7 ms·
Google tells employees that fewer of them will get promotions to senior roles
- anigbrowl 4y agoPerhaps not a wise move at a firm where it is within the reach of almost all staff to consider the org chart as a binary tree and analyze the changes mathematically.
- throwaway128128 4y ago"The L6 distinction refers to the first layer of staff that’s considered senior and typically includes people with about a decade of experience." That's not true? Isn't "senior SWE" the title for L5 at Google?
- mathgladiator 4y agoYes, but that's also title inflation
- crazygringo 4y agoThe word "senior" varies by level for different job tracks -- for some it's not even until L7 (or at least it was this way in the past). But my understanding is that, across most job tracks, it's expected that everyone should get promoted to L5 eventually just by working hard. While it's never expected to get to L6. You might get to L5 and just stay there forever. L6 requires a certain level of achievement that they don't expect everyone to be able to achieve. That's what sets it apart. So it makes sense this is the level where they're closing the gate even more.
- lokar 4y agoIt’s been a few years since I had access to the data, for for a long time 6+ made up about 10% of ICs
- eep_social 4y agoI recently heard but did not verify that L4 is now terminal instead of 5 which makes a ton of sense to me and also puts this new tidbit in context.
- BoorishBears 4y agoEh, you're a senior SWE at L5 in a lot of companies, but L6 is definitely where you start to be seen as closer to management in the chain than your typical IC. You start being involved in calibration for example. L5 is mostly about reaching greater depths with your skills as an L4, L6 is more about gaining breadth that isn't guaranteed just by being an L5 for a while
- moosedev 4y agoSenior Software Engineer is indeed the title for L5 SWE at Google. However, whether a "senior software engineer" title is considered "senior" in a general sense these days is debatable.
- BFLpL0QNek 4y agoI noticed this. Not Google but I worked at a mid-size US based company briefly last year. The team was junior but senior in titles and highly opinionated, that was why I ended up leaving as nothing was getting done. Not last week I got a bunch of LinkedIn updates saying “Congratulate X being promoted to Senior/Staff/Principal Engineer”. The grads I worked with who were good and what you expect for a grad where getting promoted to senior’s and the seniors who were ok, maybe a little inexperienced were getting promoted to staff. I think roles mean nothing these days. They’re devalued and only exist for people to move up in to the next pay band. What I consider senior from 15-20 years ago is staff engineer now and principal today feels like someone at the top of senior 15-20 years ago.
- mulmen 4y agoThere are a lot more people in the field today so the standards have dropped as is necessary. Principal is top x%, senior is top y%, etc. It's not capability based.
- ummonk 4y agoGiven that L5 is a terminal position, and thus a mark of seniority, the title of “senior” would appear to be the correct title.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y ago"Senior SWE" is not a senior position; I think we all know that.
- inoffensivename 4y agoIt hurts, but you're not wrong :(
- sowbug 4y agoL5 used to be the first terminal level, meaning that you could stay at L5 for as long as you liked as long as your performance was good. (Nowadays that so-called "growth expectation" has gotten a lot fuzzier, with some orgs letting people stay at L4 or even L3 for many years.) So L6 was the first elective level. Anyone who reached it did so by opting in, rather than just going with the flow. That is why it carries a bit of weight. All this was more true back in the 2000s. (Source: me, ex-Googler, 2003-22.)
- jnwatson 4y agoYou are correct. L5 is senior, L6 is staff, L7 is senior staff. Source: am L6.
- lacker 4y agoThis isn't surprising. "With our slower pace of hiring, we are planning for fewer promotions into L6 and above than when Google was growing quickly." Pretty straightforward, when you have fewer employees you need fewer leadership roles.
- qualudeheart 4y agoThe people that got fired could go back to grad school to learn something new.
- bigbillheck 4y agoVery few people should go to grad school.
- UncleMeat 4y agoI know several people who were laid off at Google who have PhDs from top programs.
- m00x 4y agoUnless you're the government. 1 Manager to 1 worker is very common.
- bigbillheck 4y agoIt's been over a decade since I was in civil service but my immediate supervisor had a couple dozen direct reports, and that wasn't unusual.
