8 ms·
Pedestrian Traffic Fatalities by State: 2022 Preliminary Data
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoI've been seeing increase in traffic fatalities in general being attributed by increasingly large vehicles, because they have significantly less visibility and their shape makes it so crashes are much more fatal. Does anyone have causal relationship studies? [That being said the rapid increase of pedestrian traffic fatalities depresses me greatly. Children are less safe to play on sidewalks and neighborhood suburb streets than they were just a decade ago. This isn't how safety is supposed to work.]
- Tarrosion 4y agoThis paper might be a good starting point. It's mostly about vehicle-vehicle collisions and the higher risks from heavier vehicles, but they discuss pedestrian fatalities a bit. https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w17170/w17170.pdf https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w17170/w171...
- rootusrootus 4y agoI am certainly less dangerous in my F250 than my Bolt (though I've never caused a wreck, so that's hypothetical). Why? Because the godforsaken F250 turns like an aircraft carrier and I drive it slowly and carefully as a result. The real design failure of modern cars, IMO, is the A-pillar width. It creates a huge blind spot, especially on the front left, that you have to very consciously mitigate.
- ntonozzi 4y agoMy suspicion is that this is true for you, but untrue generally. When walking and biking, all of my close calls have been with large trucks. Drivers typically feel more confident going faster in large vehicles because they are higher up, and they are less likely to see pedestrians and especially small children. Modern trucks and SUVs are very unlikely to rollover in normal intersections, so the more awkward turning doesn't force drivers to slow down. Is there any data on how often trucks and SUVs hit pedestrians and bikers compared to cars? They are certainly more lethal when they are involved in a collision.
- olyjohn 4y agoI have to constantly look around my A pillars and its annoying as hell. Even taking my Fit onto the race track, the damn pillar blocks half of the corner from view. It's a real problem.
- estebank 4y agoNot Just Bikes just released a very relevant video about the very real problems that SUVs and modern trucks have on urban environments. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jN7mSXMruEo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jN7mSXMruEo
- munk-a 4y agoCars destroy walkability. City planners need to shift their mind from arterial expressways to moats that prevent cars from ever approaching city centers and actually provide alternative transit options that aren't crap. My partner and I had a day long layover in Dallas and trying to get anywhere in that city on foot felt futile even after we taxi'd into the middle of what I assume is downtown.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoExcessive distances between destinations destroys walkability, too. Which is a necessary condition for environments that can accommodate the quantity and size of most American cars. Edit: Excessive distances are also a necessary condition for living in an environment with detached 2.5k+ sq ft single family houses with garages and backyards.
- bluGill 4y agoEven their smallest European cars take up a lot of space
- midoridensha 4y agoExactly. Basically, Americans simply do not want walkable neighborhoods or cities. They want to have huge houses with garages and backyards they rarely use, and they don't want to use municipal parks because "those people" might also use them. You can't have walkable cities when everyone is living in a huge, detached single-family house with a big yard. If it comes down to a choice between the dense, walkable cities of Europe and Asia, or the car-dominated suburban hellscape that is most of America, the vast majority of Americans are going to choose the latter. IMO, if you really want to live in a walkable city, the thing to do is simply move to one, rather than sitting around hoping the rest of Americans are going to change their opinions and their culture. This is most likely going to mean leaving America. It's exactly what I did, and walkability was one of the big reasons.
- ericmay 4y agoEventually Americans won’t really have that choice because they just won’t be able to afford it. But I do want to mention you can have a huge house with a backyard and garage. In fact the suburbs can be retrofitted to be more walkable - you just need businesses and such there. It’ll take a while but you can see the fragility of the car-only infrastructure coming to bear. Eventually it’ll just cost so much money to drive everywhere you’ll be begging to walk.
- jeffbee 4y agoWhat’s their secret in Idaho?
- reducesuffering 4y agoThere aren’t any pedestrians…
- jeffbee 4y agoYou’d imagine the same thing about New Mexico.
- ianai 4y agoNMican here. This is big vehicle country and that could be a huge factor. Also subjectively a sudden huge growth in homelessness. It’s also just otherwise not very populace so I wonder whether there’s an odd sample problem going on. It wouldn’t take as much to move the figure here as it would a more populace state. Large swaths of population 5’5” and below too. Could actually be the shortest state in the union.
- bentley 4y agoNew Mexico is known for its drug problems (including alcoholism). 30% of fatalities involve alcohol on the part of the driver or the pedestrian, and 14% involve other drugs (these percentages might overlap). https://gps.unm.edu/sites/default/files/traffic/NM_Pedestrian_Report_15-19.pdf https://gps.unm.edu/sites/default/files/traffic/NM_Pedestria... New Mexico’s pedestrian fatalities have actually stayed fairly constant or even gone down a bit the last few years, during a period when the country as a whole has had a significant increase. And we’re still #2 nationwide! That’s how bad things are here.
