3 ms·
> That said, the bill makes it clear that platforms aren’t liable for illegal user-generated content, unless they are aware of the content and fail to remove it
by vlovich123 4y ago
> That said, the bill makes it clear that platforms aren’t liable for illegal user-generated content, unless they are aware of the content and fail to remove it.
Is there any clarity as to what "aware of" constitutes here? For example, telephone providers are aware that people are using their service for illicit things but knowing which account / phone call is illicit suddenly makes that all less clear.
Honestly, I'm not quite as bullish on the ability to regulate safety on the internet, considering a not insignificant amount of the privacy violations is promulgated by ad networks collecting information on behalf of intelligence agencies to work around those pesky constitutional provisions. The history of the internet is filled with "make you safer" legislation that achieves questionable results at best.
- vlovich123 4y agoOh goody. > Only if the flagged content is evidently manifestly illegal can such notices give rise to ‘actual knowledge’. According to the text of the Digital Services Act (section 63), “Information should be considered to be manifestly illegal content and notices or complaints should be considered manifestly unfounded where it is evident to a layperson, without any substantive analysis, that the content is illegal or, respectively, that the notices or complaints are unfounded.” So glad we're leaving this up to a vague obviousness standard. Not like copyright and other kinds of illicit content is notoriously hard even for experts to decipher and get right.
- Jensson 4y agoAmerican copyright laws already makes these platforms delete anything that could hint at being copyright infringement, I don't see how this could make things worse.
- einpoklum 4y ago> I don't see how this could make things worse. Believe me, you just lack imagination. Censoring can get soooo much worse.
- vlovich123 4y agoBecause copyright infringement is only a small piece of what this will regulate. Think illicit forms of pornography, terrorism. Moreover, I imagine this will likely apply to community moderation which makes things even trickier. Viewing it from the copyright lens feels extremely narrow.
- VWWHFSfQ 4y agoAnecdotal I used to run a live video streaming website (a la Twitch.tv) for a specific niche of live content. But once the pirates discovered the site they started streaming live sports and other copyrighted content. I started getting DMCAs from MLB, NFL, EPL. All very threatening emails with PDFs of legalese containing screenshots of my (small, niche) website streaming their content. I would always just immediately shut off and ban the streamers that were mentioned. > Is there any clarity as to what "aware of" constitutes here? I became "aware" by the DMCA notice.
- vlovich123 4y agoRunning a large scale service is completely different I think though. My understanding is that most DMCA notices are automated and a good fraction of those not actually valid. Similarly, these systems from the provider side already have automated DMCA takedown mechanisms. The bigger problem is what happens when the counter party files a DMCA counter notice - now you are aware there's potentially infringing content but you're not allowed to take it down. Of course, I'm sure this law takes the DMCA into account. The trickier part though I'm referring to is not DMCA but community moderation. Someone flags a picture of your child bathing naked as child porn. Is the provider now on notice as having been informed? How do they validate the circumstances of the photo to make sure it's yours? These aren't easy questions and looking at it through the DMCA lens is insufficient because this law goes way beyond that. The section 230 lawsuits in front of SCOTUS right now are not dissimilar to what DSA is trying to regulate and yet I don't see extra clarity here.
- a13o 4y agoMy theory is that we are seeing and will continue to see these uh, VLOPs, take an interest in end-to-end encryption because it allows them to not be "aware of" anything users are doing on their platform. "Sorry officer, we just transmit encrypted bits. No moderation squad needed." The story from marketing will be that these companies care about users' privacy. But in this case, what the platforms are doing is trading safety of non-users for privacy of users. The ability to share bits in an unmoderatable ecosystem, where the potential audience is Very Large, will create a blue ocean for underground communities who produce, procure, and curate illegal content. This in turn will endanger yet more people who end up being a non-consenting subject in the illegal content.