- water-your-self 4y agoknowyourcomp
- wunderland 4y agoThis window to self-nominate (6-8 Match, so starting today) is ahead of the layoff decision for many of the European offices. There will be people who have spent the last month prepping for promo only to get the axe in about 10-15 days.
- throwawaylinux 4y agoWhat is the layoff decision for many European offices?
- UncleMeat 4y agoDifferent countries have different employment regulations. Layoffs in the US hit in January, but layoffs in other countries have been slowly rolling out as leadership figures out how to deal with various laws. Nobody in London has been laid off yet, for example. They are still waiting to find out who will be axed.
- taeric 4y agoWhat an odd message to fire across all employees. For an industry that wants so desperately to believe in meritocracy, to admit that there is a somewhat hidden quota on how many people you want at a given level feels to give the lie to the idea that it is strictly merit based.
- version_five 4y agoNo that doesn't make sense. Meritocracy doesn't automatically mean "promoting" someone when they have checked some boxes. That's actually the opposite. I see lots of people that approach work as if it's public school, that if they do the things the need to pass grade 4, they get into grade 5, and lots of companies pretend it's that way for junior roles. There is a "quota" for each level, it's driven by the business need. That has no relationship with merit based promotion.
- taeric 4y agoI hate to play the definition game, but "government or the holding of power by people selected on the basis of their ability" is given for meritocracy. If your ability is that you are at that level, you should be held to that level. If this is a meritocracy. If promotion is also bound by availability of "slots" at a given level, than by definition you will exclude some folks that are otherwise at that level. I fully sympathize that inflation of level is a thing. I also fully sympathize that resources to use people at a given level are finite. Such that you will have to do this for practical reasons. Still, the message for that is almost certainly tailored to the individual that you turned down and best left for the specifics. Blasting out this message as generically as it was done just feels wrong.
- huhneverthot 4y ago[dead]
- bentlegen 4y agoAside (and this is not meant as a rebuttal), it’s interesting to me that nobody denies that managerial roles only have so many “slots” (e.g. can’t have 5 CTOs or 7 VPEs, or Directors managing teams of 2 people), and yet, nobody decries the lack of opportunities for those in the management track.
- qualudeheart 4y agoLarge language models will reduce demand for senior employees.
- numbsafari 4y agoWhen will Sundar hit 1.0? Or will he be replaced by some Larry and Sergey 20% project and sunset without notice before leaving perpetual beta?
- qualudeheart 4y agoUnclear if he’s needed.
- ajaimk 4y agoLeveling at Google is supposed to be based on impact and the type of work you do. It isn’t about leadership. Going from L5 to L6 doesn’t make you a manager. This is just a cost cutting measure as we all know. (Former googler)
- mikebenfield 4y agoIf you're a former Googler, then you know that the role description for L6 indicates that an L6 is indeed supposed to exert a lot of leadership and influence, even if not a manager.
- maximinus_thrax 4y agoYes, exactly. This is the case in a lot of other large companies. It basically enables management to fuck it up royally and repeatedly while the more senior engineers, which ambiguously defined technical leadership roles added to their IC responsibilities clean it up and keep the lights on.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoAll promotions beyond L3->L4 involve a leadership component for some definition of leadership. Even L4->L5 promo is more than just demonstrating technical impact or ability. It involved being basically the key contact and coordinator on some project(s), "owning" some area and doing a bunch of cross-team collaboration. Being the loudest guy in the room for some thing, really. The impact that needs to be demonstrated from L4->L5 is in large part organizational/political, not technical. I understand that L4->L5 was "fixed" after I left to leave a lot more room for immediate manager opinion/involvement. That's probably a good thing, because L4 to L5 was bullshit, especially at a smaller site where impactful work was hard to get. Anyways, it's all stupid perverse incentives. People shoving each out of the way to grab the impactful work rather than cooperating. All over the place.