- ianai 4y agoNM has a population of around 2.1M and Florida around 22.2M. That puts NM at about 41 vehicular fatalities and Florida at about 443. That’s what I mean by odd numerical stuff. Dividing things by 100,000 is an attempt to smooth over population differences, but I’m not sold it actually makes as much difference as people assume. Yes the DUI thing is another known problem here. Good to point it out. Don’t know that anything could be done about it. People just don’t seem to value life enough.
- givemeethekeys 4y agoFor those of us that need to walk while the powers that be figure out how to save us from cars, my suggestion is to assume that they can't see you. Because they probably can't. No, they don't see you when you cross the street when the light is green for you. No, they can't see you when you cross the street on a 25mph school zone. No, they can't see you when you walkway is closed (for construction) and you need to walk onto the road for a bit. And, they especially can't see you at night. If you make eye contact with its driver, then maybe they've seen you. Otherwise, they can't see you.
- rootusrootus 4y agoEye contact is a good minimum bet. Not just a glance, either, humans are blind for something like 40 minutes a day and that may be one of those moments.
- stevenwoo 4y agoI've been hit twice on a bicycle by a car when the car had a stop sign and I had no sign/light at a T intersection and I was looking at the driver, people can get into a zone of looking for cars and just ignoring all else.
- btrettel 4y agoI'm a daily commuter cyclist. I try hard to be the most visible thing on the road. I always wear hi-viz clothing, always have front and rear lights (even in broad daylight), put reflective hi-viz tape on my bike and helmet, make eye contact with drivers, and politely wave at them as appropriate. (Surely other things as well; this is all from memory.) Despite all of this, I still regularly run into drivers who clearly don't see me. I'm lit up like a Christmas tree! The only conclusion I can come to is that a lot of drivers aren't paying attention. I think all the visibility changes I've made probably make a difference, but there's little I can do to for those who won't see me no matter what I do. Acting like other drivers can't see you leads to particularly conservative cycling. I do often wait for a road to be clear if I'm going through a dangerous stretch of road, but this adds a significant amount of time to my commute. The only thing I've found that works decently for drivers who clearly aren't paying attention is noise. I used to have an air horn, which I should start using again. I've been shouting as needed lately, which works but probably isn't good for my throat.
- beardog 4y ago[flagged]
- jackson1442 4y agoI walk to work every morning- about 3/4 of a mile in Texas. At least twice a week, while crossing an intersection someone will turn at least 30% of the way through the intersection (if not more) before realizing that I'm crossing the street (in a crosswalk, with a green signal) then slam on the brakes. This is after I _already started crossing_. I don't think any amount of diligence would protect me from this, other than simply not walking.
- stonogo 4y agoDiligence? No, you're right. But getting rid of "turn on red" permissions would go a long way.
- sokoloff 4y agoIt sounds like they’re talking about a turn-on-green car conflicting with a simultaneous walk-on-white pedestrian phase. Around here (MA), we’ve given pedestrians about a 4 second head start to make them more visible in situations like this (less likely to be in the A-pillar airbag blockage).
- djmips 4y agoWe have that too, recent change, in some of our downtown streets but they are not very wide so I think it's closer to 2 seconds and as a driver, I really love it.
- jackson1442 4y agoAs the sibling said, this is mostly due to left yield on green (there's no protected left at this intersection), but some drivers do this with turn on red. Even though this intersection has no turn on red signage due to very low visibility to oncoming traffic.
- mplanchard 4y agoLiving in Austin but regularly visiting other states, I had a feeling Texas would be one of the states with the worst increases, and indeed!
- rainsford 4y agoThe most immediately interesting result to me here is the significant variability between states, with Florida having roughly twice the national rate. Obviously comparing Florida to Idaho isn't apples to apples, but Florida has similar population density and population as New York and more than 3 times as many pedestrian deaths per capita. Obviously how roads and cities are designed must be a factor, as well as presumably other state-by-state variables.
- rootusrootus 4y ago> other state-by-state variables Like weather, judging from how there is a pretty clear north-south gradient.
- bobthepanda 4y agoWeather is probably indirect. The south urbanized and suburbanized later due to the invention and adoption of air conditioning, which was around the same timeframe as our movement towards cars.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ars 4y agoFlorida has significantly older drivers. That probably explains all of the difference.
- tzs 4y ago> Florida has similar population density and population as New York and more than 3 times as many pedestrian deaths per capita. The two states have similar density (FL 406/mi^2, NY 412/mi^2), but what is probably more relevant is the average "experienced density". What I mean by "experienced density" is the average over all residents of the densities of their cities. New York City has a density of 27500/mi^2, and 42% of New York residents are in NYC, so even if we play it safe and assume everyone outside of NYC lives in a place with 0 density, the average experienced density in New York would be 11550/mi^2. Florida only has one city approaching NYC density, Sweetwater (25600/mi^2), and that only has 20500 people. The next four densest range from 12800-11860/mi^2, and have populations of 38700, 1000, 21500, and 53410. Its most populous city, Jacksonville at 838000 has a density of only 960/mi^2. Taking all 919 Florida cities that have density data at usa.com [1] I get an average experienced density for their residents of 3096/mi^2. Those cities account for about 68% of the population. If we make the very generous assumption that the remaining 32% live somewhere as dense as the second densest Florida city, we'd get an average experienced density of 6200/mi^2 for the state, just over half that of New York. If we make the more realistic assumption that the remaining 32% live in places with densities around the state average of 406/mi^2, we get an average experienced density in Florida of 2240/mi^2, less than 20% that of New York. [1] http://www.usa.com/rank/florida-state--population-density--city-rank.htm http://www.usa.com/rank/florida-state--population-density--c...
