small in revenue and profit. I guess it's not exactly a laptop monopoly, but a walled laptop monopoly alright.
- frumper 4y agoI can't remember using the Mac App Store for anything that wasn't made by Apple. I've had Macs for 14 years. I install plenty of software. The Mac App Store is pretty much the last place I go for software. It's nothing like the iOS App Store.
- wilg 4y agoIt's not a monopoly because you can buy phones and computers from plenty of other people. A large player is not a monopoly, and the choice exists if you don't like their offerings. I don't see how this is some kind of societal issue.
- blululu 4y agoDepends on how you think about monopolies and bundling. For the most part Apple's devices and products face a pretty competitive landscape. But there are some areas where they have a very strong market position. The revenue for paid apps in America skews very heavily to the Apple App Store (people make apps for iOS only in the US but never Android only). The alternatives to going through the App Store are really not viable. The switching costs to consumers are very high and people buy phones because of core features (battery, camera, speakers, connectivity, display, touch screen). The availability and pricing of paid apps is such an afterthought for consumers as to be irrelevant. In this one small market Apple exerts its market dominance influence to take a lot of money from 3rd party developers. Of course this is small potatoes compared to all the other markets that they compete in and even as a fraction of their revenue. But this is Hacker News. A lot of developers hang out here. Some of whom have certainly had some bad experiences with the policies, restrictions and fees imposed by the App Store.
- smoldesu 4y ago> For the most part Apple's devices and products face a pretty competitive landscape. Not really. The point is less about market positioning and more about building fair platforms. Apple wants to frame themselves as an underdog competitor in the global economy, but they fail because they can't even build a fair or open platform when given total freedom to do so. This "failure" has made them a lot of money, but it's also come to the detriment of users everywhere, whether they know it or not. The law exists explicitly to push companies like Apple along when they get too fat and rest on their Carnegie laurels. > The alternatives to going through the App Store are really not viable. Someone ought to tell the Mac people this, they'll be heartbroken. > In this one small market Apple exerts its market dominance influence to take a lot of money from 3rd party developers. Of course this is small potatoes compared to all the other markets that they compete in and even as a fraction of their revenue. Last year Apple made more from services than they did from iPhone hardware. That's not just a "fraction" anymore.
- Zuider 4y agoYes, but the App Store is a walled garden with no workarounds because competitors are forbidden.
- sidlls 4y agoYeah, just like "competitors are forbidden" from, say, inserting their tech, logos, etc., into, e.g., vehicles. You're not going to find Ford allowing Tesla to stick its stuff in Ford's EV fleet, and vice-versa. This whole strange fascination with claiming Apple is a monopoly is just silly. There is at least one major competitor to Apple in the mobile market (said competitor actually dominates that market by a huge margin) and literally dozens in the PC market. Apple isn't a monopoly, and it doesn't have to let competitors distribute their products within its own ecosystem.
- zamnos 4y agoWhat are you talking about? If you want to replace the stock Tesla Model 3 seats with Recaro seats, go right ahead. If you want to replace the stock Tesla Model 3 rims with some 22"s, or put a lift kit, or slam it, it's your car/money; you can do whatever you want with it. Certain state's governments may have opinions on what you're legally allowed to drive on their roads, but that's nothing to do with putting a hypothetical Ford battery in a Tesla. Let's keep following in this thread. So if Ford created a 3rd-party battery pack, Tesla isn't legally allowed to prevent customers from replacing their battery pack with the Ford (or an Our Next Energy (ONE), who actually sells a) pack. Similarly, Ford has no legal standing to stop you if you buy a gasoline F-150, gut the motor and fuel tank, and install a Tesla motor and battery from a salvage title Model S. This goes even further. The Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act from 1975 explicitly says Tesla isn't allowed to deny warranty coverage just because you used aftermarket or recycled parts, or went to a non-Tesla authorized auto shop for routine maintenance or repairs. You don't own the iPhone you paid for, and the inability to install apps, with root permissions, is reason number 1 why. Meanwhile, you can actually take a wrench to a Ford F-150 all you want.