- dotcoma 4y agoCan’t have 1,000s of VPs…
- NyckTsunoda 4y ago[dead]
- cletus 4y agoThis isn't new or surprising. Nor is it new. For those unfamiliar, Google engineering levels generally go from L3 (new grad) to L9 IDistinguished SWE). There is an expectation of growth to L5 (Senior SWE). I'm not sure what the figures look like today but pre-layoffs the total comp for an L5 Google SWE was typically at least $350k and can be over $400k. Everyone who has been in this sytem knows that the bar to get to the next level (L6; Staff SWE) is gotten increasingly difficult. You packet will go through multiple promo committees and has to pass all of them. What would've gotten you promoted 10 years ago certainly wouldn't today. But here's how promo committees work: you'll basically get stack ranked. That committee might have 10-15 packets and they'll get ranked. A certain point (usually called the bubble) will differentiate between promote those above the bubble, don't below. Committee consist of higher level ICs so a L5->L6 committe will consist of L7 ICs. There is and probably has been a target percentage for promotions. This number is opaque. One of the things that Ruth Porat did when she came in to reduce costs was simply to reduce the promotion target percentage. I'm having difficulty finding the original leak for this but it leaked several years ago. What slots there are to get promoted at these companies are probably filled by a revolving door of external hires. So this is just more attacks on labor costs while executive pay is astronomically high and Google made a profit of ~$60B last year. Disclaimer: Xoogler.
- eitally 4y agoIn addition to your points, if you go for promo once, you may have an easier time of it the second try (if your manager gets senior leads to back the idea for the next round), but if you try twice and fail both, you may as well leave the company. +100 to the "revolving door of external hires". I was let go in the January action after almost 8 years of doing the same thing at Google. During that time, I saw 3 Cloud CEOs and I personally had 6 directors and 9 VPs. Change isn't always bad, but Google clearly does not value leadership & management as skills in the same way most large corporations do.
- cletus 4y agoThe leadership churn you mention is very real. The joke at Google even when I worked there (2017) was every few months you'd get an email saying your manager's manager's manager's manager now reports to a new manager. You didn't know nor had ever met any of these people. I have a theory about this: middle management likes churn because it makes you immune to the consequences of their actions. You can't fail if none of your decisions are permanent and you constantly shift responsibilities. That's not an accident. It's by design. My experience at Google was this was a huge problem. Sorry you were let go.
- eitally 4y agoThere are a couple of problems with this (not the least of which is market signaling that Google is not a place to reliably advance one's career, for anyone but the most junior staff). Clearly, it doesn't not make sense for everyone at a given firm to be in management. Facebook has recently come to this conclusion. That said, leveling and advancement at Google has always been about impact, and for the most part, employees have been able to vote with their feet (internally transfer) if they find themselves in roles that won't support "impact requirements" that justify promotion. It is utterly insane and short-sighted for Google to place such low value on things like KTLO work and optimization, and the result is the long list of deprecated and half-finished products we all know and love. The effects of these perverse incentives have been beaten to death so I won't belabor that here. However, one thing I don't see discussed much is how this same impact-driven-promo behavior leads directly to both "rest & vest" and poor management. It leads to rest & vest behavior by employees who no longer see a path upward so they cruise with minimal effort to maintain the status quo. Google as an organization does not reward Googleyness where the term is defined to mean "go outside your assigned tasks / projects to 'do the right thing'". In fact, it usually punishes people who are too Googley. Similarly, it rewards poor management because these vast quantities of employees are typically peanut buttered in such a way that everything is broken all the time and new folks constantly need to be hired to keep things running. Empire building, further supported by Google's reliance on TVCs for literally every non-product-development business process (and many functions and processes that do directly support product). Nobody knows how anything works and (see punishment for Googleyness) nobody is willing to stick their neck out too far to try and fix/change anything. There are some absolutely terrific managers at Google, but management and leadership at Google is the worst I've ever come across in my 25 year working career. This brings me to the final problem with this no-promo statement. Another common reason Googlers are dinged on perf or viewed negatively by their own leadership is when they repeatedly hit CME, maybe with a sprinkly of EE, ratings. Literally, if you are rated as "Meets Expectations" more than twice in a row you are flagged for extra review during perf calibration. If promos to L6+ are being reduced, then that logically indicates that there are fewer roles at Google scoped for L6+ impact. If that is true, then logically 1) top talent will leave (or not join), and 2) people currently in terminal roles (say an L5 SWE or an L6 TPM) have no real motivation to work harder than necessary to achieve CME since they know they can't get promoted and the bonus and equity multipliers between CME --> EE aren't really that great. Similarly, you end up with folks who, after a few years (max), are near the top end of the salary band for their level and will no longer be eligible for pay increases beyond a percent or two. Tell me, who would want to work for a company that 1) doesn't value management as a skill, 2) doesn't have logical performance metrics in place that allow all employees to articulate why what they do is important, 3) doesn't offer opportunities for advancement, and 3b) will actually fall behind CoL pay increases within a few years as a result of #3?