- x3iv130f 4y agoWe will continue to have pedestrian collisions until we start blaming those actually at fault: the politicians and engineers who design and build dangerous transit and automotive systems.
- pklausler 4y agoSurely drivers bear the bulk of the responsibility to not drive into things, including persons.
- rootusrootus 4y agoDepends on your goal. If you want to reduce injuries and fatalities, you recognize that there are multiple contributing factors and you try to address all of them if you can.
- bluGill 4y agoDrivers are human, we cannot drive safely when mixing with pedestrians or a lot of other cars. It isn't possible. Therefore if we are to drive the road environment needs to support it, which means keeping pedestrians away, or speed limits of 10mph when we must mix. To give us enough space Des Moines needs to expand to 20 lane freeways (that is Houston levels of roads in a city 1/3 the population). You can't blame drivers and get anything done as humans are not capable of getting better.
- cameronh90 4y agoThis approach is rarely useful in safety engineering. Sure, if someone is grossly negligent like driving drunk, then we can blame the individual, but usually the best way to improve safety is to look at the whole sequence that led up to the incident, and that requires cooperation from all parties rather than arse-covering. Why is it with rail and plane accidents that we investigate every safety incident, no matter how minor, no matter if there are no injuries or property damage? Yet with car travel, often we won't even look into a road design (or car design) unless there have been multiple fatalities in a short space of time. We just assign some blame, fine or incarcerate someone, and don't bother investigating it any further. This seems like such an obviously wrong way to improve road safety.
- ErikVandeWater 4y agoIn 6 months drivers killed more pedestrians than all the people that died on 9/11.
- p1esk 4y agoWow, Florida is the worst, I wonder why.
- jefftk 4y ago* This is based on the first six months of 2022 only -- it's unfortunate how long it takes data to filter in. * They're comparing against 2019, which is good: too many similar things compare to 2020 which was a very unusual year. * Pedestrian fatalities are up 18% comparing the first half of 2022 with the first half of 2019 * It's not that people are driving more: it's a 22% increase on a per-mile basis. * Looking at figure 4, there's no obvious pattern in which states are seeing the largest increases (or decreases)
- wonder_er 4y ago[flagged]
- danielvf 4y agoThis looks roughly like map of "number of days per year it's warm outside". It looks just like this summer temperature map: https://www.currentresults.com/Images/Maps/usa-state-temperature-summer.jpg https://www.currentresults.com/Images/Maps/usa-state-tempera...
- btrettel 4y agoGood catch. This could suggest that the data needs to be normalized by the number of pedestrians or something similar instead of population.
- gullywhumper 4y agoEven in supposedly bike and pedestrian friendly Minneapolis, the drivers are terrifying. The traffic dampening measures the city has put in do very little to slow the aggressive drivers, and there is next to zero law enforcement. Before becoming a parent, I was very deliberate about where I biked / ran / walked. Now with a toddler, I only walk a very limited number of specific routes at specific times of day that try to minimize potential interaction with drivers. After 8 years in NYC and 3 in Dallas, I was so excited to move here. Now I'm desperate to leave - 100% because of the drivers. But I haven't figured out where drivers don't dominate somewhat affordable urban living.
- bhauer 4y agoWhen I lived in the Los Angeles area, I commuted to work three miles—six miles round trip—as a pedestrian. I certainly buy the data shown here, though it feels like it may merely reflect the number of people walking versus the number of drivers. I suspect in the central-northern part of the country, there just aren't a whole lot of pedestrians out and about to be injured in the first place. Back in Los Angeles, I was most surprised by the resistance I received from the local city council when I asked for additional protections for pedestrians at obviously-problematic intersections. There was one crossing on my route where the cross-traffic speed limit was 40 MPH, meaning the real-world speed was 45 to 50 MPH, sometimes lower depending on traffic congestion. Only the intersecting street I was followjng had a stop, and as a result, the 45 MPH opposing traffic also had essentially zero expectation of having to stop for a pedestrian. I asked the city to consider modifying the intersection into an all-way stop. They promptly rejected the idea and instead simply painted thicker lines on the crosswalk. Thicker lines. That was what the city thought would save me and other pedestrians from cars traveling ~45 MPH on a street where no one ever expects a pedestrian to be crossing. Needless to say, I avoided crossing there for all the years I walked to work, even though doing so made my route less convenient. They claimed it had something to do with nearby train tracks, but that argument did not hold any water. So it comes as no surprise that California has high pedestrian traffic fatalities.