6 ms·

Cross-Domain Thinking Drives Insights and Innovation

95 points by jger15 4y ago

say_it_as_it_is 4y ago
It used to be called innovation
mindvirus 4y ago
I really enjoyed the book Range about late specialization. I've also been using ChatGPT for brainstorming and combining two different topics. I've tried to get it to generate analogies too, with mixed success, but I could see that being very powerful as a tool for thinking.
- andrew-jack 4y ago
  I can definitely see how combining different topics can lead to some fascinating brainstorming sessions.
tony_antony 4y ago
While reading this a book came to my mind - "Algorithms to Live By: The Computer Science of Human Decisions". There are thousands of bright people innovating clever solutions in CS but humanity often fails to bring those insights to wider societies. There needs to a bridge that could potentially tackle this problem and convert domain specific knowledge to solve day to day problems.
jalino23 4y ago
I've thought of this question a long time ago, but I never really put in the work to find the answer. What totally different domain or topic should I study that would indirectly make me a better programmer? better in general or an aspect of programming.
- urthor 4y ago
  Epistemology, cognitive science behind deliberate practice, time management, design theory. Depends if you want to make things faster, or make better things.
- monch1962 4y ago
  I'd suggest seeking out industries where IT hasn't really "happened" yet. I work at Deloitte. Every time I chat with my counterparts in Tax, Audit, Wealth, ... I come up with ideas that may or may not be worth pursuing further. After that, it's just a matter of seeking out vicious rejection of all the bad ideas, till you land on one where the best objection is "well, we just don't do things that way around here". There's also just being the guy in the right place at the right time, and being open to learning new stuff. I ran into a guy ~20 years ago who'd found a niche in building software emulators for ATMs. He didn't have a coding background, but after asking lots of questions of his buddies who worked in banking and taking a few night classes on Visual Basic coding he'd built a multi-million dollar business on his own to fill a gap that almost nobody knew existed. Thousands of better coders working in banking could've done what he did, but none thought to even look at the opportunity that was staring them in the face
  - bob1029 4y ago
    Banking is still a "please help us" area with regard to tech. I've seen some gigantic players in this space, backed up by death stars like Salesforce who have still failed to penetrate the full depth of the business model and provide a properly-integrated software solution. Everyone talks fantastical tales in their various ivory towers of decisionmaking, but no one wants to sit down with the actual front line employees and understand the UX challenges around performing a complete IRA rollover front-to-back with a customer base that may not be as financially-literate as hoped. You will find almost universally that the big players will come in and drop a 95% solution on the table. The remaining 5% is what the business actually needed to see the dream come true. If the back office still needs to visually inspect every form, you have failed in your strategic mission. It is quite easy to sweep that 5% under the rug in a larger org chart. Even in banking, the people responsible are getting fed up with the lack of delivery. This is why tiny companies like ours are able to get competitive products in place now.
- DeathArrow 4y ago
  >What totally different domain or topic should I study Any domain, literally.
_448 4y ago
That is why humanities/liberal-arts courses are better that "specialisations".
- tigerlily 4y ago
  My engineering professor once told me that a liberal arts degree is a PhD that you can do in undergrad.
  - Daub 4y ago
    Oof. I work in the so called liberal arts and have also collaborated with engineers. I can tell you that your professor is 70% correct.
rsrsrs86 4y ago
The microconomics mental models mentioned are so badly described from the trained economist’s perspectives that they aren’t even useful.
candyman 4y ago
Lateral Thinking was published by Edward de Bono in 1967.
lincpa 4y ago
[dead]
Daub 4y ago
In academia it is commonly accepted that a cross domain research portfolio is the kiss of death for tenure. I have personally seen this happen way too many times.

95 points by jger15 4y ago

It used to be called innovation

I really enjoyed the book Range about late specialization. I've also been using ChatGPT for brainstorming and combining two different topics. I've tried to get it to generate analogies too, with mixed success, but I could see that being very powerful as a tool for thinking.

andrew-jack 4y ago
I can definitely see how combining different topics can lead to some fascinating brainstorming sessions.

tony_antony 4y ago

While reading this a book came to my mind - "Algorithms to Live By: The Computer Science of Human Decisions". There are thousands of bright people innovating clever solutions in CS but humanity often fails to bring those insights to wider societies. There needs to a bridge that could potentially tackle this problem and convert domain specific knowledge to solve day to day problems.

jalino23 4y ago

I've thought of this question a long time ago, but I never really put in the work to find the answer. What totally different domain or topic should I study that would indirectly make me a better programmer? better in general or an aspect of programming.

urthor 4y ago
Epistemology, cognitive science behind deliberate practice, time management, design theory. Depends if you want to make things faster, or make better things.
monch1962 4y ago
I'd suggest seeking out industries where IT hasn't really "happened" yet. I work at Deloitte. Every time I chat with my counterparts in Tax, Audit, Wealth, ... I come up with ideas that may or may not be worth pursuing further. After that, it's just a matter of seeking out vicious rejection of all the bad ideas, till you land on one where the best objection is "well, we just don't do things that way around here". There's also just being the guy in the right place at the right time, and being open to learning new stuff. I ran into a guy ~20 years ago who'd found a niche in building software emulators for ATMs. He didn't have a coding background, but after asking lots of questions of his buddies who worked in banking and taking a few night classes on Visual Basic coding he'd built a multi-million dollar business on his own to fill a gap that almost nobody knew existed. Thousands of better coders working in banking could've done what he did, but none thought to even look at the opportunity that was staring them in the face
- bob1029 4y ago
  Banking is still a "please help us" area with regard to tech. I've seen some gigantic players in this space, backed up by death stars like Salesforce who have still failed to penetrate the full depth of the business model and provide a properly-integrated software solution. Everyone talks fantastical tales in their various ivory towers of decisionmaking, but no one wants to sit down with the actual front line employees and understand the UX challenges around performing a complete IRA rollover front-to-back with a customer base that may not be as financially-literate as hoped. You will find almost universally that the big players will come in and drop a 95% solution on the table. The remaining 5% is what the business actually needed to see the dream come true. If the back office still needs to visually inspect every form, you have failed in your strategic mission. It is quite easy to sweep that 5% under the rug in a larger org chart. Even in banking, the people responsible are getting fed up with the lack of delivery. This is why tiny companies like ours are able to get competitive products in place now.
DeathArrow 4y ago
>What totally different domain or topic should I study Any domain, literally.

_448 4y ago

That is why humanities/liberal-arts courses are better that "specialisations".

tigerlily 4y ago
My engineering professor once told me that a liberal arts degree is a PhD that you can do in undergrad.
- Daub 4y ago
  Oof. I work in the so called liberal arts and have also collaborated with engineers. I can tell you that your professor is 70% correct.

rsrsrs86 4y ago

The microconomics mental models mentioned are so badly described from the trained economist’s perspectives that they aren’t even useful.

candyman 4y ago

Lateral Thinking was published by Edward de Bono in 1967.

lincpa 4y ago

[dead]

Daub 4y ago

In academia it is commonly accepted that a cross domain research portfolio is the kiss of death for tenure. I have personally seen this happen way too many times.