- oofta-boofta 4y agoThis just reinforces what I've been saying for years: seeking promotion is for chumps. You'll make far more money and advance far quicker from job-hopping between companies than you will trying to seek internal promotion. Google, and pretty much big tech as a whole, is completely aimless at this point and has no real plan to provide new value to customers. They just jump from shiny thing to shiny new thing. Big tech has only been able to maintain it's recent dominance through monopolistic practices, and now they've mismanaged themselves into decline. Good.
- ChatGTP 4y agoI guess the new hope is they can automate everyone out of work to save money on labor, that seems to be the new growth path...
- jnwatson 4y agoIt isn't easy to get senior FAANG compensation at other companies.
- Bajeezus 4y agoThat was true 5+ years ago, but these days I can easily name 20+ companies that pay roughly the same or more at the senior level. Half your compensation at FAANG is name recognition for your resume.
- roflyear 4y agoList them!
- Panini_Jones 4y agoE5/L5 compensation is relatively similar across the board for normal performers ($350k-$450k). Once you get into the E7+ compensation levels, then you start to notice a real differences.
- roflyear 4y ago
- deanCommie 4y agoThe Great Resignation gave the individuals so much negotiation and purchasing power for a brief period of time as Big Tech companies lost people left and right to Web3 Crypto Unicorns (and other Unicorns in their dying gasps). Amazon, Microsoft, Google, all lost so many people because their systems weren't configured to be able to quickly keep up with the new market trends. But Big tech cos had 2 things could control: 1. Newhire offer bands could rise quicker than internal salaries. (Leading to resentment that newhires were getting insane offers that long-term employees could never get in a raise). Which led to a lowering of the bar across all levels in Big Tech to get those offers out. 2. Promotion bars could be lowered likewise. Neither was nefarious. Noone ever said at a high level leadership level "Lower the bar" (for either). But what did happen is that when great coworkers all around you are constantly leaving, the people remaining start to panic. They start to realize that that "almost senior" engineer who's "not quite there" and wouldn't have been promoted 6 months ago, will absolutely leave for a Senior title and a 30-50% salary bump if you don't promote him. (And still might if you do cuz you'll only give him a 15-20% salary raise). And suddenly, everyone starts "leaning in" to promotions. Likewise, on interview loops, when you've lost a bunch of folks and are desperate to replace your headcount to meet your goals, you start talking yourself into candidates that you wouldn't have taken risks on 6 months earlier. This is all basic human nature, and even experienced data-driven leaders will find themselves optimizing for different criteria and justifying it to themselves as thinking outside the box. I'm genuinely not judging, it's a reasonable and logical (albeit shortsighted) way to act under the circumstances. So now, that all of this is behind us, these companies are all sitting on hiring freeze, post-layoffs, and still with a bunch of folks that are overlevelled. An overcorrection is the only step forward. Lose even more folks because you now have to recalibrate their inflated sense of accomplishment or worse an overly optimistic sense of their opportunity ("Jeff got promoted and I'm way better than Jeff! So I should get promoted too." Yeah, Jeff wouldn't have been promoted in 2020 or 2023. So alas, too bad for you) I think to some degree this will happen across all Big Tech this year. But unlike during the great resignation, there's no more unicorns (Except Facebook) throwing insane offers at ex-Big Tech. I think things will go back to normal in 2024, for a definition of normal that is closer to 2014.
- 8n4vidtmkvmk 4y ago> The L6 distinction refers to the first layer of staff that’s considered senior and typically includes people with about a decade of experience. That all? A decade? I have 2 decades. I'm an L4. Weeeee....